We've got the list. I've seen enough to know that.

Do we have the coach???

No f-ing way.

For my thoughts on the game I direct you to this clip

http://www.facebook.com/home.php?sk=group_221875624493237

I hate reactionary garbage on Demonland but this game has really just done it for me.

There are no valid excuses for losing a game mentally, physically and statistically in the first 5 minutes of a match, against last year's wooden spooners no less.

Yep. I tried so hard to follow him with blind faith. I believed the party line but we have no heart. None. Either we get rid of 22+ players or we sack the coach and start again and I couldn't put up with another @#$%ing rebuild.

James McDonald was FORCED to leave, now it's baileys turn.

I have just joined that 'Sack Dean Bailey' facebook group...woeful display this evening

I reckon we could even get a Coach fund going. Some say we can't afford a TOP TOP line coach, well we did DD, what about the NCFF (New Coach Fighting Fund) I don't even have a job atm, but I'll contribute whatever I have got

We cant afford to not get a top coach.

Sorry Hannabal, did I give an opinion on the coaching situation? I merely gave an opinion on this thread.

Is that stating the obvious enough for you? Maybe I'll rephrase it as a statement, rather than a rhetorical question, if that makes it more obvious.

James McDonald was FORCED to leave, now it's baileys turn.

He was 34 and it was the right decision. In fact, Bailey has been sensational for our list management.

He's a great manager, or second in command, but he's not a great senior coach. Mind you, he's got terrible leaders at his disposal. Davey, Moloney, Sylvia, Green are simply not A graders.

Todd Viney, seriously could they do any worse? Bailey has nothing Viney was there in 08 with the hawks.

I want Todd Viney. I want him infor next round.

Me too

Sorry Hannabal, did I give an opinion on the coaching situation? I merely gave an opinion on this thread.

Is that stating the obvious enough for you? Maybe I'll rephrase it as a statement, rather than a rhetorical question, if that makes it more obvious.

Lame reply. Contribute or STFU.

I just don't get it, they had everything to play for and yet they watched on for the first 20 minutes. I don't think Bailey is a strong motivator or strategist.

Wellman was a big loss.

This year I have been so frustrated with how the dees have progressed.

They have definately the worst intensity and work ethic during matches in the competiton, and especially during Bailey's 4 years nothing has barely changed.

Bailey i rarely notice gets fired up and emotional during matches, and this translates to the players efforts on the ground, as many players are flat-footed and not giving a s*&^ about applying defensive pressure or tackling.

Bailey's 'game plan' is extremely easy for opposing clubs to manage, and when it isnt working melbourne are in great trouble.

The club must become serious and appoint a coach who is passionate, tough, mean and knowledgeable who will allow the MFC to progress into a premiership contender.

Seriously Malthouse should be the number 1 target. The filth players are ALWAYS RUNNING and presenting, tackling, etc and hopefully a good coach like Mick could totally change the playing style and intensity of the team.

As much as i dislike the Essendon Bummers, Hird is someone who the PLAYERS RESPECT AND WOULD PUT THERE BODY ON THE LINE ANYTIME for the coach and this has been evident this year. There list is not too different from ours in quality, just the MFC need a new coach to progress and become a premiership contender.

Bailey has been sensational for our list management.

He's a great manager, or second in command, but he's not a great senior coach. Mind you, he's got terrible leaders at his disposal. Davey, Moloney, Sylvia, Green are simply not A graders.

Don't actually disagree with this, Baley has been great. But his reign has hit the wall. We need a real Hard Nose Coach now.

Davey, Moloney, Sylvia, Green are simply not A graders.

They are when we're winning.

That's a big part of the problem IMO.

Lame reply. Contribute or STFU.

So sorry to have disappointed you. If a moderator deems my light hearted post to not be in keeping with the code of conduct, then I will happily let them remove it.

BTW, you're definitely more fun after a loss. It gives you so much more bravado.

I just don't get it, they had everything to play for and yet they watched on for the first 20 minutes. I don't think Bailey is a strong motivator or strategist.

Wellman was a big loss.

