2011 TRADES DISCUSSION

[Grandson of a gun 276]

Warnock wanting out could be good for us in that if there is no other ready made key position defender out there (a la Lake) who is looking for a new home then his price goes up a bit.

I believe Bate will at the least be offered up because we have too many of a similar type and he isn't mobile enough down forward (and nor is he the elite midfielder we need even though he has gone ok in there for Casey and in Round 24).

I can also see Maric being off loaded.

The question is two fold- does anyone want our players and will these players go there?

I can see one or two Vic clubs perhaps taking a nibble at Warnock however as i have stated on another thread, his greatest currency mght be with GWS. He is virtually assured of a game every week, will see plenty of the ball and they get a big strong body to help out the young kids. On the flip side, if Melbourne can package him with one of the compensation picks for O'Meara then i am all for it.

After all, we do need to build that elite midfield...

Don't know what interest there would be in Bate or Maric but we won't get much for them. They may be good for a couple of pick upgrades which can then be packaged together to trade for a player Neeld thinks we might need as an interim filler until the kids come on?

[dee-luded 2,959]

Warnock wanting out could be good for us in that if there is no other ready made key position defender out there (a la Lake) who is looking for a new home then his price goes up a bit.

I believe Bate will at the least be offered up because we have too many of a similar type and he isn't mobile enough down forward (and nor is he the elite midfielder we need even though he has gone ok in there for Casey and in Round 24).

I can also see Maric being off loaded.

The question is two fold- does anyone want our players and will these players go there?

I can see one or two Vic clubs perhaps taking a nibble at Warnock however as i have stated on another thread, his greatest currency mght be with GWS. He is virtually assured of a game every week, will see plenty of the ball and they get a big strong body to help out the young kids. On the flip side, if Melbourne can package him with one of the compensation picks for O'Meara then i am all for it.

After all, we do need to build that elite midfield...

Don't know what interest there would be in Bate or Maric but we won't get much for them. They may be good for a couple of pick upgrades which can then be packaged together to trade for a player Neeld thinks we might need as an interim filler until the kids come on?

Bater has changed parts of his game, and is attacking the ball differently, and more ferociously.

[Roger Mellie 3,991]

I know he's contracted, but I would be extremely happy if Dunn was off our list by hook or by crook.

The guy is a dead set fraud

[The Chazz 4,077]

Yep, and I wouldn't be surprised to see us trade one, either this or next year.

So I'd like to rookie another 'young long term ruck', this Year, who can spend 2012 in the Casey 2nds.

Trade one what?

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

When is the delist list completed?

[Roost It 1,434]

Time to trade Jamar. He's a top 10 pick in this years draft possibly higher. If we want some serious quality coming in we have to offer quality. We could have virtually anyone who wanted a trade with Jamar. Clubs would join the cue. The club needs to be bold.

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

Not technically a trade/delisting issue, but according to todays Age, Emma Quayle believes highly touted Casey defender Tim Mohr is likely to be one of the players GWS take as a pre-listed player (ie. They get a free hit on guys not on lists who have previously nominated for drafts, think Krakouer, Mzungu last year).

Is a BIG unit and has an AFL ready bod. Haven't seen enough of him to know what he offers though.

You seen much of him Dave?

[Prof 15]

Time to trade Jamar. He's a top 10 pick in this years draft possibly higher. If we want some serious quality coming in we have to offer quality. We could have virtually anyone who wanted a trade with Jamar. Clubs would join the cue. The club needs to be bold.

The quickest way to ruin a footy club would be to give the bullet to "good, hard working, loyal" players. Is Jamar to be traded to a billiards club or another footy club?

[Harrisonrules 273]

Without wanting to criticize any of our players, who do you expect will be on the trade table/delisted over the next few weeks? (more interested in discussing who we think will be moved on, than any disrespectful pots at players we think deserve to go but we know will stay please)

As and example, IMO I expect either Bate or Dunn are likely to be moved on, but not both. Both can fill similar roles, but neither are in our best 22. Keeping one for back up to Pettard, Jurrah, Watts, Green if injured is ideal, but the second would be superfluous. Bate played a few good games in early 2009 (or 10...it's a blur) before being injured, and would be great if could get that form back. Dunn showed some good passion this year, and some diversity in the roles he can play. Thoughts?

Who else to we expect to see departing?

Moving on would mean de-listing, trading is a very inprecise activity. I doubt whether the club would have initially planned to get rid of Cheney last year, but open discussion can lead to the unexpected. To delist Bate and Dunne is a risk given our young list, to trade depends on whether anyone wants someone supporters deem no good at Melbourne for maybe pick 60. Does that offer a better option than experience. What would we want to give up for a quality player, pick 12? Otherwise forget it.

[Little Goffy 14,463]

Well, combining my interest in (hmm.... let's just say curiousity about) Lachlan Hansen, and the fact that I'm also well over Dunn, I think it would be great if we could arrange for Dunn and Brent Harvey to play alongside eachother at the 'Roos. They sure do get along.

[east gippsland demon 7]

Time to trade Jamar. He's a top 10 pick in this years draft possibly higher. If we want some serious quality coming in we have to offer quality. We could have virtually anyone who wanted a trade with Jamar. Clubs would join the cue. The club needs to be bold.

your clearly taking the p!ss??? I hope so for your sake....

