James Magner

[Philthy 284]

Although slow, he can lay a tackle ( defensive pressure in our fwd 50 has been non-existent). Might be a good idea to give him a rest in the pocket here and there?

Discuss

[biggestred 5,036]

Happened this year. A lot. Love him But Not a forward pockets left toe.

[jabberwocky 2,301]

I reckon we should pick him up with a rookie pick.

Edited October 5, 2012 by dandeeman

[Little Richard 6,262]

Nah, inside is where he plays best for me. Struggled up forward, get him back in the guts.

[Pates 9,660]

He was much better when feeding the ball out of congestion, as a defensive forward he looked lost IMO.

[King Kunta 97]

Yeah as has been said, he played the second half of the season to limited success. Although he is relatively competent over head, he just lacks any quick sideways movement so isn't dangerous as a small forward. Love his hunger and intensity he just needs to gain some pace and agility if he is to be part of this side moving forward

[Sammy J 3]

He is a good hard player wiith a strong player. Give him a full pre season with a good understanding of what it takes to train at this level and then judge him. every player that makes the afl has talent, you just have to work hard to be a player.

[Pipefitter 2,156]

I think (hoping) that neeld gave him some roles this year to get a feel of the game and will unleash him into the midfield next season. If this isn't the case I'm really not sure why he drafted him. He's hard and a clearance machine.

[DeeZee 7,364]

Just needs another preseason....has a great attitude, and tough as nails.

Another one to make a difference next year.

[monoccular 17,417]

Although slow, he can lay a tackle ( defensive pressure in our fwd 50 has been non-existent). Might be a good idea to give him a rest in the pocket here and there?

Discuss

He was at his best early in the season as a strong bodied mid: Neeld may have 'sacrificed' his game a bit by trying him elsewhere, in what after all was an experimental season.

One shouldn't be surprised to see him back in the midfield after another strong body building preseason.

[John Crow Batty 8,863]

Should only play where his toes are at risk of being butted out by size 16 ruckman boots.

[thaipantsman 180]

Although slow, he can lay a tackle ( defensive pressure in our fwd 50 has been non-existent). Might be a good idea to give him a rest in the pocket here and there?

Discuss

I will discuss. Had him in my supercoach all season. Kept him because because he was there. To be respectful the guy has all the heart in the world but is out of his depth He tried his outmost. Already have Mackenzie. Got to be a limit especially if we want to head north on the ladder.

[thaipantsman 180]

He was at his best early in the season as a strong bodied mid: Neeld may have 'sacrificed' his game a bit by trying him elsewhere, in what after all was an experimental season.

One shouldn't be surprised to see him back in the midfield after another strong body building preseason.

possible Mono. he did play forward and seemed to struggle.

[thaipantsman 180]

He was much better when feeding the ball out of congestion, as a defensive forward he looked lost IMO.

spot on Pates

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Never understood why he was taken out of the middle, seeing him play forward was just weird.

[Gippsland Dee 367]

I think his time would be better spent in the role he played in his first few games when he was getting 30+ possesions, who cares if a few of those are a bit wayward? yes he is a decent tagger but he is a better ball getter!

[monoccular 17,417]

Never understood why he was taken out of the middle, seeing him play forward was just weird.

Possibly a part of the Neeld assessment year - to see what role(s) he is and is not capable of filling.

[thaipantsman 180]

Possibly a part of the Neeld assessment year - to see what role(s) he is and is not capable of filling.

lots of bench warming to come but a handy player.

Possibly a part of the Neeld assessment year - to see what role(s) he is and is not capable of filling.

apparently Neeld game him the strap

[Steamin Demon 392]

Guts and guts only.

[Je Roos Salem 661]

He went from a ball winning machine in the first 2 rounds (and the preseason) to a defensive midfielder/forward to a sub and then to out of the team. I think Neeld definitely made a mistake in where he placed him. Should've freed him up a lot more

[spirit of norm smith 16,346]

In the guts only ... not up fwd. Poor call by Neeld. Magner is tough and shows how he can add value at stoppages.

[angrydee 842]

Tired badly in his first season. Expect a lot more guts time in 2013

[Guest neeldstherealdeal]

Deserves another crack but looked lost in the second half of the season and was found seriously wanting in terms of skill level required.

With injection of midfield class from draft and a trade or two I can't see him playing too many senior games next season.

[picket fence 17,103]

To slow and skills not up to it.

Who could forget his hopelessly inept effort in being 30 metres out from goal on a set shot and ... failing to make the distance!

Yes hard as nails but in this quickening game lack of pace and skills are telling! A poor man's Valenti and look where he is now!

[Chook 15,012]

To slow and skills not up to it.

Who could forget his hopelessly inept effort in being 30 metres out from goal on a set shot and ... failing to make the distance!

Yes hard as nails but in this quickening game lack of pace and skills are telling! A poor man's Valenti and look where he is now!

That was actually a goal. Too bad the third umpire left his courage in the carpark (to coin a phrase). Edited October 6, 2012 by Chook