David Hale

[Demon Tragic 0]

Given our desire to seek a second ruck, is David Hale a feasible option? Not a demand, but definately a worthwhile question.

[45HG 1,539]

Ah, thank you. Thank you very much.

[Demon Tragic 0]

Ah, thank you. Thank you very much.

Your welcome?

[hoopla 418]

Not sure that we could get him - but of all of the players looking for a new home, he's the one who'd really boost our list.

Proven tall forward - and capable ruckman - to ease the load on Jamar while Fitzpatrick and Gawn develop.

[e25 5]

Would allow us to jettison PJ which needs to happen sooner or later.

[Deetective Sgt. Taggert 380]

I didn't realise he was only 26 so I think he's definately worth a crack

[rpfc 27,684]

Go after White and then Hale.

[Guest Rojik of the Arctic]

Given our desire to seek a second ruck, is David Hale a feasible option? Not a demand, but definately a worthwhile question.

Feasible but what would it cost us? If he comes cheaply I say we jump at it.

[Al`s DEMONS 0]

Feasible but what would it cost us? If he comes cheaply I say we jump at it.

is bate cheap enough

[deeflog 679]

is bate cheap enough

don't think Bate is going anywhere!!! If the club still has him doing media gigs(TAC superstars) then he is safe as houses. They don't put potential trade players out there to spruke the club

[45HG 1,539]

I can't believe my eyes. I needed the laugh first up on a Monday morning, but now...

[dee-luded 2,958]

is bate cheap enough

IMO bate is our handy Utility, but isn't the longterm answer as our key forward. I see him more like a Goddard but with inferior hands.

[Red and Blue Flame 142]

IMO bate is our handy Utility, but isn't the longterm answer as our key forward. I see him more like a Goddard but with inferior hands.

and slower....and not as good as kick...and not all australian utility...

[Al`s DEMONS 0]

don't think Bate is going anywhere!!! If the club still has him doing media gigs(TAC superstars) then he is safe as houses. They don't put potential trade players out there to spruke the club

cant hold a spot though. brock gave 10 then was gone. anything can happen

[pm24 451]

I think Hale would be perfect for our list. He and Russian are both the same age, and in 4 yrs time when both would be in their 30's we'd have Gawn and Fitzpatrick to take over from them.

Hale can play in the forward line and is mobile enough around the ground to. How many guys at nearly 200cm who have been in the league for a while, can we pick up on the cheap. Nth don't need him given they've got Goldstein, McIntosh, and Petrie as their top bigmen.

I think this is a very good suggestion, and one i've seriously thought about as well.

[pitchfork 181]

Is there any evidence that David Hale can ruck?

I'm really not trying to dissmiss the guy but it seems that he's been best used as a stay at home forward

Bit slow, can't do much once the balls is on the floor.

No thanks, unless there's someone who can actually help Jamar in the ruck I think we're in a not too bad position.

As difficult as it may be to accept, PJ did a really great job once he returned in the last couple of months. Is there much diff b/w Hale and PJ's ruck work? could be seeing big Max anyway

Edited September 13, 2010 by pitchfork

[deeflog 679]

cant hold a spot though. brock gave 10 then was gone. anything can happen

there is one thing a player giving $10K of his hard earned and another thing putting a plyer out on media duties for the club.

[hoopla 418]

Is there any evidence that David Hale can ruck?

I'm really not trying to dissmiss the guy but it seems that he's been best used as a stay at home forward

Bit slow, can't do much once the balls is on the floor.

No thanks, unless there's someone who can actually help Jamar in the ruck I think we're in a not too bad position.

As difficult as it may be to accept, PJ did a really great job once he returned in the last couple of months. Is there much diff b/w Hale and PJ's ruck work? could be seeing big Max anyway

Yes Hale can definitely ruck .... he began his career as a ruckman - and only went forward when McIntosh emerged. I'd take him as a knock ruckman over PJ any day- (quite apart from the fact that he can mark)

Realistically big Max is at least two years away ... even if his knee hasn't gawn

[rpfc 27,684]

Bit slow, can't do much once the balls is on the floor.

Not many of us can...

[old55 21,864]

One thing I'd be looking closely at in fwd-ruck is defensive pressure - we can't afford to have a statue that defenders can easily run off. Leigh Brown, Paddy Ryder and Mitch Clark average about 4 tackles per game - David Hale averages less than 2 and Jesse White averages close to 1.

