Top 3 draft picks are locked away

[dee-luded 2,958]

Um......there was no AFL in their day. $$$ make a decision easier and that is probably why they stayed in Victoria. The VFL was the premier competition way back then.

There was big cash under the table for topliners in their state comps, some went back. My point was that if you recruit a gun you do what it takes to keep them.

[brey9186 102]

yeah, mitch was a father son, but ive heard they are regretting it (mitch has a bit of an attitude too)

mitch should be a at richmond next year, and where cale will be is up in the air, cant see him going past the top 6 or so, but i dont think he'll be at west coast

[Harry Manback 2]

We should definitely be looking to acquire another top ten pick. From all reports, it sounds like Bailey was always going to trade Johnstone regardless of the Chris Judd situation. Whilst a part of me would like to see how he fares in the post-Daniher era, the reality is that the whole group aged 25+ years have had ample time to develop to the level of excellence and consistency that we have hoped- and in some cases as with Travis- expected.

Daniher had three or four attempts at building 'his' list in his ten year period as coach, and unfortunately for him (and all MFC supporters) it was not good enough to take us all the way. With that in mind, Bailey should be looking to move-on the inconsistent performers from that period and develop 'his' list from the current crop of youngsters already at our disposal, and through the draft. This is the perfect chance to build a side that can be seriously competetive in 2-3 years time, ala Hawthorn's aggressive trading for picks in 2004-05.

Whilst we certainly require both key forwards and defenders, we would be crazy not to go for the best availble at pick 4. If we had another top ten selection we could then look to draft on a "needs" basis, without the shadow of another Chris Lamb/ Luke Molan situation hanging over our heads.

[jacey 333]

yeah, mitch was a father son, but ive heard they are regretting it (mitch has a bit of an attitude too)

mitch should be a at richmond next year, and where cale will be is up in the air, cant see him going past the top 6 or so, but i dont think he'll be at west coast

Kruezer will go number one and Cotchin is near certainty to go number 2.

Cotchin was training with Richmond last preseason and from what Nathan Brown says, the tiggers are very impressed. (We all know NB has a say since his dad coaches them.)

I'm just wondering if Mitch Morton went father son, how come Cale isn't. Aren't they brothers?

[Gouga 512]

Yes Travis has been a disappointment, not because he hasn't played great games, but because he hasn't done it on a consistent basis. Green on the other hand has always been consistent without being outstanding (except for a few early games).

My point is Johnstone's upside is greater than Green's, and in the hope that Bailey can get the best out of all players on our list, I'd make the hard call and trade Green.

Green may infact have a greater trade value than Johnstone, I know St.Kilda has expressed an interest in the past.

We could get an early second round pick for Green. That pick could then be traded for a younger player that is yet to establish himself at another club such as Drum (Fre), Prismall (Geel) or Tenance (Geel). I'd also trade Wheatley for a third round pick which can be traded for Meesen.

That leaves our original picks 4, 21, 37, 53, 69, 85 to be used on draft day.

[Demon Disciple 11,139]

IMO, we need a KPF, KPB, Fast midfielder and a ruckman

if we are able to obtain a 2nd top 10 pick, we can take 2 of those needs out. we trade for the others or get them in next years draft.

with Robbo signing on for another 2 years, and with the emergence of the future greatest all-time goal kicker in Newton, our KPF can go on hold until next year (unless Henderson slips to pick 21 )

i reckon we go for our fast midfielder with the first pick, if we get another top 10 pick we should get Rance, and if Bellchambers is around (or maybe McEvoy, i can dream ) at pick 21, get him.

That's not assuming we don't upgrade our 2nd round pick, or get another 2nd round pick through trade.

[Bruce Almighty 0]

Does anyone know if Richmond will go for Cotchin if not i dont think west coast will grab him, i think they will go for Masten or Palmer. I hope we snag Cotchin with pick 4.

[Diablo 1]

Yes Travis has been a disappointment, not because he hasn't played great games, but because he hasn't done it on a consistent basis. Green on the other hand has always been consistent without being outstanding (except for a few early games).

My point is Johnstone's upside is greater than Green's, and in the hope that Bailey can get the best out of all players on our list, I'd make the hard call and trade Green.

Green may infact have a greater trade value than Johnstone, I know St.Kilda has expressed an interest in the past.

We could get an early second round pick for Green. That pick could then be traded for a younger player that is yet to establish himself at another club such as Drum (Fre), Prismall (Geel) or Tenance (Geel). I'd also trade Wheatley for a third round pick which can be traded for Meesen.

That leaves our original picks 4, 21, 37, 53, 69, 85 to be used on draft day.

Frankly, if we traded Green and wound up with any of those 3 players I'd be pretty miffed. I'd rather trade Green and our second rounder for another 1st round pick, if we were going to trade Green at all. Picks outside of the top 25-30 this year are worth sweet FA. Top 10-15 picks are the way forward for us. If we can get 2 I'll be stoked. 3 (very unlikely) and I'd be in rapture.

[brey9186 102]

changed the rules since mitch morton was a fattherson pickup, other brother jarryd went the hawks last year too

[Gouga 512]

Frankly, if we traded Green and wound up with any of those 3 players I'd be pretty miffed. I'd rather trade Green and our second rounder for another 1st round pick, if we were going to trade Green at all. Picks outside of the top 25-30 this year are worth sweet FA. Top 10-15 picks are the way forward for us. If we can get 2 I'll be stoked. 3 (very unlikely) and I'd be in rapture.

I agree but teams are not going to part with their first round picks. If we trade anybody, Johnstone included, we are looking at a second round pick. But by trading that second round pick for a youngster like those I mentioned we would be making the most of a shallow draft.

