Who would you want with ball in hand on the siren?

 

Fritich

Salem

No love for Maxy?

N.Jones

I like Jack Viney but it neatly sums our forward woes when the coaches think our most reliable set shot is a dodgy left footer who struggles from 40m+. 
He has kicked 32.29 from his 120 games

Depends on the distance. If it's 40+ metres out, Melksham; if it's less than 40 metres, Salem.

Around 40m or closer i’d go T Mac. Over 40 I’ll choose Hunt, he holds the clutch award from 2019. 

I'm going Salem within 45m.

Outside 45m I'd go a bit of a roughy and say Steven May who has a beautiful and long kick.

My future up and comer however is Trent Rivers and I think he could quickly become the best kick in our side.

Melksham is elite. Left and right

1 hour ago, Accepting Mediocrity said:

No love for Maxy?

 

53 minutes ago, Collar-Jazz-Knee said:

I'm going Salem within 45m.

Outside 45m I'd go a bit of a roughy and say Steven May who has a beautiful and long kick.

My future up and comer however is Trent Rivers and I think he could quickly become the best kick in our side.

 

1 hour ago, La Dee-vina Comedia said:

Depends on the distance. If it's 40+ metres out, Melksham; if it's less than 40 metres, Salem.

Not a set shot but gee god boy wow ...

 

1 hour ago, Rodney (Balls) Grinter said:

N.Jones

Not a set shot either but was the sealer.

He has a beautiful set shot kick for goal.

 

toss up btw salem and melksham for me

Set shot: Tmac.

No one else comes close atm

TMac from the set shot. 
Melksham from on the run. 

1 hour ago, Melb-A-Toast said:

Melksham is elite. Left and right

For set shots he’s one of our worst.

2 hours ago, La Dee-vina Comedia said:

Depends on the distance. If it's 40+ metres out, Melksham; if it's less than 40 metres, Salem.

...60m+ out, I'll go with Jayden Hunt

 

20 minutes ago, Clint Bizkit said:

For set shots he’s one of our worst.

He is a bit like Maxy in so far as you put him within 15 - 20m straight in front and he gets the yips.  Further out than that, or hard up against the boundry right in the pocket, I think they go all right.

If it's from the boundary, then Maxy is Da Man.

I can't work out if this clip shows a replay or the second of these goals that Max kicked from the same spot in the space of about 5mins.

The spray he gives the Bombers fan afterwards is gold and would be worth while setting up Max to kick for goal just to get up opposition supporters.

Melbourne	Goals	Behinds	Other	Total shots	Accuracy %
Jayden Hunt	18	10	4	32	56.3
Christian Petracca	17	10	7	34	50
Sam Weideman	11	8	4	23	47.8
Tom McDonald	18	15	6	39	46.2
Jake Melksham	10	5	7	22	45.5
Jeff Garlett	9	9	3	21	42.9
James Harmes	10	15	4	29	34.5

That was from sen stats in 2019. https://www.sen.com.au/news/2019/07/10/who-are-the-most-accurate-and-inaccurate-players-in-the-afl/

Edited June 5, 20205 yr by Melb-A-Toast

Pruess

Those stats say Weideman and so do i. If he gets a go this year it will become obvious....