Edited September 22, 2011 by High Tower

[The Big Ticket 94]

Well, combining my interest in (hmm.... let's just say curiousity about) Lachlan Hansen, and the fact that I'm also well over Dunn, I think it would be great if we could arrange for Dunn and Brent Harvey to play alongside eachother at the 'Roos. They sure do get along.

I've watched Hansen closely this year and quiet frankly, I wouldn't touch him with a 10 foot pole. He's soft, has below average footy IQ, terrible decision maker and he's hopeless by foot. He's a hell of a lot more frustrating to watch than Dunn too.

We can do better than going after Norf's damaged goods.

[Viney Vidi Vici 145]

Who is out of contract for us? at least on this forum, it seems like bate and dunn's names are the only ones being brought up. Neeld surely is going to freshen up the list more than that.

[rpfc 28,266]

Who is out of contract for us? at least on this forum, it seems like bate and dunn's names are the only ones being brought up. Neeld surely is going to freshen up the list more than that.

Who do you think should be in the gun?

Bate, Dunn, Warnock, Maric, Batram, MacDonald, Wonaeamirri, and Spencer are those that I believe are in trouble of losing their spot on the senior list.

Warnock and Maric are in danger of deletion.

Bate, Dunn, Batram, and Spencer are/or will be surplus soon (tough one with Batram - he is a committed player with an excellent work ethic) and may be traded.

If trades don't eventuate I can see the club trying to get some wiggle room by putting Wonna on the Rookie List.

[The Chazz 4,077]

Who do you think should be in the gun?

Bate, Dunn, Warnock, Maric, Batram, MacDonald, Wonaeamirri, and Spencer are those that I believe are in trouble of losing their spot on the senior list.

Warnock and Maric are in danger of deletion.

Bate, Dunn, Batram, and Spencer are/or will be surplus soon (tough one with Batram - he is a committed player with an excellent work ethic) and may be traded.

If trades don't eventuate I can see the club trying to get some wiggle room by putting Wonna on the Rookie List.

Geez I feel sorry for Barty. He cops so much sh!t on this site, and like Jones, I think it is quite unfair. He is one of the best taggers on our list, and would take a couple of bloody good players to make him surplus.

[beelzebub 23,313]

................................

If trades don't eventuate I can see the club trying to get some wiggle room by putting Wonna on the Rookie List.

ive select this bit of your quote as it struck me as a sort of "D'oh" . This should and ought to be the way to go. There needs to be a reality of where both parties are at and acts of good faith by both. I think all things considered it might be a slightly rich impost to just give Aussie a senior spot willy nilly. Not because hes incapable as his plainly is ( uninjured) but because it might be somewhat unfair to another kid.

Aussie could easily break back into the seniors with dedication and application but his head has to be in the right place and theres no guaranteee of that ( just being horriby realisitc )

The Rookie list is a fair path back imho

[rpfc 28,266]

Geez I feel sorry for Barty. He cops so much sh!t on this site, and like Jones, I think it is quite unfair. He is one of the best taggers on our list, and would take a couple of bloody good players to make him surplus.

I guess my grave assessment can be considered 'sh!t.'

He is all heart, and I love his attack on the footy and the man.

But he struggles to hit targets and doesn't realise his limitations.

He can become an effective role player, but if Neeld cannot turn him into a disciplined role player who is happy getting more tackles than touches, then he will find it difficult to get a game.

[mordja 187]

Geez I feel sorry for Barty. He cops so much sh!t on this site, and like Jones, I think it is quite unfair. He is one of the best taggers on our list, and would take a couple of bloody good players to make him surplus.

I like Bartram's work ethic as well. But it is quite obvious that being the best anything on our list, is not sufficient.

[beelzebub 23,313]

I dont think anyone really has it in for Barty, if 'only' he didnt murder the ball !! He doesnt need to be a magician with it to be useful and effective he just needs to give it off asap to someone who knws what to do with in. As a negator/link man he has a lot of upside....if he can get that link thing happening...otherwise hes just another NQR...life's harsh sometimes hey !!

[btdemon 482]

Gee, Chris Dawes didn't really impress me tonight. I also learnt that the most goals he has kicked in a game this year is three. I don't know if he is worth chasing too hard.

[Old Man Rivers 326]

Gee, Chris Dawes didn't really impress me tonight. I also learnt that the most goals he has kicked in a game this year is three. I don't know if he is worth chasing too hard.

Yeah - He was terrible

He just kicked 3 in The Preliminary & crashed the pack open nearly every time the ball went forward for The Filth tonight.

Why would we need him?

Edited September 23, 2011 by Old Man Rivers

[Shwarmas 26]

Chris Dawes is exactly the player that we need.

He presented all night, crashed every pack, tackled ferociously, and threw his body at the ball and player at every opportunity...and kicked three goals.

He is exactly the player that we need. We should be doing everything in our power to get him.

[Old Man Rivers 326]

Chris Dawes is exactly the player that we need.

He presented all night, crashed every pack, tackled ferociously, and threw his body at the ball and player at every opportunity...and kicked three goals.

He is exactly the player that we need. We should be doing everything in our power to get him.

Very Very wise first Post Shwarmas

Welcome to the forum, always good to have a little common sense onboard.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Trade one what?

The post was about rucks.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Time to trade Jamar. He's a top 10 pick in this years draft possibly higher. If we want some serious quality coming in we have to offer quality. We could have virtually anyone who wanted a trade with Jamar. Clubs would join the cue. The club needs to be bold.

GWS/ POWER/ HAWKS/ CATS/ PIES/ BOMBERS/ There could be some interest within this group, & some can Pay.