Brock McLean

[Jonesy!!! 27]

woohoooo.. i was worried carltank would back out on their word, but straight swap brock for 11

[Al`s DEMONS 0]

very happy

[Old Gregg 1]

Is this official?

[Jonesy!!! 27]

Is this official?

yes, harrington confirmed on sen

[jayceebee31 671]

very happy

I think a great deal for MFC- we get a great pick in this draft for a guy who always has shown promise however over the last two years has dropped back- I felt the way he was going would not be in my best team in 2010 unless improved spees dramatically. Felt both Maloney and Jones had gone ahead of him as an inside midfielder

[Old Gregg 1]

yes, harrington confirmed on sen

Fantastic. A good outcome, I think it's win-win, Brock wasn't going anywhere at Melbourne. A great deal for us especially, he probs wasn't worth a pick 11.

[Al`s DEMONS 0]

I think a great deal for MFC- we get a great pick in this draft for a guy who always has shown promise however over the last two years has dropped back- I felt the way he was going would not be in my best team in 2010 unless improved spees dramatically. Felt both Maloney and Jones had gone ahead of him as an inside midfielder

right on both counts, pick 11 on KPF(hopefully) Beamer and Jones stood tall in a season which , well what can you say, got the picks and games into the kids, Brock should do well at the Blues, wont be required to run and carry

[JACKATTACK 17]

Glad the deal is done now and we got good value for a player who lost interest, but i'm still not happy.

Something is just not right and I won't be happy until the player we pick up with Pick 11 starts performing.

[jayceebee31 671]

Fantastic. A good outcome, I think it's win-win, Brock wasn't going anywhere at Melbourne. A great deal for us especially, he probs wasn't worth a pick 11.

It all depends on who we pick up for 11 and how the player performs, don't you think?

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

Finally.

He also said we were looking to hold onto all the picks.

Was also fairly fervent in selling the "developing through the draft" line, almost insistent on it without being asked, as though he needed to make it clear that losing Brock was a positive.

[dee-luded 2,958]

woohoooo.. i was worried carltank would back out on their word, but straight swap brock for 11

Confirmed on MFC website. -

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/newsart...42/default.aspx

[H_T 2,941]

.... but i'm still not happy.

Something is just not right and I won't be happy until the player we pick up with Pick 11 starts performing.

It's probably Brock's decision that is not right or doesn't sit right with you.

It was his decision to walk. I couldn't give a rats what he does from here on in, and I for one will not be sitting around unhappy waiting for Pick 11 to perform.

I will be looking very much forward to Pick 11's debut.

I'm very happy that we have 1,2,11,18 to be brutally honest.

Edited October 5, 2009 by High Tower

[beelzebub 22,256]

Finally.

He also said we were looking to hold onto all the picks.

Was also fairly fervent in selling the "developing through the draft" line, almost insistent on it without being asked, as though he needed to make it clear that losing Brock was a positive.

thats right looking to...it is the intention to... but he sounded very much like the door was open to anything for pick 18 and above

[JACKATTACK 17]

It's probably Brock's decision that is not right or doesn't sit right with you.

Yes I think you're right. I guess the club, and our list managers are hardening up a bit and making some tough decisions particulalry with pay and such, if Brock couldn't handle it then fine, we'll find someone who can.

I would like to say goodluck and give him my best wishes, but i'm still angry and I don't think he deserves them.

[grant 10]

Glad the deal is done now and we got good value for a player who lost interest, but i'm still not happy.

Something is just not right and I won't be happy until the player we pick up with Pick 11 starts performing.

Always the pessimist Jackattack. Pick 11 for Brock is an absolute steal! By obtaining this pick we have a shot at drafting a capable KPP. Brock on the other hand is a known quantity which we simply don't need.

[JACKATTACK 17]

Always the pessimist Jackattack. Pick 11 for Brock is an absolute steal! By obtaining this pick we have a shot at drafting a capable KPP. Brock on the other hand is a known quantity which we simply don't need.

Not always, I just really liked Brock. And I don't seem to rate picks this year as much as others here. I suppose in this case I am a bit pessimistic.

