Pennant St Dee

Dunn has a big body and Needs to get the defensive forward job on Hodge or Suckling

I understand somewhat of what your saying hardnut but Geelong have been doing it for a long time, 1999-2003 they were a basket case when a lot of their current playing group were new to the big league. They have been playing that gamestyle for 8 years now whilst we have been at ours for 8 months. I do agree however that not one magical player will turn us around, I think we are 3 to 4 short of becoming a decent unit. Dangerfield will be expensive and he will be an immediate success along with Viney, but on the other hand maybe targetting two from the Suns and start being proactive and hitting up boys well in advance at GWS who will be out of contract at the end od 2013. On that note very impressed with Toby Green today

That is true Jamar has far less talent and the heart of a lion, White had an abundance of talent probably to much to warrant him working his arse off. He never came to terms with the ruck change to combat the PCL curse. We talk of our bad culture and from afar it is the likes of Trapper, Yze, White and similar gifted players who Danners stuck with who set this culture in stone and one of the reasons we are lacking leadership now

It's good in theory but if you loose a player ealry its a full game for him, look long term and give him another full game with Casey

+ 1 on this Maloney has not been great but he does take another midfielder from the opposition and has a big body to crash through packs. Sylvia was very good last week when he came off the subs bench but was found wanting yesterday. I think we may need him against the bigger bodied Hawks as we have no obvious replacement but it's up to Neeld

It's not his brother its his cousin, and he is very homesick, West Coast and Freo will make very big plays for him

Hawks are not quick through the middle but hard as nails and they run hard, so despite Bail being off today he stays. Hawks defence can be exploited if Gibson is out, Dunn to nulify Hodge across half back. Sellar is the obvious out but do you bring Fitzy in to play 2nd ruck or go more mobile with Petterd forward and let Dunn pinchhit. Bennell & Blease also under consideration for some run off half back . Neeld needs to pull Sylvia asde and ask him for something I'd also play Magner head to head against Mitchell unless they feel he needs a rest Out: Sellar, maybe Tappy if Bennell or Blease are to come in In: Fitzpatrick or Petterd, maybe Bennell or Blease

6-Clark - by a street, marked, crumbed, chased and worked his arse off 5- Jones not as good as last week but worked hard and kicked a couple 4- Howe presented well unfortunatley needs to finish off his good work. Has been a good positive this year 3 - Morton backed up from last week looks to be gaining some confidence 2- Frawley defended well as usual but his disposal let him down otherwise could have taken 5 votes 1- Can't split Barty or Mcdoanld solid efforts

Not 100% sure but think it was Mark Robinson on SEN today who said he'd heard rumours a Melbourne based club was looking at making an offer to Dangerfield at seasons end. Robbo did not name the club but said he contacted the club and asked them, they confirmed his rumour and their interest but advised they were told he is likely to stay. Could be true or could be a club trying to put something to bed until seasons end

JT has not been great this year, but thought he was okay today ran out the game well and is one who actually runs to support his players. He got a lesson in hard work last week from Lenny Hayes and on face value today took something from it. Will stay in on todays performance, Grimes still finding form and coming along okay, Both will grow into the role

Good post, the faith in each other will come when they trust there teammate to go in win it and lay it off. Dunn, Bate, Barty while not stars are doing everything Neeld asks and its all he expects. Good to see Morton going in hard and gaining some confidence to take things on. As for Clark glad we got him, great target, work ethic and attitude

Stuie you clearly don't like Neeld you have been at him since the season started, he has a massive task ahead of him, the boys knew they were in for a day right from the start, we got smashed down there last year and there was back slapping and congratulations when players kicked the 5 or 6 goals we kicked. Tackles & Chases are non negotiables. The Cats took it up to us in time on in every quarter which to me is fitness and not coaching, we do not have the confidence within ourselves to change the tempo in time on this will come. If you don't think we have improved greatly since Round 1 I don't know what you expect, every week there is improvement whilst we may have been better last week the opposition was not as good and the Cats at home one of the hardest tasks in the league. The fact we didn't rest on last weeks performance is something against the roller coaster. The Cats trust one another they have been at there game for years they know what each other are thinking and where they will be, whether Selwood is in or out those coming in know exactly what their role is in the team, that again takes time. We are not to many players away from dramatic improvement, a defender with good kicking skills to help clear the lines could be a fit Strauss or maybe target Mckenzie from the Suns. Frawley defends very well but his decision making is not the best at the moment probably a confidence issue. Another pre season will see the run and spread component, A bit of speed through the middle we have the ball winners which is why we are winning the contested possessions but getting killed in the uncontested possessions. As the team gets used to the game plan there will be less occassions where they all head to the ball leaving free opponents over the top The forward line needs a bit of work but Clark looks dangerous whenever it gets down there, Howe needs to work on set shots and Jurrah to come back - Davey has shown a bit but we desperatley need a crumber. Taylor and Scarlett are a class act but Clark & Howe will cause a lot of headaches to defences Anyway Stuie as I said in my original post, nothing IMO that cant be rectified

Beyond maybe D grade Stuie you never played did you

really, we never gave up unlike recent seasons, they could have blown us away several times but we continued to fight, last season we would have rolled over. Not a step back in my opinion unlike last season when we belted sides only to believe our own press and play four bad games the following weeks. Missed some very gettable goals into a howling breeze in the last quarter which could have seen us get to within 4 goal defeat. Did not see anything from our side today that can not be rectified

AFL SITE I'M listening on SEN

Another week (if Casey don't have a bye next week) wont do Watts any harm get some consistency into him and maybe just maybe make him realise after a few weeks out. When I get my chance again I am going to grab it. To early a call on Jurrah

The porn star does what Neeld asks, Ricky needs to do the same

Well seriously I have said nowt for a couple of months but must you fook up every thread!

Not really, Jack if you want to play at this level you have to earn it, whilst I appreciate the conditions last week didn't suit you they were perfect for putting bodies on the line and tackling. Sam Fisher showed you how much you have to work át this level now learn from it go back and make yourself a better competitor and get the hunger to succeed. You have the tools but only you can take yourself to the next level

Sorry Big Jim, I'm not a Watts knocker but can't agree with you here, Davey has improved every week this season and provided some forward pressure. Dunn took over from Watts last week picking up Fisher and done the job. I'm not writing Watts off far to young for that and not enough games in him..He showed glimpses last season especially through the middle of the year. IMO 1 week out is not enough unless he really tears it up, send him back for two reasons build confidence and build hunger, it may spark something inside him

Gold

No make him earn it, lets see him do this over 3/4 weeks. We Need to make our team similar to Wes Coast where guys are tearing the WAFL apart to get a chance and once they do are playing to the team structures and hearts out just to stay in

and they say a week is a long time in footy Jackie, didn't you start this thread

From what I seen yesterday and if he continues to play like that, Do it. Break out game? Maybe He will be much sought after if he keeps playing like that

A lack of pace can be compensated by smarts, Treners and Scully complimented each other and were great picks together, Scully had the pace and gut running, Trenners has the smarts and still does IMO he is getting to grips with new gameplan and also suffering from interupted pre season. Pretty confident the captaincy is not a burden on him at all.