I give up!

[stormndemon 1]

High intensity needed: Neeld

By Matt Burgan 11:34 AM

Sun 08 Apr, 2012

COACH Mark Neeld says his side’s immediate challenge is to play “high, intense footy for longer than a half”.

Hello! WTF has he been up to for the past 6 months!

[ex52k2 238]

In answer to those people who think the AGM is a joke, and the hard questions wont get answered. I have a suggestion go along and ask them, you might be suprised. After all its very hard for the board to answer questions that havnt been asked!

There were only two people who got up and asked questions, I know, I was one of them. I asked the question regarding FOJ .sponsorship.

You will never find out what you want to know if you dont ask. Its an old method but it works for me!

[Sir Why You Little 37,127]

In answer to those people who think the AGM is a joke, and the hard questions wont get answered. I have a suggestion go along and ask them, you might be suprised. After all its very hard for the board to answer questions that havnt been asked!

There were only two people who got up and asked questions, I know, I was one of them. I asked the question regarding FOJ .sponsorship.

You will never find out what you want to know if you dont ask. Its an old method but it works for me!

Did you get an answer?

[Biffen 12,947]

Dear Big Jim-you are a disgrace to the moniker-and you are verging on illiteracy .

Loyalty is not something you take on when times are good .

Stormin- your posts are dull and obvious.Besides"sack the coach ,sack the ceo ,sack everyone ",try to offer a way to improve with the men we have on and off the field.

With supporters like you guys ,who needs enemies?

Edited April 9, 2012 by Biffen

[Dee Fan 3,247]

We've become unwatchable. A VFL side masquerading as an AFL team. Much more of this garbage and the club is rooted. Next draft is the most important in the club's history.

Unfortunately when you see the best player in our side over the last two weeks is a VFL player, you are probably not far away from the truth.

It's shameful that we've had all these early draft picks, but some mature aged recruit out of left field is seemingly better than all of them.

[Biffen 12,947]

Please read the quote by 3183 Dee on the other thread .Supporters are supposed to lift the team when they are down .Not drag it into the mud.

[ex52k2 238]

Sort of, they answered that the signing was nearly done and they were waiting for the final signature, just crossing the ttttts.

But my real point is GO AND ASK. dont just sit in front of a keyboard and bleat!

[Sir Why You Little 37,127]

Sort of, they answered that the signing was nearly done and they were waiting for the final signature, just crossing the ttttts.

But my real point is GO AND ASK. dont just sit in front of a keyboard and bleat!

I agree 100% but i can sympathize to a degree that supporters deserve to know what is really going on.

[jabberwocky 2,301]

Unfortunately when you see the best player in our side over the last two weeks is a VFL player, you are probably not far away from the truth.

That's one way of looking at it...

[Dee Fan 3,247]

That's one way of looking at it...

And the other is....?

[jabberwocky 2,301]

And the other is....?

That we have recruited a bloody good player that 17 other teams would love to have.

Lets be serious now, this has been a nightmare of a start to our season. But lets let the negatives be negatives and let the positives, as few as they are.. be positives.

Edited April 9, 2012 by dandeeman

[Pipefitter 2,168]

Im close to giving up. I watched half of the eagles match then decided to go the MCG to watch the tigers. At least they have a crack. Watching us is disturbing. To think this was the year we were supposed to be challenging for the 8. We have 2 new teams in the league and we will be challenging them for the wooden spoon. Is it almost time for the AFL to step in and demand answers? Why aren't we progressing? Do the people we have in charge of the club have any idea? Our last recruiting officer was a fraud, and cameron wasn't much better. Our last 10 years of drafting has been an example of how not to build a list. I look at our list and shake my head. There is not a lot to be excited about. And not much improvement to come.

Richmond have been able to ride the wave of disappointment, but we just don't have that sort of blue collar support. Another 2-3 years of this and all the work Jim did will be in vain. We won't exist.

This is about the most pessimistic I've ever been about the club. We are in some serious trouble.

[Guest Dr Who]

Sadly this thread says it all. Its quite disturbing when the "passionate" want to give up - but some have been warning about this "attitude" for some time now.

[BIG JIM 508]

Have you put your name up for a board spot? Or are you just comfortable sitting at your desk banging every person at the club who is working hard. If you don't like it, chalenge and put yourself up.

And please use paras as it hurts my eyes reading your long drawn out crap.

To be honest I CBF getting involved with you. You asked some questions, I answered some.

I never said your wrong, questioned your loyalty or that you should be quiet.

Similar to that I'm not going to raise elements of your arguement such as your hypothetical scenario as a rebuttle to a logical solution, your view that AGMs are a joke - worrying that just attending (which I assume you haven't, similar to you not even calling the club) would have answered most of your questions and saved face from trolling on threads but almost not as worrying as your grammatical errors... Or that you just successfully buzz killed the muppets

Again I'm not going to say anything - keep trolling on!

