Barely a player on our list that hasn’t been written of by Demonland in their first few years- including players who have left the club and are player regular football elsewhere.

ANB was a liability.

Beford was not a ball winner.

Jordon had no weapons.

Don’t get me started on the impatience with Gawn, McDonald, Brayshaw, or the huge error of drafting Kossie over Weightman. Gameday thread in Petracc’s first game referred to him a a one speed ‘plodder’.

Most kids take time; few burst out of the blocks and sustain it. Some will make it and some won’t, but two thirds of the way through their second year, following a massive injury lay off is too early to make a statement one way or the other.

Of our many issues, Kolt ain’t one of them.

6 hours ago, Pirlo said:

Kolt has yet to show more than a handful of glimpses in 19 games, and that's the occasional goal or good kick inside 50 rather than anything groundbreaking. He has, for example, yet to deliver anything more exceptional than what Brown did on debut. It is hard to see how he keeps getting senior games, even in our current rudderless phase of the season. Jefferson also doesn't look ready, but he's a year older and dominates at Casey.

The difference is, IMO, Jefferson has at least shown moments where I think “maybe, just maybe” there’s something. Tholstrup (once again, IMO) hasn’t even shown that.

2 hours ago, Ghostwriter said:

😂 Big thanks. This made me laugh on an otherwise depressing day. Love you, J.

You’re welcome. Keep laughing my friend ❤️

3 hours ago, TeamPlayedFine39 said:

Barely a player on our list that hasn’t been written of by Demonland in their first few years- including players who have left the club and are player regular football elsewhere.

ANB was a liability.

Beford was not a ball winner.

Jordon had no weapons.

Don’t get me started on the impatience with Gawn, McDonald, Brayshaw, or the huge error of drafting Kossie over Weightman. Gameday thread in Petracc’s first game referred to him a a one speed ‘plodder’.

Most kids take time; few burst out of the blocks and sustain it. Some will make it and some won’t, but two thirds of the way through their second year, following a massive injury lay off is too early to make a statement one way or the other.

Of our many issues, Kolt ain’t one of them.

Think you are missing the point - which is that Kolt has been woefully mismanaged this year.

He was rushed into the firsts with no form & not much fitness.

He should have spent a month at Casey building up both.

This is a dreadful way to manage a young player.

Lindsay & Windsor & McVee have also been poorly managed this year.

1 minute ago, Cranky Franky said:

Think you are missing the point - which is that Kolt has been woefully mismanaged this year.

He was rushed into the firsts with no form & not much fitness.

He should have spent a month at Casey building up both.

This is a dreadful way to manage a young player.

Lindsay & Windsor & McVee have also been poorly managed this year.

Anything related to management is not what I was responding to.

It’s silly to write someone off who’s had two years in the system and one has been marred by an interrupted pre season.

Likewise it’s ok to admit that Kolt isn’t being helped playing seniors right now. He is barely getting the ball, and when he does get it, he isn’t using it well.

I don’t think he’d be thinking he’s performing well himself, and to keep rewarding him with games at this level where he’s often subbed off, is a bit silly.

It also makes a mockery of guys like Laurie who are consistently performing at Casey and knocking the door down each and every week.

For his sake I hope he goes back to Casey and gets to play some midfield minutes for the rest of the year. Get his hands on the footy and set himself up for a massive pre season.

4 hours ago, TeamPlayedFine39 said:

Barely a player on our list that hasn’t been written of by Demonland in their first few years- including players who have left the club and are player regular football elsewhere.

ANB was a liability.

Beford was not a ball winner.

Jordon had no weapons.

Don’t get me started on the impatience with Gawn, McDonald, Brayshaw, or the huge error of drafting Kossie over Weightman. Gameday thread in Petracc’s first game referred to him a a one speed ‘plodder’.

Most kids take time; few burst out of the blocks and sustain it. Some will make it and some won’t, but two thirds of the way through their second year, following a massive injury lay off is too early to make a statement one way or the other.