How did we go over in the west while Wellman was assistant coach recently? love how people can identify a single factor for this loss tonight. I watched us play Adelaide over there last year, with wellman coaching and I was just as, if not more disappointed then the loss tonight against the Weagles. mainly because the crows weren't playing as well as the weagles tonight, and we got thmuped just as badly. try again.

I'm not convinced he's been great as a list manager at all. Will agree that he made some hard culling calls, but we have so many small players. Poor old Jamar was simply overwhelmed and our foward line ex Watts are bloody midgets. Cook and Co. miles off, Martin gentle enough to tap dance on a cake without dinting it.

How did we go over in the west while Wellman was assistant coach recently? love how people can identify a single factor for this loss tonight. I watched us play Adelaide over there last year, with wellman coaching and I was just as, if not more disappointed then the loss tonight against the Weagles. mainly because the crows weren't playing as well as the weagles tonight, and we got thmuped just as badly. try again.

No mate, not saying its all about Wellman....but copping a hiding like this and not having a crack in the first quarter is mystifying

Edited April 28, 201114 yr by ravi shanker

So sorry to have disappointed you. If a moderator deems my light hearted post to not be in keeping with the code of conduct, then I will happily let them remove it.

BTW, you're definitely more fun after a loss. It gives you so much more bravado.

You're funny. I call it as I see it whatever the circumstances. Can you say the same ? I doubt you and the word "bravado" have ever been confused. LOL

But Bobby, I'm happy to hang it on the line. What have I said that you disagree with ? You have 9 years of material to work with.

One of the most concerning aspects of tonight's game was the ease with which our tackles were brushed off and equally worrying was the Eagles' ability to take marks under pressure when all too often we couldn't.We were rattled - no question.

We can understand it's a hostile environment over there and perhaps make some allowances - looks like a pretty important game coming up next.Aside from that

This may not be a popular sentiment at the moment but here it is:

Disunity is Death

I don't think sacking Bailey right now is going to solve anything. Don't like the idea of a caretaker coach for 18 rounds and there's zero chance of signing a Quality coach right now.

I've been a big Bailey fan around here and as was mentioned earlier his list management during our rebuild has been excellent. I was happy to see him get his extention last year because I thought he deserved a chance to prove himself as a match day coach capable of delivering a premiership. To be fair to Dean I thought he needed till at least mid season this year before we could make a reasonable judgement and as far as I'm concerned nothings changed.

I fully understand the anger around here right now but I don't think we'd gain anything by sacking Bailey instantly. Might not hurt to start considering possible options but I still think Dean's got maybe 6 weeks to turn it around

You're funny. I call it as I see it whatever the circumstances. Can you say the same ? I doubt you and the word "bravado" have ever been confused. LOL

Tee hee. I'm laughing at you using the word 'bravado', deriding my masculinity and then followed it up with a 'lol'.

Very manly, cupcake.

it needs more shouting and CAPS LOCKS !!1!!1!1!11

Indeed.

I've got to say that I'm as disappointed as anyone with the result, but the angry mob with the torches is giving me a smirk too. People powah!

I don't think sacking Bailey right now is going to solve anything. Don't like the idea of a caretaker coach for 18 rounds and there's zero chance of signing a Quality coach right now.

I've been a big Bailey fan around here and as was mentioned earlier his list management during our rebuild has been excellent. I was happy to see him get his extention last year because I thought he deserved a chance to prove himself as a match day coach capable of delivering a premiership. To be fair to Dean I thought he needed till at least mid season this year before we could make a reasonable judgement and as far as I'm concerned nothings changed.

I fully understand the anger around here right now but I don't think we'd gain anything by sacking Bailey instantly. Might not hurt to start considering possible options but I still think Dean's got maybe 6 weeks to turn it around

I only object to one thing you say.

I see no proof yet that his list management has been "excellent"

He has gutted the experienced players and bought in players almost to man who are players of 2-3 years time.

We have little proof that a large number of these will make it.

Only hope at this point.

Now is not the time for sackings but if the last five game effort continues I see no reason why he should continue past June 30.

Edited April 28, 201114 yr by old dee