Thanks muppets i will keep posting my thoughts if you dont like well dont read and as for my grammer well did get kick out of school when i was young so im a bit like a cave man with spelling but my passion for my club is what matters to me. So see you at the games if you go because i might sound angry but i always go every week because i love the demons. But i hate this board and CEO right now cheers.

[BIG JIM 508]

Dear Big Jim-you are a disgrace to the moniker-and you are verging on illiteracy .

Loyalty is not something you take on when times are good .

Stormin- your posts are dull and obvious.Besides"sack the coach ,sack the ceo ,sack everyone ",try to offer a way to improve with the men we have on and off the field.

With supporters like you guys ,who needs enemies?

As a memeber and life time demon fan i will keep posting my thought once again if you dont like dont read when you see my name Biffen and love the photo mate cheers

[Diablo Deemon 220]

The rank and file are offered this chestnut as an excuse

source: http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/7415/newsid/132626/default.aspx

....It must be remembered - and reinforced - that Melbourne entered 2012, as one of four AFL teams, along with Greater Western Sydney, Gold Coast Suns and Richmond, to be in the bottom five clubs for fewest AFL matches played and list youthfulness combined....The development and progression of a team can’t be transformed over night....

[Return to Glory 8,448]

Cheer up, at least it's great to see the smugs at Hawthorn get done.

[Guest Dr Who]

The development and progression of a team can’t be transformed over night.

Critical line. Sadly we all must just wait.

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

It pains me to read some peoples passion fade away on this thread. By wednesday I am optimistic about the next week and Guess what? I still am. I believe we will beat the tigers next week and we will against the dogs and the saints as well. I won't comment on Schwab because I drive a truck and know bugger all about business,advertising and sponsorships. Go Dees!

[Real Demon 232]

The problem is that a whole number of key events lead supoorters to believe that we were inching closer and closer to a flag.

Debt being wiped out

New facilities

A raft of high draft picks

Getting a new improved coaching team from successful clubs

Record membership

Etc etc

We've only just started to resemble a competent club.

Schwab's "Base Camp" analogy seems right on the money.............the real work starts now!

[Sir Why You Little 37,127]

The rank and file are offered this chestnut as an excuse

source: http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/7415/newsid/132626/default.aspx

How nice. I have read that for 4 years now...whilst other clubs accelerate by.

I heard it said today on Radio that Hawthorn had 7 players in todays side who had played under 30 games. They learn quick over there.

Next time we recruit for a bunch of kids can we recruit a teacher as well...example Luke Ball. Who was under our nose, and we baulked.

[Dee Dee Ramone 89]

It pains me to read some peoples passion fade away on this thread. By wednesday I am optimistic about the next week and Guess what? I still am. I believe we will beat the tigers next week and we will against the dogs and the saints as well. I won't comment on Schwab because I drive a truck and know bugger all about business,advertising and sponsorships. Go Dees!

Love your enthusiasm Cowboy. Unfortunately I do not share your level optimism but I LOVE MELBOURNE FC. I do have faith in our club's board and CEO.....they know more about football & running football clubs than I and every poster on this site.

Great posts Redleg, Jordie Tackles and Biffen, keep the passion.

[old dee 23,872]

The problem is that a whole number of key events lead supoorters to believe that we were inching closer and closer to a flag.

Debt being wiped out

New facilities

A raft of high draft picks

Getting a new improved coaching team from successful clubs

Record membership

Etc etc

We've only just started to resemble a competent club.

Schwab's "Base Camp" analogy seems right on the money.............the real work starts now!

RD not from where i sit.

A list that is poor

belted by the side that finished third last in 2011

No major sponsors

No balls to sue Thomas and Channel 9

Very likely finish between last and third last.

Does not look like a competent club to me.

Looks no better than the sides that have been in the competition of One year and 2 games

[Hells Gates 505]

I may be angry, annoyed, upset, frustrated & disgusted with on field performance and everything else that comes everyday being a Dee's supporter, but NO WAY am I prepared to "give up" like this thread says.

My best mate said to me before he passed away - "A winner never quits & a quitter never wins". So bloody true. Will take that memory to the grave with me.

[old dee 23,872]

I may be angry, annoyed, upset, frustrated & disgusted with on field performance and everything else that comes everyday being a Dee's supporter, but NO WAY am I prepared to "give up" like this thread says.

My best mate said to me before he passed away - "A winner never quits & a quitter never wins". So bloody true. Will take that memory to the grave with me.

Unfortunately HG attitude is not enough.

Even though you battle on in the end the enormity of the task overwhelms you.

I fear that is what faces the MFC