jayceebee31

No--- I am saying he has the ability BUT his injury will have to improve drammatically.He could hardly run..I hope he does improve drammatically and if not WILL NOT MAKE IT-IT IS AS SIMPLE AS THAT..

A good choice if we thought he was our best pick but agree with Deeluded -we have priorities this draft.

Your just playing with words.He will have to improve heaps to make it..note-I am not saying he will not make it..but by gee I saw him play nearly every match and gee he was really feeling his leg. I rated Sam as the best prospect at the club before his injury.He has the ability..however like Egan's injury he'll have to improve drammatically

However, you would have to admit- he'd have to improve drammatically to make it.

OK- WHO DO YOU SUGGEST WILL BE INTHE RUNNING FOR PICK 12?.

Agreed- good by Fev.One loose cannon there.

Good prospect most likely will head to GC.

I certainly believe he will be.He will be around for another 5 years IMO.He has just turned 27.

Your joking-I'd want picks,3,5 &15 for the All Australian ruckmam .

Jiohnson is well passed his used by date- Junior could definately played for at least a season..

Good points again RR -however just concerened we have the leadership to step up next year.

Could be a worthwhile rookie !

I'd be very surprised if a Victorian club picked him up-GWS may.

Just lodged mine.

I hope that is SOON

Don't forget all- he played with Trengove & Tapscott last year.

suffering imaginitis....or confused with PJ.. CONGRATS Shane- well done

Very well explained.

So- who do you suggest we look for at pick 12.

You have just posted the credentials to keep him- maybe we should play him in his natural role/s. Just maybe others need to learn like him, such as Trengove,Scully etc..

The right time is when the right players and the club agree .What I mean by this is- if the club feels they have a weakness and want to fill it by experienced players, then, when we approach the player and they agree- that is the right time.Whether that is this year, the next or when.

Hey,I'd hate him to lay one on you or I.

If Ratten wanted Warnock why not ask for Gibbs for a trade.

It shows the true character of the player when he asks to meet the coaches and ask about his future.No spittin the dummy(well-at this stage).No doubt he has been asked to fill different roles this year. I feel he is still in our best 22. We need players like him at the club- a real trooper and great character.

Agree on the best available- however if this is a tall -PLEASE do not expect him to be a star in 2011.Talls need time... Furthermore,it is my opinion that we have to have 3 picks.however with the rookie changes now- I do not know if indeed we upgrade ,say Jordie that would qualify for a pick..ditto- Jake Spencer