[Yencks 8]

is there anywhere where we can see footage of the draft boys this year? sorry to be a [censored] but i have no idea. where does everyone find out all of the information about the draft?

[sylvinator 96]

i think people will find that picks 2 and 3 are not locked in.

many phantom drafts have Palmer at pick 3. wouldnt be surprised if Rance got a look in.

for pick 4 it depends what we prioritize:

Ruckman- Mcevoy

Key forward- henderson

key back- Rance

midfielder- Morton/Masten/Palmer/Ebert...

any of these 7 i'd be stoked with.

up to CAC which of these he favours.

agree a second top 10 pick would be invaluable

[deanox 8,795]

Ruckman- Mcevoy

Key forward- henderson

key back- Rance

midfielder- Morton/Masten/Palmer/Ebert...

this is exactly why i advocate picking up a KPP with your first pick IF he is good enough, and in the same league as the others available (ie luke molan wasnt just a KP he was apparently a tough KPP).

there is one KPF and one KPD listed as goers for the top 7 or 8. they are harder to come by than any of the four mids who could make it...

[issarab 0]

I think Palmer and Masten have huge potential but we are desperate for KPP Players and Rance and Henderson are the standouts our half forward line maybe

Masten Bate Palmer imagine that being read out .

[dee-luded 2,958]

i think people will find that picks 2 and 3 are not locked in.

many phantom drafts have Palmer at pick 3. wouldnt be surprised if Rance got a look in.

for pick 4 it depends what we prioritize:

Ruckman- Mcevoy

Key forward- henderson

key back- Rance

midfielder- Morton/Masten/Palmer/Ebert...

any of these 7 i'd be stoked with.

up to CAC which of these he favours.

agree a second top 10 pick would be invaluable

Yep, thats exactly how I've been thinking as well.

Ps. If the Doggies don't trade for a Key forward I think they'll grab Henderson.

P

[Mick 1]

Do we have any REAL under 18 watchers on Demonology? Not having a go at people but most people seem to be going based on what they've read elsewhere, one game (WA v Vic shown on Foxtel) and maybe some YouTube clips. Unfortunately I'm only going by the same.

But do we have anyone on here who really watches TAC Cup and juniors in other states closely and can give a bit more insight based on first hand knowledge?

Btw, I agree with others that we need to go for the best available with our first pick (we need stars in our team, regardless of what position they play) and would also love to trade for another top 10-15 pick. I love the sound of the Sydney trade.

[Demons 32 235]

I love the sound of the Sydney trade.

Yeah ive actually jumped on this bandwagon.

One of our best player and pick 21 for Jolly and pick 11 sounds great.

[Mick 1]

Yeah ive actually jumped on this bandwagon.

One of our best player and pick 21 for Jolly and pick 11 sounds great.

Swap Jolly for Buchanan...that's the trade I meant

[Demons 32 235]

Swap Jolly for Buchanan...that's the trade I meant

What?

[StevenStretch 1]

If we want some gauranteed enjoyment out of next year we want Mastern, only for the simple fact he could possibly line up along side Bate...

[Jerry Lundergard 392]

I think we should draft a key foward or a gun midfielder with pick #4.

My reasons for this are that when i look around the league at gun players in the positions of either a backmen or a ruckman, were any of these guys actually top draft picks? I haven't done the appropriate research, so feel free to correct if i am wrong.

These are some of the top backmen. Glass, Rutten, Scarlett(father/son), Egan, Barry, Fletcher(father/son). Where any of these guys top draft picks?

The three best ruckmen this year were Cox, Lade and McIntosh. Fraser and White were both No 1. picks, but are not dominant ruckmen(hopefully Kruezer falls into this catergory).

My point is, i think that fowards and midfielders are a much safer bet for using such a high draft pick, as it seems to me that backmen and ruckmen can be developed from picks further down.

[Demon Disciple 11,139]

Before the AFL introduced the new center circle rule, White was the dominant ruckman of the AFL, so he did live up to the hype of being a #1 pick.

I know that Cox came off the rookie list.

[jacey 333]

These are some of the top backmen. Glass, Rutten, Scarlett(father/son), Egan, Barry, Fletcher(father/son). Where any of these guys top draft picks?

The three best ruckmen this year were Cox, Lade and McIntosh. Fraser and White were both No 1. picks, but are not dominant ruckmen(hopefully Kruezer falls into this catergory).

Glass was pick 8 from memory.

Rutten Rookie

Scarlett/Fletcher F/S

Egan pick 62

Barry Pick 30's i think

McIntosh was pick 8 too.

You pick the best talent regardless of size. (If you pick the best KPP when there's better mids, u could end up with a Molan or a Tim Walsh)

If Rance is worthy of pick 4 so be it but there's big wraps on Ebert. Tagged but still did well. Showed fantastic leadership.

Palmer. Dominated the carnival and still slaying them in the WA. Impressive Midfield Goal kicker. (hmm probably not as good but...sounds familar to a certain somebody who was drafted to Weagles 6 years ago).

[mo64 5,262]

Draft best available player, and trade for needs.

I don't get excited about KP backman who dominate at under 18 level. If they're that talented, they'd be a forward. Case in point, Lachlan Hansen at the Roos.

[StevenStretch 1]

thats rediculous not drafting for backman, you will find (except the super freaks) that most kids in the junior ranks that play back make better forwards, they understand the work rate much better, and if your a KPB you know how hard you have to work to make a good fwd coz you've played on the good ones and played on the duds, providing you can kick a footy and take a grab I would have no hesitation drafting someone from a backline in the TAC cup etc.