Worst player

[Homer J 0]

Some suggestion today that CJ is the worst player to play for Melbourne. Not true. Here are some candidates:

Michael Young

Michael Byrne (before traded to Hawthorn)

Glenn McLean (traded to the fiflth)

Roger Ellingworth

James Frawley (His cousins could play better)

Alistair Nicholson

Tony Campbell

Ricky Jackson

Mark Jackson

Luke Molan (although to be fair he never played a senior game)

Stan Alves (because he slags on us at every opportunity because he didnt get the captaincy)

Diamond Jim Tilbrook (overpaid and over-rated)

Craig Turley

Nick Pesch

Luke Williams

Michael Seddon

[Rogue 585]

It's hard to believe Nicho is a candidate for worst player - he was okay for us.

[Homer J 0]

It's hard to believe Nicho is a candidate for worst player - he was okay for us.

He's not in the class of Andy Moir!!!!

[kryton 0]

Some suggestion today that CJ is the worst player to play for Melbourne. Not true. Here are some candidates:

Michael Young

Michael Byrne (before traded to Hawthorn)

Glenn McLean (traded to the fiflth)

Roger Ellingworth

James Frawley (His cousins could play better)

Alistair Nicholson

Tony Campbell

Ricky Jackson

Mark Jackson

Luke Molan (although to be fair he never played a senior game)

Stan Alves (because he slags on us at every opportunity because he didnt get the captaincy)

Diamond Jim Tilbrook (overpaid and over-rated)

Craig Turley

Nick Pesch

Luke Williams

Michael Seddon

At last, a positive post to discuss......

[gOLLy 401]

Scott Chisolm anyone?

[Rogue 585]

I'm surprised Grgic hasn't been mentioned.

[Homer J 0]

Scott Chisolm anyone?

Good stuff

Add Brent Grgic - playing for Bell post hill or Bell Park for the last few years

[Sleeve 67]

David AND Donald Cockatoo Collins.

[stretch marks 2]

Some suggestion today that CJ is the worst player to play for Melbourne. Not true. Here are some candidates:

Michael Young

Michael Byrne (before traded to Hawthorn)

Glenn McLean (traded to the fiflth)

Roger Ellingworth

James Frawley (His cousins could play better)

Alistair Nicholson

Tony Campbell

Ricky Jackson

Mark Jackson

Luke Molan (although to be fair he never played a senior game)

Stan Alves (because he slags on us at every opportunity because he didnt get the captaincy)

Diamond Jim Tilbrook (overpaid and over-rated)

Craig Turley

Nick Pesch

Luke Williams

Michael Seddon

Did you ever see Ricky Jackson play? If so how could you even consider him for this list?

[Deestroy All 14,266]

All of the above posters must be on a serious amount of crack and other narcotics because none of you mentioned DAMIEN GASPAR.

An Eskimo kickin' a fish around would look like more of a footballer than that complete clown. And calling him a clown isn't an insult, apparently he was the funniest bloke at the club, humour must be very highly rated at MFC for DAMIEN GASPAR to have ever played more than a quarter of football.

Worst

Player

Ever

In

History

[Homer J 0]

Did you ever see Ricky Jackson play? If so how could you even consider him for this list?

The 1987 preliminary final sealed his fate to the list. Simon Eishold has to go in as well.

Also Vin Catoggio for his 7 or 9 games played. Think we swapped Greg Wells to Carlton!!!!!

[joeboy 3,166]

Joe Rugolo for mine , whilst Isaac Weetra is well on the way.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Stan Alves (because he slags on us at every opportunity because he didnt get the captaincy)

Stan Alves

226 games for MFC between 1965 and 1976.

2 B & Fs in 1972 and 1974

Runner up in Brownlow in 1975.

Captain 1973 to 1976

Represented Victoria 6 times.

Played 40 games for North Melbourne 1977 to 1978

1977 Premiership player.

Worst Player is he??

[Jarka 767]

Woah, settle down tiger.

Bit harsh on Stan Alves, he was a club champion who was harshly dealt with by the club when it came to redo his contract.

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,837]

Luke Williams, Brent Grgic and Colin Garland

[praha 11,240]

That list fails because it doesn't have Damien Gasper.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Woah, settle down tiger.

Bit harsh on Stan Alves, he was a club champion who was harshly dealt with by the club when it came to redo his contract.

Agree Jarka.

The Club treated its 1970s champions very very poorly. Their bitter treatment of Alves then Wells was appalling.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Chris Woodman No 41

[robbo24 66]

Luke Williams, Brent Grgic and Colin Garland

Daniel Ward hands down.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Ward_%28footballer%29

[Homer J 0]

Stan Alves

226 games for MFC between 1965 and 1976.

2 B & Fs in 1972 and 1974

Runner up in Brownlow in 1975.

Captain 1973 to 1976

Represented Victoria 6 times.

Played 40 games for North Melbourne 1977 to 1978

1977 Premiership player.

Worst Player is he??

Have heard Stan on the radio in the last seven years. No t one positive comment about Melbourne. That's why he made the list

[Homer J 0]

Daniel Ward hands down.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Ward_%28footballer%29

We miss his run and carry from half back already!!!!!

[Homer J 0]

Forgot to put in Tom Flower

[Whispering_Jack 30,168]

Whatever view one might have of a player it's a disgrace and an indictment on Wikipedia that it allows such nonsense as this on its pages -

"By the end of his career, Ward was best known for his inability to pick up an opponent or get his hands on the ball, and when he did get his hands on the ball he frequently coughed it up to the opposition, often resulting in goals. It is believed that his inability to play football in his last season played a large part in the sacking of coach Neil Daniher who was reluctant to drop him from the team."

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Have heard Stan on the radio in the last seven years. No t one positive comment about Melbourne. That's why he made the list

Good criteria for worst player!

Given the way MFC has played over the past seven years we have given commentators good reason to be critical.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Whatever view one might have of a player it's a disgrace and an indictment on Wikipedia that it allows such nonsense as this on its pages -

"By the end of his career, Ward was best known for his inability to pick up an opponent or get his hands on the ball, and when he did get his hands on the ball he frequently coughed it up to the opposition, often resulting in goals. It is believed that his inability to play football in his last season played a large part in the sacking of coach Neil Daniher who was reluctant to drop him from the team."

That the sort of rubbish you would get on this site.