DEE fence

Just out of curiosity (am a hopeless optimist with the predictor) how many wins do you have us getting for 9th?

Four out Four games, he's the first defender I want to see each week picked (Salem/Vince not far behind)

* SNAP* (-;

The defence was magnificent, but i am torn the first half was champagne, the second dour-do i back those who got the lead or kept it. Viney-on all day Watts-was a rolls royce Gawn-the game is played on our terms even though grundy had a good day too Lumumba-broke the lines for us Jetta-love his heart Tyson-haters be gone. Apologies to Pederson/N.Jones/Bugg/Wagner/McDonald/Harmes

Had fun reading PRE and Nick's Footy, the pies all reckon we were better playing good footy, and the tiges are sure the're going to lose. Watching the replay in Roma (sadly knowing the result) and I have this to say. 1. I thought the pies must have played badly, they didn't, they brought pressure, we brought more. 2. The umping boo boos were fairly even. 3. Finally saw why they stuck with Frost et al, looks like the coaching staff know something about football. 4. H had a great game, was in the best. 5. Harmes is a player, I had no idea, reminds me a little of Whelan (not quite the wrecker yet) or a Peter Walsh. 6. We are on for more than 10 wins this year.

AN_Inkling Joined: 06 Oct 2007 Posted: Sun Apr 17, 2016 9:53 pm Post subject: Pies4shaw wrote: "Look, Melbourne is a very good football team." They sure are. If they can keep up their current form they will go very close to making finals.

On emotion - its Trengrove, therefore 25 should be hung. Otherwise 2 weeks is about right.

Matt Jones has owns his spot - that said, who to drop, its difficult, every time we try to have a tall fwd line it always seems to fall over for us, am happy to go with better ball users, than size alone.

I thought they were shot when Libba Jr went down and they didnt miss a stride, I reckon they have some belief that will keep them performing. I like Murphy, but am in shock PF said something agreeable.

Was wondering I I hope not) if the coaching panel has written this game of and is using it to experiment a little? I really think Dunn is key down back - I feel really nervous without him there, more than Tmac, Garland needs a reset button he's becoming a bit too relaxed, like Howe was/is so happy he's in the magoos. the other I need to see is Jetta, very nervous without him playing. BTW Silly me out of loyalty I traded him into my fantasy side and he's an emergency... d'oh

Now that D.Swan is out for the season (very nasty break wouldnt be surprised if that was his last game-think the poor geelong bugger that Neitz collected) the pies will be cursing the kennedy trade. Not that they are like for like but they are in trouble in the mids after one game. BBT humble pie for me was sure Kennedy was NQR.

I misread my email inbox just now, thought it said 'Oliver to defect' fell off my chair literally.

M.Jones - a stop gap - I'd like to think M. Jones has found something, I reckon there is something different about him this season I'm going with 'useful team player' everything else I can pretty much live with - would like you to be wrong about Spencer though.

I had mixed thought about tuning in - when I saw the lineup I first thought thats it for me but have since decided to follow and see what happens. (actually Freo Fanatic on you tube is a good poster for OS people like myself) Scott was tolerable but I think he will struggle to keep a lid on it this year if they hit speed bumps, he does wear his heart on his sleeve. Buckley I like, I'm kinda curious about how the magpies go this year, he's been given a blank canvass in so many ways to do as he likes and I'm interested to see if it pays off for him. ( I still hate the magpies, don't get me wrong) Robbo and Gerard have chemistry that works on air, I don't like him but it doesn't mean they have suddenly become the footy show. Heppell and Riewoldt, for sure they are flawed, but they might just have a different POV that could be interesting, who knows and at least its not the footy show.

I actually think we are the hardest team to call in the comp apart from Carlton and Essendon. For so many reasons 8-10 wins are possible (injuries etc) but for so many reasons, if we avoid the Norm Smith curse (Neil Balme would still have nightmares about the injury list he had) I can see as many as 14 wins (This is realist me, fantasy me says 15....). So anyway my point is the pundits all sound like they are hedging their bets, they know we are on the move but need to see change before they back us. They will jump on quickly and say they saw the improvement. As for Viney, I'm starting to think by the end of his playing days Junior Viney will be the best thing Senior Viney ever did for us, and that is not meant as a slight against Todd.

Sometimes I think the forum should be called 'DemonTherapy', we qualify by any objective measure.

Even Paul Hopgood would do a nice job

I'm with BB, I'm hoping that during the year we demonstrate that we are a desirable place to be. I want the guys that have bought into the team already to be rewarded and not pushed aside or asked to settle for less. This would I think degrade the culture and team being built. We are also going to need plenty of coin to retain the core that has been put together. So if Prestia wants to come, well and good, but no kitchen sink offers. I do understand that we cannot stand still with list management but I think we are at a different point to where we have been (possibly since the 90's) It is a different story with Rucks, I want another key tall defender who can back up ruck. I find i'm not as confident anymore in our back six as a unit as I was two years ago. Am happy to shop in this area, or be proved wrong with garland and tmac being consistent (I love them both but don't know why they are not playing there best footy atm)

I actually struggle to find much useful in Kings comments beyond his description of attack on the ball and the individual attributes of players. Pagans' Paddock was as much as about keeping it simple for the mouth breathers he had on his team. Everything else he has to say smacks of being a windsock. I do think he understands individual players though.

Great post, was about to do the same

Viney vs Oliver vs VDB scalps list over the season.

Arm wasn't pinned and no head into ground, therefore I think the fine was unfair. It looked worse than what it was. Whereas elbow lifted into Tyson's face from what I could see...

matt jones had a good game. i don't need to hide, neither do you!

http://watchafl.afl.com.au/ Viney's tackle made the 1 of the top 10 list, sorry if already posted. I think it's a bit like Howe's MOTY, there are so many he is the default #1,

They are dumb enough to tongue wash dead bodies...