Pennant St Dee

Yes because when he doesn't kick a bag in his first few hit out's demonland will go into meltdown

WYL if you believe DARLING would turn this side around and would have had the same impact with us last year that he had at Meth Coast you are mistaken

,WYL you can't have it both ways you said we butchered the pick by taking Cook. over Darling.

Big Statement WYL you have gone out on a limb and made it without even seeing Lucas Cook fully develop 1 week in footy is a long time let alone 2 years

Would pay $450 for Sidey not sold on Beams but not saying he's a dud just think he is not worth big money would not be against Sidey, Caddy & Viney and seeing a fit Trenners and Gysberts in there and Jack Grimes given a lengthy run injury free in the middle will only improve

FFS just get over it Cooky seems to be coming on well at Casey and Howe has also been very good. and to bring the Scully saga into it FFS He wouldn't have complimented Clark in 2011 and would not have had the same impact as at Meth Coast, but Im sure you all would have overlooked that feckin hindsight recruiters

Don't agree Sidebottom is the better of the two by a fair way IMO and BEAMS is not better than Jones, would you pay that for Jones, if you paid these 2 Pies $5-600K each you could get a Caddy, Koby Stevens and another mid whilst keeping money the following season to target another kid maybe GWS who may want to come home maybe Toby Greene (who will be very good IMO) Dylan Shiel. The Tigers actually did the right thing targetting fringe players they needed to fill the holes in their list whilst having in Cotchin, Martin, Grimes, Rance and other young players coming good . The players they targetted were not getting regular games at their own clubs They needed a running half back - Houli, a solid mid - Grigg and a Ruckman - Maric. Whilst I am happy to target a quality mid lets not target someone who plays in a very good side and pay overs. We need a quality mid, a half back to break the lines and press by foot and a small forward thats were the money needs to go

beams is good but he certainly is not worth $500k per year, He has been doing the pre seasons for 4 or 5 years now that our boys have only done for the first time. i would sound him out but not for thee amount some here are quoting

Tom Swift is a dud despite the injuries I have seen him play WAFL and get plenty of the ball due to far superior fitness than opponents but still continues to butcher it even with more time. Koby Stevens is a stand out for East Fremantle in the WAFL and just can't break into one of the top 2 midfields in the comp, would be a very good get and IMO would come farily cheap, may also be out of contract at end of season

As I said WYL can't think of any of his direct opponents towelling him up either, Neeld is playing him defensively this year whilst Misson works on his fitness.

Can't guarantee with injury etc WYL but you know MO on Trengove, has all the tools and has never been considered slow before. They are building his tank up and he is learning from the best opposition players getting challenged every week, Can you honestly tell me anyone who has absolutley panced him this year over an entire four quarters. He will be the better for 2012

Good call on Sidey anyway

Mark my words Olisik he will be better than Dusty in the long run, has been run into the ground by Misson and Neeld this year and it's part of the long term plan for him. Dusty has not set the world on fire this year but will also be a good player

Can't believe those saying Sellar offered nothing, he took Dawes to the cleaners and thats two solid efforts in a row now, if he is dropped for GWS it will only be because there is no match up but could be needed if they decide to play GILES forward. Dunn another target offers vesersatility off the bench, can play as a defensive forward, run with player subs can be called upon ealry as happened with Didak today. Blease in what game 7 had a few bad moments but the kid will be the better for exposure in a big game, Morton has footy smarts and knows how to run and spread but supporters continue to call for the whipping boys to be dropped and old favourites like Petterd to come in with no form. Cook is not ready, Gysberts needs more game time and if we have a VFL game this week Martin needs another run and Dunn needs a full hit out. The Dees of 2011 would have rolled over today, really good heart and a will not to be smashed from the boys work in progress And in closing Green kicked badly today but was brave in contests, he has been a loyal servant and if it is his last season he deserves to go out in a bit of style

Can you and hardnut take this to PM with each other instead of wasting half to a full page of threads with I see more than you

1) Trent Cotchin - on his way to being the best mid in the comp 2) Scott Pendlebury - currently the best mid in the comp 3) Travis Cloke - with the above 2 n our midfield along with what we have and Mitch Clark would be very hard to beat

Is it 1987 WYL would love a trip back to that fairytale ride, but just want to see 4 quarter efforts for the rest of the season do that and we will win another 5-7 games.

Happy with this, Thanks Russian, shot in the arm for the club and stamp of approval for Neeld and future direction of the club. Has been a loyal servant to the club and really hope he is still around when we play deep in September

Fiery encounter Old Dee the feckin Royals drew level with a kick off the ground from the goal square in the dying seconds, The Cardies were up by 40pts at half time and just ran out of legs, not quite perfect but no losses on the weekend

Hardie hates Connelly & Schwab and gives Schwab no credit for turning Fremantles off field fortunes around, he cleared a massive debt while he was there. One thing Brad will never do is backdown from something he says eg "telling Woosha in 2010 he was about as close to a Premiership as he (Hardie) was to getting to Mars". Hardie has also kept quite his belief around trade time 2011 & earlier this season that we had paid way overs for Mitch Clark and he wasn't worth that sort of money

Was thinking of you WYL and some of the older supporters I know last night. Due to our 0-9 start the thougts of many are things are so bad we wont ever move forward. There will still be bad days but we needed to pear right back before we really move forward, Hope you WYL and others now believe better times are ahead, still a while away though Enjoy it my Demon brothers, Mt Hawthorn Cardies JFC had a win today and The Perth derby tomorrow so here's hoping for three wins

Wyl & old dee this is for u Believe!

Boys my best mate is a born and bred bomber and andrew welsh's uncle i watched the game with him and to be honest we were all waiting for the dees to fall over fook this felt good when wad the last time we won ugly!

I could be wrong but my understanding is Boak and his family are bluebaggers, but IMO like Judd, Franklin & Pendles it means nothing romantic notion but if we want him we need to sell ourselves, media and many demonlanders believe on field ATM we haven't a hope in selling ourselves but we need to get into his manager now and sell the vision and the big part Boak (and whoever else we are targetting) play in it

Good player but would not be throwing everything at him