The Grand Final Thread

[Sir Why You Little 36,603]

Yes i hope the Coach watches that GF a couple of times.

The real stuff for him & our club starts on monday.

We must recruit some players who are ready to go round 1.

New blood who couldn't get regular games at other clubs for reasons out of their control.

Yes we do need kids. But we need experience more.

2013 the respect of the MFC must begin. At present we have none.

But Norm now watches over his MCG.

[pitmaster 3,443]

Comiserations to the umps; they gave it their best but couldn't get over the line.

They were lucky Swans won.

If Hawks won that free kick count would have been a controversy.

[Dreamin' Demon 10]

The next best feeling after a Demons, win is a dawks grand final loss. Absolutely hate that team with a passion & at the moment I'll cherish the night. Might even watch the replay.

[Sir Why You Little 36,603]

The next best feeling after a Demons, win is a dawks grand final loss. Absolutely hate that team with a passion & at the moment I'll cherish the night. Might even watch the replay.

it was good ripping in to Hawks supporters today.

They expected that cup all year.

My facebook page has gone feral. Love it.

[Sir Why You Little 36,603]

Apparently Goodes did his PCL today. I doubt he will care for a while after kicking that late goal.

Never say die.

[Biffen 12,807]

it was good ripping in to Hawks supporters today.

They expected that cup all year.

My facebook page has gone feral. Love it.

Seems funny that the shite and wee didn't see it coming.

I hate them all-worse than the Filth.

Lets hope a spiral down the ladder follows.

Edited September 29, 2012 by Biffen

[IRW 1,377]

it was good ripping in to Hawks supporters today.

They expected that cup all year.

My facebook page has gone feral. Love it.

The only thing wrong with today was that I wasnt surrounded by the usual mob of arrogant Hawks supporters so I could rub it in...at the very end if the truth be known.

My son had to tell me to stop looking around.."there arent any here,just watch the game".

The place was full of fellows who had brought their wives for their one game of the year.

[Sir Why You Little 36,603]

The only thing wrong with today was that I wasnt surrounded by the usual mob of arrogant Hawks supporters so I could rub it in...at the very end if the truth be known.

My son had to tell me to stop looking around.."there arent any here,just watch the game".

The place was full of fellows who had brought their wives for their one game of the year.

MCC Reserve?

[IRW 1,377]

Yes i hope the Coach watches that GF a couple of times.

The real stuff for him & our club starts on monday.

We must recruit some players who are ready to go round 1.

New blood who couldn't get regular games at other clubs for reasons out of their control.

Yes we do need kids. But we need experience more.

2013 the respect of the MFC must begin. At present we have none.

But Norm now watches over his MCG.

Its the players who need to watch the game.Neeld has seen the Pies play committed football for years.

If they were in town and werent there they are a disgrace.

Can you imagine Watts playing loose down back today? Even when he was 20 metres back Gibson looked dangerous, not like he was waiting for a free ride on a reality bus.

[IRW 1,377]

MCC Reserve?

Its the only place I'm 'brave' enough to abuse the 'enemy'.

Pathetic I know, but true.

[Sir Why You Little 36,603]

Its the players who need to watch the game.Neeld has seen the Pies play committed football for years.

If they were in town and werent there they are a disgrace.

Can you imagine Watts playing loose down back today? Even when he was 20 metres back Gibson looked dangerous, not like he was waiting for a free ride on a reality bus.

point taken & i do agree, but it is Neeld who must mould this list. He must identify the talent. Because we do need some results next year.

But yes i hope the boys were watching & not scared by it.

Today was real footy, as most Grannies are.

[Brian Wilson 331]

I'm sounding like a broken record but don't forget they have almost just under one million dollars more per year to spend on players.

I'll say it again, they have recruited and drafted very well but I don't get excited by it when they have an unfair advantage.

True... But they are up against the ridiculous home ground advantage that Melbourne teams have when the GF is played at the MCG. It's a horribly unpopular thing to say but I think that it's time for the national game's big event to lose its Melbourne bias.

Besides, I lost patience for this argument when Eddie bleated about it while losing to the Lions (who waited for their time longer than us).

And for the record, I'll go anywhere to watch MFC play in a GF.

