WC just received draft assistance end of first round pick 19

afl.com.au

Eagles 'take responsibility for previous decisions' as AF...

The AFL has revealed the assistance package handed to West Coast

Hello Judd!

26 minutes ago, old55 said:

WC just received draft assistance end of first round pick 19

Hello Judd!

will be a mid 20’s pick no doubt, which is probably around his worth

If WC were interested in Judd, and Judd was interested in them, then there’s nothing stopping them from taking him to the PSD. And we sure as hell aren’t getting that pick 19 while they have the psd threat

19 minutes ago, mmwd6 said:

If WC were interested in Judd, and Judd was interested in them, then there’s nothing stopping them from taking him to the PSD. And we sure as hell aren’t getting that pick 19 while they have the psd threat

Clubs very rarely go straight there. WC negotiate in good faith first and offer pick 19, Judd has a decision to make but probably still wants to go to Freo but now there's a real bid that Freo need to at least match, if they don't and Judd holds firm and so does MFC ... well there's the PSD and WC tried their best but were forced to go there.

8 minutes ago, old55 said:

Clubs very rarely go straight there. WC negotiate in good faith first and offer pick 19, Judd has a decision to make but probably still wants to go to Freo but now there's a real bid that Freo need to at least match, if they don't and Judd holds firm and so does MFC ... well there's the PSD and WC tried their best but were forced to go there.

Fans love to bring this up every time a player requests a trade. That’s just not how it works. When a player nominates a club you will be dealing with that club only. No matter what WC offer we won’t be dealing with them since Judd doesn’t want to go there. He’s not contracted to the club anymore so we can’t pick and choose.

1 minute ago, mmwd6 said:

Fans love to bring this up every time a player requests a trade. That’s just not how it works. When a player nominates a club you will be dealing with that club only. No matter what WC offer we won’t be dealing with them since Judd doesn’t want to go there. He’s not contracted to the club anymore so we can’t pick and choose.

I don't think you understood my post.

4 minutes ago, mmwd6 said:

Fans love to bring this up every time a player requests a trade. That’s just not how it works. When a player nominates a club you will be dealing with that club only. No matter what WC offer we won’t be dealing with them since Judd doesn’t want to go there. He’s not contracted to the club anymore so we can’t pick and choose.

I wonder what Mitch Clark is up to these days

23 hours ago, doomsday dee said:

A attacking game style sounds great but what will happen if say a Cameron kicks 5 on Howes,Bowie or Salem,with a quarter to go,will be back to McVee🤔

The same thing happened with Jeremy Howe, wanted to play forward. Buckley and Collingwood sold him on being that forward at Collingwood and guess where he's played ever since they figured he wasn't the forward they needed.

He's been a back man for them and Roos was right all along.

No guarantee the same thing won't happen to McVee at Freo...Cameron kicks 5 and who is Longmuir going to move onto him.. just a tip, it's not going to be Clark.

40 minutes ago, rjay said:

The same thing happened with Jeremy Howe, wanted to play forward. Buckley and Collingwood sold him on being that forward at Collingwood and guess where he's played ever since they figured he wasn't the forward they needed.

He's been a back man for them and Roos was right all along.

No guarantee the same thing won't happen to McVee at Freo...Cameron kicks 5 and who is Longmuir going to move onto him.. just a tip, it's not going to be Clark.

They have Brandon Walker who locks down the smalls if they want to use him. And if they don’t we should be ringing up his manager ASAP

5 hours ago, mmwd6 said:

Clark got turned into an AA by the dockers. They’ve sold that same vision to Judd. And they have Bailey Banfield playing off half back so they sure have room for him to slot in. Actually off the top of my head I can’t think of any other running half backs they have aside from Clark.

11 minutes ago, Rab D Nesbitt said:

This is the only hat I'd take off for Freo, TL.

1 hour ago, rjay said:

The same thing happened with Jeremy Howe, wanted to play forward. Buckley and Collingwood sold him on being that forward at Collingwood and guess where he's played ever since they figured he wasn't the forward they needed.

He's been a back man for them and Roos was right all along.

No guarantee the same thing won't happen to McVee at Freo...Cameron kicks 5 and who is Longmuir going to move onto him.. just a tip, it's not going to be Clark.

Wont be McVee,they have a lock.freo will have another Clarke and you can take that to the bank

2 minutes ago, doomsday dee said:

Wont be McVee,they have a lock.freo will have another Clarke and you can take that to the bank

Or the trade table at least. What's a future AA running HB worth?

Pick 11 sounds like a good start.

17 hours ago, layzie said:

Good call.

An even better call was my posting while Clark was playing in the VFL for the Cats and before leaving was even mentioned, that we should go after him.