Of our many issues, Kolt ain’t one of them.

Jordon always had two weapons and everyone knew about them. He could kick it 50 metres and he could run all day. That wasn't so valuable on the MCG when teams just set a man down the line on his wing, but is much more important at the SCG which has 10 fewer metres at each end.

Sydney saw his attributes and decided he could be a contributor. That's what good scouting is.

Bedford told us he wanted to leave, he had plenty of admirers at MFC. He was a victim of the 2022 "let's never, ever rotate a Premiership player, even if they can barely run they're so tired/injured" policy.

1 hour ago, Jaded No More said:

It’s silly to write someone off who’s had two years in the system and one has been marred by an interrupted pre season.

Likewise it’s ok to admit that Kolt isn’t being helped playing seniors right now. He is barely getting the ball, and when he does get it, he isn’t using it well.

I don’t think he’d be thinking he’s performing well himself, and to keep rewarding him with games at this level where he’s often subbed off, is a bit silly.

It also makes a mockery of guys like Laurie who are consistently performing at Casey and knocking the door down each and every week.

For his sake I hope he goes back to Casey and gets to play some midfield minutes for the rest of the year. Get his hands on the footy and set himself up for a massive pre season.

I'm not writing him off, I would like him to play out the season but I'm really struggling to see much to get excited about.

Like Windsor has had a poor season but I know exactly what kind of player he can turn into.

With Kolt I'm just not sure what sort of player he will be in 5 years time. What seperates him from Taj Woewodin, Bailey Laurie or Kynan Brown?

Edited 4 hours ago4 hr by KozzyCan

1 minute ago, KozzyCan said:

I'm not writing him off, I would like him to play out the season but I'm really struggling to see much to get excited about.

Like Windsor has had a poor season but I know exactly what kind of player he can turn into.

With Kolt I'm just not sure what sort of player he will be in 5 years time. What seperates him from Taj Woewodin, Jake Bowey or Kynan Brown?

I’m with you in that I’m not sure what type of player Kolt can be. His attributes don’t jump out at me like with say Windsor having elite speed and endurance and a neat kick.

Or Langford who is a physical beast but with time and poise and beautiful decision making and ball use. Or Lindsay who has time and space whenever he gets the ball.

I know Kolt is rated highly for his attitude and that’s a very important trait, but it’s not enough right now. I think half forward is a useless position for a kid trying to get his hands dirty, and he’d be better off going to Casey and playing mid/wing or even half back. Get the ball in his hands and get him some confidence.

Rotting at half forward and getting 2 touches before being subbed off is not exactly progressing him in the right direction.

20 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

I’m with you in that I’m not sure what type of player Kolt can be. His attributes don’t jump out at me like with say Windsor having elite speed and endurance and a neat kick.

Or Langford who is a physical beast but with time and poise and beautiful decision making and ball use. Or Lindsay who has time and space whenever he gets the ball.

I know Kolt is rated highly for his attitude and that’s a very important trait, but it’s not enough right now. I think half forward is a useless position for a kid trying to get his hands dirty, and he’d be better off going to Casey and playing mid/wing or even half back. Get the ball in his hands and get him some confidence.

Rotting at half forward and getting 2 touches before being subbed off is not exactly progressing him in the right direction.

He is loyal, cares so much about the club and wants to do well. Apparently they're the traits he has according to what the learned footy observers tell me. How dare we even question that.

Note: I agree with you entirely here.

I dont get the "poorly managed" thing. Dont these guys want to play AFL? Do they not put their hand up at training and say Im ready to go? And they are not kids!

Tholstrup is a bust, cut him loose. Windsor is playing back because they want him to learn defence. McVee has gone backwards, couldnt care less if he left, hope he does. Lindsay will be a player.

Kolt hasn't shown much buts its clear that he's being treated differently to KBrown and BLaurie