🥴

Not the first time this season I've heard of players being very ill during the week and still playing on the weekend.

You'd think we're racing for a flag.

Ridiculously and needlessly careless at this stage of the season.

3 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

Not the first time this season I've heard of players being very ill during the week and still playing on the weekend.

You'd think we're racing for a flag.

Ridiculously and needlessly careless at this stage of the season.

i get ill watching them

4 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

Not the first time this season I've heard of players being very ill during the week and still playing on the weekend.

You'd think we're racing for a flag.

Ridiculously and needlessly careless at this stage of the season.

It’s absolutely crazy.

4 minutes ago, ANG13 said:

It’s absolutely crazy.

Thatdoesnt even begin to describe the absolute stupidity and unnecessary risk

Goodwin is now an absolute desperardo trying to save his ****

Shocked Gary Lyon didn’t put Ashton Moir in his AFL 360 MVP 3-2-1 votes for the round, given the over compensating his done against his own side for the entire year.

1 hour ago, dazzledavey36 said:

🥴

The club is taking the [censored] at this point

Their refusal to use any different midfielders - even when one is SICK WITH THE FLU - is becoming a joke

Why couldn’t Rivers take his role for that game? Why couldn’t Langford get some CBA exposure? Hell I’d even take bringing Laurie in for a game to give him a go

For anyone who can’t see how stubborn Goodwin is, this should show them exactly the kind of mindset he has

And it’s going to run the club into the ground next year if he’s still our coach

1 hour ago, ANG13 said:

It’s absolutely crazy.

What's even more funny is that even though he was bed ridden with the flu we still played him majority of the midfield minutes 🤣

Poor Trent Rivers thinking to himself what more doe he need to do to get a look in..

Edited July 22Jul 22 by dazzledavey36

1 hour ago, Jaded No More said:

Ridiculously and needlessly careless at this stage of the season.

I reckon I can be convinced on lots of outwardly counterintuitive things as they relate to footy. This is one that not even the strongest argument would turn me around on.

Yes, footy careers are short. Yes, you need to make every game count. No, you don't need to play when very unwell or seriously affected by injured.

A half-fit X is better than a fully fit Y is one of the stupidest cliches in all of top level team sport - far stupider in an 18-person game.

1 minute ago, The Taciturn Demon said:

A half-fit X is better than a fully fit Y is one of the stupidest cliches in all of top level team sport - far stupider in an 18-person game.

I mean that's not totally true, because even when sick some players are simply still better than the alternative.

If this was a final, or we had to win this game to make finals, you take a risk and back in your best players. We did that with May in the GF and it worked.

But the season is so dead it's cold, and this is when these types of arguments are irrelevant.

We had a golden opportunity to rest Trac and mix things up, and we chose not to. Instead we pushed him through illness, and we still lost. Great work.

On 20/07/2025 at 15:36, Previously known as LITD. said:

I thought our average age for our premiership team was quite young.

Apart from our fwd line collapsing, what happened?

Do they just lose their appetite? And if so, why?

We never replaced Jackson Brayshaw ANB or Hibberd . Each had a specialrole.

4 minutes ago, 48 Year Now said:

We never replaced Jackson Brayshaw ANB or Hibberd . Each had a specialrole.

Nor BBB

15 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

I mean that's not totally true, because even when sick some players are simply still better than the alternative.

If this was a final, or we had to win this game to make finals, you take a risk and back in your best players. We did that with May in the GF and it worked.

But the season is so dead it's cold, and this is when these types of arguments are irrelevant.

We had a golden opportunity to rest Trac and mix things up, and we chose not to. Instead we pushed him through illness, and we still lost. Great work.

Low iq coach so many examples

7 hours ago, ElDiablo14 said:

Remember the other plays like that mark not paid to JVR right in front of goal. Then the ball goes to their fwd 50 and goal.

12 point swing in under a minute.

2 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

🥴

Geez we are amateurs. Reeks of desperation and Goody trying to eek out a win at all costs.