When they call out pick 11 on draft day i'll feel better.

[Armitage Shanks 0]

Absolutely magnificent result for the MFC.

I was convinced that after the inclusion of both Scully and Trengrove (who i think will definetly be playing round 1) that Mclean was going to be pushed out of our best 22.

Number 11 and 18 i would think HAVE to be used on key position forwards as i feel our midfield is going to develop quite well when you consider the young talent in there.

Scully

Trengrove

Blease

Strauss

Jones

Moloney

Sylvia

Grimes

Morton

Bennell

Jetta

Davey

Petterd

We are starting to see the makings of a quality side when you add our growing list of key position backs coupled with the emergence of Watts and Jurrah.

[Al`s DEMONS 0]

Absolutely magnificent result for the MFC.

I was convinced that after the inclusion of both Scully and Trengrove (who i think will definetly be playing round 1) that Mclean was going to be pushed out of our best 22.

Number 11 and 18 i would think HAVE to be used on key position forwards as i feel our midfield is going to develop quite well when you consider the young talent in there.

Scully

Trengrove

Blease

Strauss

Jones

Moloney

Sylvia

Grimes

Morton

Bennell

Jetta

Davey

Petterd

We are starting to see the makings of a quality side when you add our growing list of key position backs coupled with the emergence of Watts and Jurrah.

from the players metioned there is a nice balance of youth, experience, inside/outside mids and those who do both

[DeeM 42]

does that mean i have to change my name....damn.

Question: when we play Carlton next will we boo him?

I understand C Johnson, and i will always hate him but i dont know why but im happy for Brock and not angry at him

[DemonDing 56]

does that mean i have to change my name....damn.

Question: when we play Carlton next will we boo him?

I understand C Johnson, and i will always hate him but i dont know why but im happy for Brock and not angry at him

its because we got a great deal out of it and going by the list of midfielders in those other posts mclean would struggling to get a game in a years time i reckon!

[Binmans PA 26,292]

Tim Harrington is earning his money. He's a new favourite of mine, along with BP. God, I'm glad we got rid of Craig Cameron. Our recruiting team is the best it's ever been. Finally, the MFC is on the way to being a professional outfit.

[Binmans PA 26,292]

It's probably Brock's decision that is not right or doesn't sit right with you.

It was his decision to walk. I couldn't give a rats what he does from here on in, and I for one will not be sitting around unhappy waiting for Pick 11 to perform.

I will be looking very much forward to Pick 11's debut.

I'm very happy that we have 1,2,11,18 to be brutally honest.

Right there with you, HT.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

thats right looking to...it is the intention to... but he sounded very much like the door was open to anything for pick 18 and above

Had he said "we're absolutely not planning to trade them" I'd have taken that with a grain of salt too. As the saying goes, there's no such thing as untradeable.

im happy for Brock and not angry at him

I must admit, although I'm annoyed at the circumtances, I find myself wishing him well.

Tim Harrington is earning his money. He's a new favourite of mine, along with BP. God, I'm glad we got rid of Craig Cameron. Our recruiting team is the best it's ever been. Finally, the MFC is on the way to being a professional outfit.

Jesus I hate this line of thinking. BP has had hardly any time to be proven a winner as a recruiter. His worth will only be proven in 4 or so years.

And however well you think of him now, CAC was as close to completely supported on here as you could get as a recruiter, and that WAS after half a dozen recruiting seasons. I don't want to reopen the old boring debate, but he is given a far harder time on here than he deserves. There's a reason he was headhunted.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

God, I'm glad we got rid of Craig Cameron. Our recruiting team is the best it's ever been. Finally, the MFC is on the way to being a professional outfit.

Craig Cameron resigned his post at MFC. Its too early to start toasting the recruiting team we have now but I hope you are right. For the record the list we are building now will include many of Cameron's selections up to 2007. Grimes,Frawley, Martin, Garland are all from Cameron's era.

Laud BP when justified but credit where credit is due.

[Gorgoroth 12,331]

Still gutted.

Will be hating the fact that come the first game we play v Carltank that a heap of idiots will boo Chooka.