All over

[Demon_Tingles 211]

Club Received From

Richmond

Adam Thomson

Port Adelaide

Port Adelaide Round three draft pick (No.42) Richmond

11:48AM 10/10/08

Club Received From

Sydney Swans

Rhyce Shaw and round four draft pick (No. 61)

Collingwood

Collingwood Round three draft pick (No. 46) Sydney Swans

12:00PM 10/10/08

Club Received From

Collingwood

Anthony Corrie

Brisbane Lions

Brisbane Lions

Round six draft pick (No. 93) Collingwood

12:02PM 10/10/08

Club Received From

St Kilda

Farren Ray and round three draft pick (No. 48)

Western Bulldogs

Western Bulldogs

Round two draft pick (No. 31) St Kilda

01:52PM 10/10/08

Club Received From

Essendon

Brent Prismall

Geelong

Geelong Round three draft pick (No. 39) Essendon

01:54PM 10/10/08

Club Received From

Carlton

Robert Warnock and round five draft pick (No. 69)

Fremantle

Fremantle

Round two draft pick (No. 24) , round four draft

Now i hope that we finish in top eight soonish to shove it up the players who didn't want to come here.

Show the pricks that our draft picks can get the job done.

[45HG 1,539]

Now who wants to go through the threads and create a giant WRONG thread for anybody who said anyone would come to Melbourne? Should be a laugh

[H_T 3,047]

Now who wants to go through the threads and create a giant WRONG thread for anybody who said anyone would come to Melbourne? Should be a laugh

[Mousey 47]

What gets to me is-

We finished 16th! i would of thought there would be little amount if anyone that was untouchable.

Why the hell didnt we get rid of anything?

I am kind of disappointed.

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,833]

AFL trade week is a joke and a disgrace. 6 trades in 5 days. Every other sport in the world must laugh at our clubs ability to trade players.

[QueenC 74]

What gets to me is-

We finished 16th! i would of thought there would be little amount if anyone that was untouchable.

Why the hell didnt we get rid of anything?

I am kind of disappointed.

Maybe becuase no-one wanted any of our anything......

[deeflog 679]

Another very ordinary draft week for the MFC...i am so dissapointed in the club. I realise we wanted to keep our high drat picks but surely there was something out there that could have helped improve the MFC

[Mousey 47]

Maybe becuase no-one wanted any of our anything......

That cant be it..

When you see players like Ryce Shaw and Ray getting traded, im sure we could give people more decent players than that.

I think our negotiating skills must be horrible and we must be expecting too much for players who were part of a 16th placed team.

[Guest unstable punt]

That cant be it..

When you see players like Ryce Shaw and Ray getting traded, im sure we could give people more decent players than that.

I think our negotiating skills must be horrible and we must be expecting too much for players who were part of a 16th placed team.

l just think that no-one wants to come to us, we have this reputation mainly spun by the media that we are going to be no good for the next 10 frickin' years, f%#k the lot of them, we will be back on track with our own young blokes in about 2-3 years

[Bails 0]

The problem we have is that the MFC dont have enough $$$ to hire compotent people to work on things like trade week, i think you will find that CC is doing the job of three people.

[e25 5]

l just think that no-one wants to come to us, we have this reputation mainly spun by the media that we are going to be no good for the next 10 frickin' years, f%#k the lot of them, we will be back on track with our own young blokes in about 2-3 years

Judging by the Rhys Shaw and Anthony Corrie deals, i'd say there weren't any deals that WE were happy with.

Nothing wrong with that.

I'd be a lot more [censored] off if we traded a bunch of players for inadequate compensation.

THAT would be an indication we have poor negotiating skills

i'd rather we rebuild the club from the draft and in-house

[DemonDave 1,089]

The problem we have is that the MFC dont have enough $$$ to hire compotent people to work on things like trade week, i think you will find that CC is doing the job of three people.

You're saying Melbourne knowingly hired incompetent people? Interesting.

[Yze_Magic 3]

Amazing that we couldnt even unload Daniel Bell for a pick in the 70's.

[Bails 0]

i agree with that YM

i am so glad we kept CJ and i want you guys to remember this and if im wrong i will wear the abuse...

if he stays injury free he will prove to be a super player and will come in the top5 in the B & F next year!!!

[Sir Why You Little 37,038]

I wouldn't worry too much. I really don't think there was much to trade for. We have our picks and PSD in place. Brent Prismall has a bung Knee, Okeefe a highly inflated price. We Didn't lose Green, & nobody knows how good or bad Warnock is. Definately not worth 400 k. Carlton may regret that one. So all in all i think MFC was quite wise. Remember if there is no interest in Bell or Carroll that's that. MFC can't give them away. Think toward the Future-we will improve.

[Rogue 585]

What gets to me is-

We finished 16th! i would of thought there would be little amount if anyone that was untouchable.

Why the hell didnt we get rid of anything?

I am kind of disappointed.

On the flip side, it can mean we have a poor list of ordinary senior players that no one wants (and we're not willing to trade away our youngsters).

It's not like we were the only Club to fail to find a suitable deal - North were shopping around a few players and didn't get any takers.

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,833]

i agree with that YM

i am so glad we kept CJ and i want you guys to remember this and if im wrong i will wear the abuse...

if he stays injury free he will prove to be a super player and will come in the top5 in the B & F next year!!!

CJ is out of contract.

Could walk into the PSD on the way to WC or Freo.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

On the flip side, it can mean we have a poor list of ordinary senior players that no one wants (and we're not willing to trade away our youngsters).

It's not like we were the only Club to fail to find a suitable deal - North were shopping around a few players and didn't get any takers.

Correct. Six ordinary trades across 16 clubs.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

if he stays injury free he will prove to be a super player and will come in the top5 in the B & F next year!!!

That does not make him a super player.

And your comment on MFC staff shows how uninformed you really are.