At least he played better than Brent Moloney in THAT game.

53 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Nor BBB

Oh yes. What a recruit.

Not one like for like replacement with our recruitment.

Maybe - Jeffo for Brown

9 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

🥴

This is just astonishing

What a shambles of a club we are. Did Trac think he was some sort of hero playing like that an helping us?

For goody, what a chance this was to try Rivers or Langford, instead he kept his same 4

What a joke

8 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

What's even more funny is that even though he was bed ridden with the flu we still played him majority of the midfield minutes 🤣

Poor Trent Rivers thinking to himself what more doe he need to do to get a look in..

IMO, this is the reason why I'm over Goody.

Last season we wasted the whole year only to find this gem in the middle, play the whole pre season there, only to shaft him to the backline ALL YEAR and not even TRY him once there

I see in the other thread, a reliable poster has said Oliver believes the game has passed him by. All teams have moved on with pace in the midfield (adelaide, freo) and we continue to play the slow bulls who can't kick in the middle while Rivers rots in the backline

Better hope his missus convinces him Victoria is the place to be because I'm sure a trip home to reunite with his former midfield coach will be back on the cards.

I've said it for 4 years. Our FD sucks. I'm glad to see some are waking up to it.

Only way it all changes at once is for Goodwin to roll. And it ain't happening with no CEO or President.

2 minutes ago, Deez21 said:

IMO, this is the reason why I'm over Goody.

Last season we wasted the whole year only to find this gem in the middle, play the whole pre season there, only to shaft him to the backline ALL YEAR and not even TRY him once there

I see in the other thread, a reliable poster has said Oliver believes the game has passed him by. All teams have moved on with pace in the midfield (adelaide, freo) and we continue to play the slow bulls who can't kick in the middle while Rivers rots in the backline

Better hope his missus convinces him Victoria is the place to be because I'm sure a trip home to reunite with his former midfield coach will be back on the cards.

Mate I agree..

As tough as it would i wouldnt blame Rivers if he decided to request a trade to West Coast just further enhance his talent and ability by playing more midfield time at the eagle.

He'd actually be a gun in their mid alongside Harley Reid.

The treatment by Goodwin towards River has been not only mind boggling but pretty pathetic actually.

on Petracca playing with the flu - I keep saying it, we are not a serious club.

Dead rubber, play a star with the flu

Heads should roll

I wonder if all this bubbling tension of Curnow wanting to leave was put to rest last week which led to Curnow's uptick in enthusiasm against us. If we had faced them a week earlier we probably would have rolled them by 3 goals.

35 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Mate I agree..

As tough as it would i wouldnt blame Rivers if he decided to request a trade to West Coast just further enhance his talent and ability by playing more midfield time at the eagle.

He'd actually be a gun in their mid alongside Harley Reid.

The treatment by Goodwin towards River has been not only mind boggling but pretty pathetic actually.

Wondering if thats why McVee hasn't signed,clubs a basket case

Docherty retiring next game. Wowee. What a crazy career. More lows than highs. 3 x ACL, 2 x cancers, and a life at carlton.

Was going to post during the game day thread about being angry and [censored] off about a carlton set shot that pretty much ended our night but then it was Doch having the shot and to be honest I was actually OK with if. Great bloke had a [censored], really [censored] few years out of his 14 in the league. Wish him the best - perhaps we would be wise in finding him a post playing role at our club and teach our boys about resilience

Edited July 22Jul 22 by Sideshow Bob
.

Post after post after post of outrage on the back of a CalTwomey article... Oh please!

Is this the same guy?

"THE AFL'S decision to delay a rule change until 2025 seems likely to scupper any monster trade this year involving disgruntled Melbourne star, Christian Petracca.

That's the opinion of AFL.com.au's trade expert Cal Twomey, who says clubs are unlikely to be able to offer enough high-end draft picks to lure the four-time All-Australian out of the Demons this off-season."

"It could be a good result for all parties to see him go to another club." - @CalTwomey on Christian Petracca Watch @gettable_afl now: ...