[IRW 1,377]

point taken & i do agree, but it is Neeld who must mould this list. He must identify the talent. Because we do need some results next year.

But yes i hope the boys were watching & not scared by it.

Today was real footy, as most Grannies are.

I'm pretty certain Neeld was at the ground somewhere and that all the Assistants were watching it as well.

[Sir Why You Little 36,603]

I'm pretty certain Neeld was at the ground somewhere and that all the Assistants were watching it as well.

yes. I was interested today at the pub i was in, that everybody has absolutely no time or respect for the MFC when i mentioned who i followed.

We are on our own. Which maybe a good thing.

[monoccular 17,313]

My Martin Luther King moment: I had a dream today - a guy, number 10 named Morton - two vital goals and some important heavy lifting in a winning GF side. Then I woke up!

Edited September 29, 2012 by monoccular

[monoccular 17,313]

True... But they are up against the ridiculous home ground advantage that Melbourne teams have when the GF is played at the MCG. It's a horribly unpopular thing to say but I think that it's time for the national game's big event to lose its Melbourne bias.

Besides, I lost patience for this argument when Eddie bleated about it while losing to the Lions (who waited for their time longer than us).

And for the record, I'll go anywhere to watch MFC play in a GF.

Trouble is, BW - the GF doesn't just get set up in the week after the PFs; it takes months. So if not at the G, where the greatest number of teams play and where the greatest number of spectators can fit in, (and where the Dees have their ancestral home) then how do you decide where?

You may argue for the city of the reigning premiers, but say for example that Sydney don't even make the top 4 next year, then HM would attend a game at Homebush?

[Sir Why You Little 36,603]

The GF won't move. The interstate clubs have a very good record on GF day.

I was suprised when i looked it up a while ago.

[Brian Wilson 331]

Trouble is, BW - the GF doesn't just get set up in the week after the PFs; it takes months. So if not at the G, where the greatest number of teams play and where the greatest number of spectators can fit in, (and where the Dees have their ancestral home) then how do you decide where?

You may argue for the city of the reigning premiers, but say for example that Sydney don't even make the top 4 next year, then HM would attend a game at Homebush?

The prelim finals get set up in the week after the semi finals, so it should be possible for the GF to be set up in the week following the GF. All of the extraneous pieces of the GF get in the way of the actual game. It might even allow for more members of the relevant clubs to attend.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

The biggest problem with the salary cap has only just begun, Free Agency.

If they aren't a top four team each year for now on their List Manager should be shot.

Edited September 29, 2012 by Clint Bizkit

[Sir Why You Little 36,603]

The biggest problem with the salary cap has only just begun, Free Agency.

If they aren't a top four team each year for now one their List Manager should be shot.

is the 10% advantage locked in infinitum? Or is it dropping each year?

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

is the 10% advantage locked in infinitum? Or is it dropping each year?

As far as I know it's permanent (happy to be corrected on this).

Like I said, the justification is the cost of living, but that would mean Adelaide teams should have a lower salary cap.

[Sir Why You Little 36,603]

As far as I know it's permanent (happy to be corrected on this).

Like I said, the justification is the cost of living, but that would mean Adelaide teams should have a lower salary cap.

yes it is an interesting one.

But we just have to get better. No point bringing up excuses.

We have done too much of that.

[skills32 229]

Did Neville Jettas mum put in a word for Lewis after Neville was drafted?

Yes and she should be on our recruiting panel.

Recruiting......... nobody knows!

but she knows.

Words to the effect of ........'but there is a better one coming'

OMG; our recruiters were over paid nobodies and that is one reason why.

[skills32 229]

They were lucky Swans won.

If Hawks won that free kick count would have been a controversy.

Yes and It wasn't so much the free kick count as the number of missed frees that the Swans didn't get.

Also I see that the Dawks have the privilege of being allowed to flick pass and even throw the ball.

GFC!!!

the AFL are going to have to allow umpire bashing now or there will be a revolution.

Edited September 29, 2012 by skills32

[rhaz 342]

Cant believe the Swans won. They won't go down as a "great team" in history, but to be honest this season was a bit lacking in 'great teams'.