Who's your preferred forward 6 for 2009?

[H_T 2,941]

Feel free to give your opinions

So far the Demonland voting members have decided on the most preferred back 6 defenders for 2009 as: -

BACKS: WHELAN WARNOCK GARLAND

H-BACKS: RIVERS MARTIN C.JOHNSON

(Not necessarily in those positions)

Now give us your Forward Six selections - Good luck!

For the record my starting 6 are: -

FWD: - SYLVIA MILLER WONAEMIRRI

H-FWD: - DAVEY BATE ROBERTSON

All the best.................

[Rogue 585]

It makes it tough to select a forward and back six, given the rotations in footy these days.

PS. I didn't see this coming

Maybe I should start a preferred midfield 6 thread. <_<

[H_T 2,941]

I didn't see this coming

Maybe I should start a preferred midfield 6 thread. <_<

I take it your putting Davey in the midfield?

[Rogue 585]

I take it your putting Davey in the midfield?

I'm not sure how you can gather that from my comment

[deeflog 679]

my other is Jack Watts

[H_T 2,941]

I'm not sure how you can gather that from my comment

No I gathered that from what I thought was your vote - which was rather quick after i first posted...

I shouldn't assume this...but your secret is safe.....unless you either plan on putting davey on the bench, emergency or are considering trading him?

B)

[H_T 2,941]

my other is Jack Watts

Good point. Fingers crossed for that one.

[Rogue 585]

No I gathered that from what I thought was your vote - which was rather quick after i first posted...

I shouldn't assume this...but your secret is safe.....unless you either plan on putting davey on the bench, emergency or are considering trading him?

I haven't voted

[H_T 2,941]

I haven't voted

okay............

[Gouga 512]

HF: Davey, Bate, Wonaeamirri

F: Robertson, Miller, Sylvia

[barpen 0]

HF: Davey Miller Bate

F: Sylvia Robbo Wonaemirri

Even if we draft watts, he will take time and this is my starting forward line for 2009. Newton can hopefully displace Robbo although I doubt it.

[Beamer 1]

HF: Bate, PJ, Miller.

F: Sylvia, Robbo, Austin.

Davey wing/midfield.

[sylvinator 96]

Forwards:

talls: Miller, Newton, (PJ resting ruck?)

mobiles: Bate, Sylvia, Robbo

Smalls: Wonaeamirri, Davey, Maric

Garland for me, could be the surprise packet. if we continue to develop 4 other key defenders (Martin, Frawley, Rivers and Warnock), it would be well worth giving Garland a go in the forward line. hes so quick, agile and versatile that it could pay off big time...

[paddo 0]

HF: Davey Miller Sylvia

FF: Wonaeamirri Newton Robertson

Bate to midfield. Robbo to play for another 1-2 years to develop young forwards.

[Guest Schtacker]

Love the idea High Tower, just wondering how you plan to manage the problem that certain players can play in several positions - Davey is the best example as in different people's eyes he could be back, forward or mid... which might mean he misses out on all three

Bruce will probably not make your 22 but I imagine most of us would have him in for 2008

Not a criticism just a question

[H_T 2,941]

Forwards:

talls: Miller, Newton, (PJ resting ruck?)

mobiles: Bate, Sylvia, Robbo

Smalls: Wonaeamirri, Davey, Maric

Garland for me, could be the surprise packet. if we continue to develop 4 other key defenders (Martin, Frawley, Rivers and Warnock), it would be well worth giving Garland a go in the forward line. hes so quick, agile and versatile that it could pay off big time...

Like your thoughts on Garland. Garland did drift down to the forward line against Richmond. Kicked a goal. maybe we might see a bit more of him down there this week, courtesy of Bailey. We could see this next year when Rivers is back in.

The 7th most voted defender on Demonland was in fact Frawley.

[Eastie Boyz 0]

HF: Davey - Miller - Bate

FF: Wonaeamirri - Robertson - Sylvia

Still lacking a decent tall forward to take Robbo's place

[Rogue 585]

Not a criticism just a question

Have a vote for the last remaining four spots, and include seven - four on the 'int' and three on the emergency list.

edit: didn't make sense...

[H_T 2,941]

Have a vote for the last remaining four spots, and include seven - four on the 'int' and three on the bench.

Someone's on the ball...!

Cheers.

Well, Schtaker match committee selectors have tough decisions to make...........so now you guys are in their shoes.

The players that end up missing the interchange or emergencies don't necessarily have to be considered "dee-listed" , just pretend they didn't make your side and they're playing at Sandy, or in next years case Casey!

[Guest Schtacker]

Have a vote for the last remaining four spots, and include seven - four on the 'int' and three on the emergency list.

edit: didn't make sense...

yes but that may still well result in Davey on the bench or emergency when he is clearly best 18

midfield is going to be a tough one which makes me happy

[H_T 2,941]

yes but that may still well result in Davey on the bench or emergency when he is clearly best 18

midfield is going to be a tough one which makes me happy

Schtaker, we'll manage it no problem. As long as the votes keep pouring in, it will sort itself out. It may also mean Davey in the starting 18!

For example, the 7th highest voted defender is Frawley, so he might get named on the bench......once the 6 forwards are settled, the midfielders will be done, then the players that miss each section will be pooled and the bench will be voted on out of 7, as Rogue said, the 3 left over will be the emergencies.

[w00dy 146]

Newton

Miller

Robertson

Bate

Wonaeamirri

Davey

davey could obviously play in the middle, perhaps maric to take his spot?

[drdrake 3,049]

I had Davey in my midfield so my forward 6

Sylvia Miller Bate

Newton Robertson Aussie

[H_T 2,941]

I had Davey in my midfield so my forward 6

Sylvia Miller Bate

Newton Robertson Aussie

Yep.

[Lord Travis 10,267]

Davey Miller Bate

Wona Robbo other

The other being Watts (or whomever we draft as a forward). If he (draftee) is too raw, then put Sylvia there. Newton is gone. Useless IMO