On 10/05/2011 at 11:54, Roost It said:

That was me. When I typed it I thought, shite, I should delete this but it was to late, the universe had heard me and the rest is history.

Roost It, are we able to eject you from the supporter's club?

  On 10/05/2011 at 11:50, Deeoldfart said:

That's the spirit MM. Big Jimma will regard these setbacks as an important challenge for our players and coaching staff, and I reckon we should all take a leaf out of that book. If we continue to play in the vein of last Sunday the next month has some winnable games.

Well said ! Ok we may not win the majority of the tapouts, so then we shark it, and give the same effort as shown against the crows.

  On 10/05/2011 at 11:53, Rogue said:

Wow, terrible. I've said he's our most important, because aside from him our ruck stocks are pretty poor.

Terrible timing for Spencer, who presumably would have had a crack at the big time.

We'd want to see Campbell come into the side ASAP, but we might need to go with Martin and Newton for now.

EDIT: North are pretty tall and so are Essendon.

Well, time for Martin to shine.

Jamar, Spencer and I believe Fitzy too has an injury (did I read that right ?) Gawn may get a seniors gig at Casey, good luck to him. It situations like these that test clubs from time to time. And now it's time for Martin & Moloney to synergise.

Carlton are also tall. Or will be with Kreuzer returning soon.

I think this is all Bailey's fault. If he hadnt put grimes into the middle he wouldnt have got injured, if jamar hadn't been playin so much in the ruck then he wouldn't have got injured, if he hadn't made them go harder with their tackling then trengrove wouldn't have been suspended and if he had been playing Spencer in the seniors then he wouldn't have got injured in the twos.

He has to go now, it's all his fault!

  On 10/05/2011 at 12:04, Age said:

I think this is all Bailey's fault. If he hadnt put grimes into the middle he wouldnt have got injured, if jamar hadn't been playin so much in the ruck then he wouldn't have got injured, if he hadn't made them go harder with their tackling then trengrove wouldn't have been suspended and if he had been playing Spencer in the seniors then he wouldn't have got injured in the twos.

He has to go now, it's all his fault!

Sounds right to me

I'm coming around to the majority opinion.

Sorry I've been so slow to see the light .....

I still can't find any confirmation of this (checked AFL, MFC, newspapers, google etc)

that is strange as this is big news

  On 10/05/2011 at 11:56, Striker475 said:

Roost It, are we able to eject you from the supporter's club?

I guess I deserve 3 weeks for that!

  On 10/05/2011 at 12:03, High Tower said:

Well, time for Martin to shine.

Jamar, Spencer and I believe Fitzy too has an injury (did I read that right ?) Gawn may get a seniors gig at Casey, good luck to him. It situations like these that test clubs from time to time. And now it's time for Martin & Moloney to synergise.

Carlton are also tall. Or will be with Kreuzer returning soon.

Well we could call on both Martin and Newton, bit IMO we need some experience in there. Maybe we bring in Campbell, even if he's not 'matchfit', together with both Martin and Newton. We neeed at least one giant, plus we need that experience.. Yeah, thats the other thing, he's gone for a month. So we have to plan for that timeframe.

Lets see what we got for a ticker. No need to worry about jocks creeping up our backsides anymore. Jack and Jamar will be back soon. Bring on North.

Martin or Juice?

or both?

Weird how we lose Jamar/Spencer/Fitzy in the same damn week. Our ruck stocks looked invincible.........realty bites.

Gawn isn't ready. They will call up Campbell before Gawn I would think.

channel the spirit of stynesy and put it into big stef martin, lets get on it

  On 10/05/2011 at 10:58, Red and Blue Flame said:

Gawn Not ready. Martin and Newton will come in to cover for Jamar. Martin also as a defensive cover as Roos will go tall.

Agreed. In comes Martin and Newton to try to be flexible ruckman

And i thought the Budget was tough

  On 10/05/2011 at 10:52, Nasher said:

The biggest thing I'm disappointed about is that this would've been an absolutely golden opportunity to see what big Jake is made of as first ruck. Not to be.