The exact same scenario happened for Bolton, Treacy and Meek existed when I also posted often about them.

I don’t write this to show that I am brilliant, which of course I am, but rather to highlight the disappointment I have, that we got none of them.

I don’t need the excuses about each player as I already know them, but the disappointment is still there anyway.

Apparently we never even tried to get any of them.

That is disappointing to me.

Given the players we have traded in in the same period, it is more disappointing.

Anyway here’s hoping we get a few good ones this off season.

5 hours ago, ChaserJ said:

Or the trade table at least. What's a future AA running HB worth?

Pick 11 sounds like a good start.

And a player rated in the top 10 players of those mentioned as possible trades this trade period.

Yes pick 11 is the start and maybe the finish too, or a player we all like and value, can go home but to WC.

8 hours ago, doomsday dee said:

Wont be McVee,they have a lock.freo will have another Clarke and you can take that to the bank

History can be insightful. Howe was playing forward until injury (to defenders) forced him back which is where he has remained for his career apart from a few cameo's forward.

Turns out he's good at it.

Nothing is a given.

Edited September 30Sep 30 by rjay

12 hours ago, old55 said:

WC just received draft assistance end of first round pick 19

afl.com.au

Eagles 'take responsibility for previous decisions' as AF...

The AFL has revealed the assistance package handed to West Coast

Hello Judd!

They'll use that to get Starcevich

39 minutes ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

They'll use that to get Starcevich

Another rote form the AFL.

WCE ask for allowance outside of the rules to bring in FA Starcevich and not at the same time dilute the FA compo they are going to receive from loosing Allen. AFL say no, however how about we give you an end of first round pick and you can use that to trade for Stracevich, giving the premiers a pick in the first round instead on any FA compo pick???

44 minutes ago, BangBnagBang said:

Another rote form the AFL.

WCE ask for allowance outside of the rules to bring in FA Starcevich and not at the same time dilute the FA compo they are going to receive from loosing Allen. AFL say no, however how about we give you an end of first round pick and you can use that to trade for Stracevich, giving the premiers a pick in the first round instead on any FA compo pick???

Colour me shocked

My final word on Judd McVee

Premiership Player

Important member of our Premiership team, a Premiership I thought i would never see in my lifetime. Thanks Judd, all the best back home with family and friends.

3 minutes ago, 48 Year Now said:

My final word on Judd McVee

Premiership Player

Important member of our Premiership team, a Premiership I thought i would never see in my lifetime. Thanks Judd, all the best back home with family and friends.

ummmm

4 minutes ago, 48 Year Now said:

My final word on Judd McVee

Premiership Player

Important member of our Premiership team, a Premiership I thought i would never see in my lifetime. Thanks Judd, all the best back home with family and friends.

Reality update: Casey 2022.

6 minutes ago, 48 Year Now said:

My final word on Judd McVee

Premiership Player

Important member of our Premiership team, a Premiership I thought i would never see in my lifetime. Thanks Judd, all the best back home with family and friends.

This might be your second last word on Judd.

5 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

ummmm

DC depending on how the roulette wheel spins between 14 - 17 premiership heroes will remain on our list in 2026.

Edited October 1Oct 1 by Tarax Club

10 minutes ago, Dee Zephyr said:

This might be your second last word on Judd.

Indeed😀

7 hours ago, Redleg said:

The exact same scenario happened for Bolton, Treacy and Meek existed when I also posted often about them.

Shai Bolton? Not sure there was ever a time for us to make a move for him.

We were heavily linked to Meek when we lost Jackson got Grundy. Meek might’ve even been first choice.

A mega deal for Treacy after first few years would’ve been super gusty but turned out great. He signed a 3 year deal in 2023 indicating interest from someone, you’d hope one of those teams would’ve been us. Upped it to a 4 year extension in 2024 when he broke out tying him until 2030.

But hey, let’s go one better and hire David Walls as our head of footy. Freo do a great job improving their list year on year.

13 minutes ago, DeeSpencer said:

Shai Bolton? Not sure there was ever a time for us to make a move for him.

We were heavily linked to Meek when we lost Jackson got Grundy. Meek might’ve even been first choice.

A mega deal for Treacy after first few years would’ve been super gusty but turned out great. He signed a 3 year deal in 2023 indicating interest from someone, you’d hope one of those teams would’ve been us. Upped it to a 4 year extension in 2024 when he broke out tying him until 2030.

But hey, let’s go one better and hire David Walls as our head of footy. Freo do a great job improving their list year on year.

Meek should've been steak knives in the Jackson deal then. Hell even get Rory Lobb in that year and we probably make the gf in 2023.