Why we wont win a grand final soon

[Rab D Nesbitt 8,367]

I’m sure the Dogs weren’t thinking they were premiership material after round 10 of 2016. Let’s just enjoy the ride and see where it takes us. 

 

[siam juntaRus 92]

My only concern is that we still have that 'soft' reputation with the other clubs.They always lift against us because you know youre always a chance against Melbourne. The crows game was the classic example 3 goals down with  minutes left they never gave up - with help from the umps- and won.They would have given up against a Richmond or Geelong side. Even if we beat the bulldogs and/or lions Collingwood will fire up agaInst us on the MCG on QB  they could beat us.

I still think dees can finish top 2 so long as no more serious injuries and viney's foot doesnt fall off.

[TeamPlayedFine39 8,503]

Until we can figure out a way to beat Richmond and Geelong at the MCG, then... oh, hang-on...

 

 

[Dr. Gonzo 24,209]

[censored] off with this negative [censored]

[YesitwasaWin4theAges 6,702]

Saturday's loss while is hurt has been taken right out of context.

We have won the most quarters against top 8 teams everybody.

We are 9-1

Close thread ffs.

 

Edited May 24, 2021 by Win4theAges

[Young Blood 2,620]

Can we please close this thread?

[siam juntaRus 92]

2 minutes ago, TeamPlayedFine39 said:

Until we can figure out a way to beat Richmond and Geelong at the MCG, then... oh, hang-on...

 

 

True, thats why i said Melbourne should aim to finish top 2 not 4.

That doesnt mean that sides like Collingwood and Hawthorn wont lift against us.

That notorious last quarter in  1992 against Essendon when we were 51 points in front  with 18 minutes to go and LOST did us alot of damage. Did basically the same thing against Geelong  just a few seasons back.

[picket fence 17,146]

1 hour ago, dazzledavey36 said:

1 loss and you might as well close the shop. 

Classic demonland.

And a freakishly unlucky loss at that. I do not and never have bought into the myth regarding "The loss we had to have" that is classic losing mentality!

[gregdemon 624]

1 hour ago, John Crow Batty said:

I’m not prepared to throw in the towel yet. Adelaide were s**t hot on Saturday. We played well except for lapses when comfortably in front. We and they never gave up. They got lucky in the end and we were not smart enough to close the game down.  What irks me though is that most losing opposition side don’t seem to throw in the towel when playing us. They know we don’t have a killer instinct and always think they have a chance. We needs a step up in ruthlessness and intimidate.

 

 

Very valid we never win by much    not like doggies   but still wrapt with the year so far  At start of  I never would have thought we would be 9 and 1 (I did expect finals given last year form at times)   So....... so far well bowled  by Goody and the coaching panel and players ...... very well bowled !!

[M_9 2,082]

1 hour ago, Rab D Nesbitt said:

I’m sure the Dogs weren’t thinking they were premiership material after round 10 of 2016. Let’s just enjoy the ride and see where it takes us. 

 

It was the form of Tom Boyd in the GF that got them over the line.

14 disposals, 8 marks, 3 goals 2.

In the lead up 14 games he'd kicked a total of 10 goals and had been goal-less in 8 games.

Weid stepped up in two finals in 2018. I'm not prepared to write him off yet.

[58er 6,425]

52 minutes ago, siam juntaRus said:

True, thats why i said Melbourne should aim to finish top 2 not 4.

That doesnt mean that sides like Collingwood and Hawthorn wont lift against us.

That notorious last quarter in  1992 against Essendon when we were 51 points in front  with 18 minutes to go and LOST did us alot of damage. Did basically the same thing against Geelong  just a few seasons back.

Come on be real 

We are not suffering because of that 1992 result now!! That's ridiculous!

in 2018 we lost at the Cattery after being 5 goals up at 3/4 time. We beat them in the Elim final about 5 weeks later!!

You will have to come up with better than that !! 

[Spargonicus 539]

2 hours ago, Smokey said:

9-1 and apparently the sky is falling. Take a deep breath everyone, we we're beaten for the first time this year against a team at home playing well. So what, it's not like we were never gonna lose a game again ... 

[Ted Lasso 19,513]

Defense wins championships, this is a universal fact in all team sports, and we have the best defense in the AFL. yes there are areas to work on, but we're 9-1 we probably only need to win 1-2 more games to lock up finals and 4-5 to lock in top 4. we've got time. 

we are a massive chance to win the premiership, and we're up against our biggest competition on Friday night on their home deck. 

I'm expecting a strong response to the Crows loss and our 10th win.

[gregdemon 624]

really worried about the doggies (obviously)     We had a ball breaker game some players looked tired     Max I am sure needs a rest  6 day break and the doggies had a light training run in their game.     Would be a great win if we can pull it off   Go dees

Selection has to be spot on which I am sure it will be.   WEID out Jetta out        Salem   Brown in

 

[Guest]

1 hour ago, siam juntaRus said:

I still think dees can finish top 2 so long as no more serious injuries and viney's foot doesnt fall off.