He looked good to me at Casey 10 or so days ago. Very raw still but was the most dominant ruckman on the ground for my mind. Four weeks in the ones would have done him the world of good

  On 10/05/2011 at 12:11, daisycutter said:

I still can't find any confirmation of this (checked AFL, MFC, newspapers, google etc)

that is strange as this is big news

There doesn't seem to be any confirmation out there as yet Daisy.....

That being said I doubt very much if Sheahan would announce something so important if he didn't have his facts right

  On 10/05/2011 at 12:11, daisycutter said:

I still can't find any confirmation of this (checked AFL, MFC, newspapers, google etc)

that is strange as this is big news

Agreed.

So denial it is, for now.

This is another challenge. You just lost your AA ruckman who has meagre backup, and two of your best young kids.

The only thing you can take from it is that it opens a window for 3 other blokes.

Time for everyone to respond, again.

  On 10/05/2011 at 12:20, Wrathchild said:

Martin or Juice?

or both?

Weird how we lose Jamar/Spencer/Fitzy in the same damn week. Our ruck stocks looked invincible.........realty bites.

Gawn isn't ready. They will call up Campbell before Gawn I would think.

I'd play the 3 of them. Plonk Campbell in the forward pocket, to play deep, with 2 (5 minute) stints a Qtr in the ruck.

Play Martin as the 2nd ruck, can go back if needed. Play Newton from the Goal square roaming the forward half, and going 3rd man up around the place.

Jones in to the Mids to play a role. Bail back to the wing, or to Harvey. Bring in McDonald to the back flank..

we are gawn

If you took out of Collingwood this week(as yard stick) Jolly(jamar), Wood(spencer), Maxwell (grimes),Ball( Mckenzie ), Beams(scully)

Sidebottom)(Trengove (Scully and trengove are not swan, pendelbury class yet) this week vs cats they would struggle their foward structure would be stuffed, playing cloke and dawes as rucks

I can't believe it.

We win after playing some great football, in a fantastic response to a terrible performance one week earlier.

Then...

Grimes does his navicular, out for the year.

Trengove cops a ridiculous suspension, out for three.

Spencer does his ACL, which didn't seem so bad, until Jamar did his PCL.

Brilliant.

  On 10/05/2011 at 12:59, titan_uranus said:

I can't believe it.

We win after playing some great football, in a fantastic response to a terrible performance one week earlier.

Then...

Grimes does his navicular, out for the year.

Trengove cops a ridiculous suspension, out for three.

Spencer does his ACL, which didn't seem so bad, until Jamar did his PCL.

Brilliant.

I thought our non-existent injury list couldn't last for long :-(

all is not lost if we dont panic and we are smart. I think when you go in with a weaker ruck the pressure can come onto the more dominant ruck if you read their taps. Hawthorn have had weak rucks and historically have been able to combat that by basically following the opposition ruckman. Having Jamar did not help us against them.

Having said that, are we smart enough to rove to the opposition ?

another point, out investment in rucks stocks has not been too bad, with probably Gawn the one we have highest hopes for after Jamar. It's just now the timing is bad, but it was always a distinct possiblity Jamar could get injured and in the very game we did not take a second ruck....hmmmmm.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/two-game-ban-for-melbournes-jack-trengove/story-e6frf9jf-1226052693677

martin has injury cloud aswell, oh goodness

  On 10/05/2011 at 13:41, Mad_Melbourne said:

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/two-game-ban-for-melbournes-jack-trengove/story-e6frf9jf-1226052693677

martin has injury cloud aswell, oh goodness

Stynes in for Jamar!!

Article refers to Martin hurting his ribs. I'd say unless he's ruptured a kidney he'll be in!! I remember Dermy wearing that stupid vest for the Pies when he had same. Ended up ripping it off half way through game i think lol. Anyone got his number?

Host of the Fox Footy clip referred to JT as Drac! DRACULA Trengove ... A real Demon of the night! Mwahaha!

  On 10/05/2011 at 13:41, Mad_Melbourne said:

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/two-game-ban-for-melbournes-jack-trengove/story-e6frf9jf-1226052693677

martin has injury cloud aswell, oh goodness

[grimaces]

...that leaves Newton.