[pm24 451]

One thing I'd be looking closely at in fwd-ruck is defensive pressure - we can't afford to have a statue that defenders can easily run off. Leigh Brown, Paddy Ryder and Mitch Clark average about 4 tackles per game - David Hale averages less than 2 and Jesse White averages close to 1.

You might be expecting a bit much from Hale's tackling when he's played at full-forward compared to playing in the middle.

Also worth noting that Leigh Brown is 194cm to Hale's 201cm. Brown plays all over the ground as well, giving more opportunities to tackle.

Ryder is also 197cm and probably one of the most athletic big men in the game who again spends most of his time in the middle. Again, more opportunities to tackle.

Clark is the only one comparable to Hale in terms of height given he is 200cm, yet he also plays more of a roaming ruckmen type role. I'm not sure if your stats are career averages or just from last year, but i fully expect that if Hale played in the centre of the ground and not a full-forward for the Kanagas then he would have had more tackles.

Anyway, i'd feel pretty confident the club could get him to improve on his tackling if it was a concern.

Regardless, for mine he just ticks the right boxes for our lineup. Can play as a second ruck, go forward and kick goals, is another legitimately big body, and is reasonably mobile to play around the ground. He's worth a shot and would be a real upgrade over pj.

[Hobbits's 17]

Not many of us can...

nothing worse than a battered sav.

[Grandson of a gun 276]

You might be expecting a bit much from Hale's tackling when he's played at full-forward compared to playing in the middle.

Also worth noting that Leigh Brown is 194cm to Hale's 201cm. Brown plays all over the ground as well, giving more opportunities to tackle.

Ryder is also 197cm and probably one of the most athletic big men in the game who again spends most of his time in the middle. Again, more opportunities to tackle.

Clark is the only one comparable to Hale in terms of height given he is 200cm, yet he also plays more of a roaming ruckmen type role. I'm not sure if your stats are career averages or just from last year, but i fully expect that if Hale played in the centre of the ground and not a full-forward for the Kanagas then he would have had more tackles.

Anyway, i'd feel pretty confident the club could get him to improve on his tackling if it was a concern.

Regardless, for mine he just ticks the right boxes for our lineup. Can play as a second ruck, go forward and kick goals, is another legitimately big body, and is reasonably mobile to play around the ground. He's worth a shot and would be a real upgrade over pj.

Not overly fussed about this bloke. There's a reason he couldn't get a game at North and the fact he couldn't after Petrie went down again is concerning.

He could be worth a punt however what we would have to give up is the big question.

He isn't worth a first round pick. He is probably a late second round and a player maybe but what players do we realistically have that north want or need and that we would be willing to give up (especially in light of today's signings announcement)?

Summing everything up i'd probably just say no.

[dee-luded 2,958]

Yes Hale can definitely ruck .... he began his career as a ruckman - and only went forward when McIntosh emerged. I'd take him as a knock ruckman over PJ any day- (quite apart from the fact that he can mark)

Realistically big Max is at least two years away ... even if his knee hasn't gawn

I think he'd cost too much, compared to the out of fashion Q. Get someone short term & cheap. And draft kids for 2 years time.

[dee-luded 2,958]

You might be expecting a bit much from Hale's tackling when he's played at full-forward compared to playing in the middle.

Also worth noting that Leigh Brown is 194cm to Hale's 201cm. Brown plays all over the ground as well, giving more opportunities to tackle.

Ryder is also 197cm and probably one of the most athletic big men in the game who again spends most of his time in the middle. Again, more opportunities to tackle.

Clark is the only one comparable to Hale in terms of height given he is 200cm, yet he also plays more of a roaming ruckmen type role. I'm not sure if your stats are career averages or just from last year, but i fully expect that if Hale played in the centre of the ground and not a full-forward for the Kanagas then he would have had more tackles.

Anyway, i'd feel pretty confident the club could get him to improve on his tackling if it was a concern.

Regardless, for mine he just ticks the right boxes for our lineup. Can play as a second ruck, go forward and kick goals, is another legitimately big body, and is reasonably mobile to play around the ground. He's worth a shot and would be a real upgrade over pj.

good points you raise.