I’m half-expecting some clown on here to chime in with, “even if Viney’s foot did drop off he’d still play better than most of our boys did on the weekend,” or similar. 
Critiquing is one thing. But brutal, scathing no-holds-barred attacks are totally undue. And NOT cool.  

[Marty 419]

Too early in the year to focus on the GF.

After the last 2 years, I’m just focused on the positives, like...
We are on the same amount of wins this season as Collingwood, Carlton, Hawthorn and North Melbourne combined. 

[Young Blood 2,620]

Should I start another boringly trivial thread called 'why we might win a flag this year'?

[Adam The God 30,222]

Haha, like clockwork. Lose one game and all of a sudden we can't win the flag and we have problems across all lines.

I wonder what you would have been saying about the multiple chokes from Richmond across 2017, let alone the three 8th finishes prior to it. 

This is a laughable kneejerk reaction, but as I say, like clockwork after a loss.

[YesitwasaWin4theAges 6,702]

1 hour ago, gregdemon said:

Very valid we never win by much    not like doggies   but still wrapt with the year so far  At start of  I never would have thought we would be 9 and 1 (I did expect finals given last year form at times)   So....... so far well bowled  by Goody and the coaching panel and players ...... very well bowled !!

Let's see how the Dogs go against good defensive structured, high press pressure teams.

Edited May 24, 2021 by Win4theAges

[titan_uranus 25,014]

34 minutes ago, Patches O’houlihan said:

Defense wins championships, this is a universal fact in all team sports, and we have the best defense in the AFL. yes there are areas to work on, but we're 9-1 we probably only need to win 1-2 more games to lock up finals and 4-5 to lock in top 4. we've got time. 

we are a massive chance to win the premiership, and we're up against our biggest competition on Friday night on their home deck. 

I'm expecting a strong response to the Crows loss and our 10th win.

Not sure 4-5 more wins gets us top 4.

Most years the cut off is a 15-7 record. That's six more wins from here (indeed, a break-even 6-6 record).

In some years that hasn't been enough - in 2019 West Coast finished 15-7 but missed the top 4 on percentage and in 2016 the Dogs finished 15-7 but 7th (in 2016 the bottom six were terrible, with Richmond 13th with an 8-14 record and a sub-80% percentage and the five lower sides even worse than that. With the bottom six all sucking, more wins were taken up by the top 12 and in particular the top 6).

I'd suggest we'll need five wins, minimum, to be in the running for 4th as that will get us to 14-8. Six wins and 15-7 will make it far more likely, and seven wins and a 16-6 record should guarantee it. Anything beyond that and we start to play off for top 2.

Edited May 24, 2021 by titan_uranus

[Adam The God 30,222]

51 minutes ago, Patches O’houlihan said:

Defense wins championships, this is a universal fact in all team sports, and we have the best defense in the AFL. yes there are areas to work on, but we're 9-1 we probably only need to win 1-2 more games to lock up finals and 4-5 to lock in top 4. we've got time. 

we are a massive chance to win the premiership, and we're up against our biggest competition on Friday night on their home deck. 

I'm expecting a strong response to the Crows loss and our 10th win.

Love it mate.

[Jaded No More 68,909]

[dino rover 714]

3 hours ago, Smokey said:

apparently the sky is falling

Hyperbole - what I said was can we win the GF - nice straw man.

[dino rover 714]

22 minutes ago, A F said:

Haha, like clockwork. Lose one game and all of a sudden we can't win the flag and we have problems across all lines.

I wonder what you would have been saying about the multiple chokes from Richmond across 2017, let alone the three 8th finishes prior to it. 

This is a laughable kneejerk reaction, but as I say, like clockwork after a loss.

"and we have problems across all lines"

Actually I said our midfield and defence was good but id like an upgrade on Hunt and Brayshaw.

[Ted Lasso 19,513]

11 minutes ago, titan_uranus said:

Not sure 4-5 more wins gets us top 4.

Most years the cut off is a 15-7 record. That's six more wins from here (indeed, a break-even 6-6 record).

In some years that hasn't been enough - in 2019 West Coast finished 15-7 but missed the top 4 on percentage and in 2016 the Dogs finished 15-7 but 7th (in 2016 the bottom six were terrible, with Richmond 13th with an 8-14 record and a sub-80% percentage and the five lower sides even worse than that. With the bottom six all sucking, more wins were taken up by the top 12 and in particular the top 6).

I'd suggest we'll need five wins, minimum, to be in the running for 4th as that will get us to 14-8. Six wins and 15-7 will make it far more likely, and seven wins and a 16-6 record should guarantee it. Anything beyond that and we start to play off for top 2.

6 is fair enough, but i think it's fair to say based on our form in the first 10 games, we're almost certain to make finals, and we'd be very unlikely to fall away so badly we don't make top 4.

But our goal, i'm sure is and should be a top 2 spot, and if we get that, we're a very real chance to make the Grand final. and i think any team would find us really hard to beat on the MCG.