6 minutes ago, Matsuo Basho said:

14 goals in 18 games COMBINED from your two “key” forwards by round 11. 

There’s no argument on the need for one. That is totally unacceptable regardless of any mitigating factors. How much lower do you wish to set the bar?

No need to sell the farm for anyone but you do have to get creative and sometimes you do have to give in order to get.

No calculated risk, no reward.

And 19 goals combined from Cox & Hogan

1 hour ago, Mel Bourne said:

The AFL app/site has just put a quite a lengthy compilation of all of the best goals of the season thus far. It was kind of shattering to watch goal after goal with every club being represented (Carlton four times ffs) with an inspired moment in front of the goals except for you know who. About three minutes in we get a little glimpse of Preuss snapping his first goal against the Swans to wholesome reactions from commentators and crowd alike...and that’s it. Five friggin’ minutes and one goal from the Dees. It’s this kind of stuff that brings back that old feeling. The forgotten ones. The non-contenders. The....f$&@ing participants of the Melbourne Football Club. 

We need a spearhead. Desperately. 

 

 

You get 6 points for one dead in front and 6 points for flashy goals.

Jeff Garlett continues trying to kick flashy highlight goals as he has done since coming back into the side when he could 

a) run further and invite contact and handball to a teammate free who the opponent has just run off

b) run further and kick a simple goal as opposed to trying to dribble a goal from 25m+ out or on some ridiculous angle 

c) play the %'s and feed it off to a teammate in a much better position as opposed to trying to dribble a goal from 25m+ out or on some ridiculous angle 

Those examples above have happened on numerous occasions which along for his lack of forward pressure and constant avoidance of physical contact are why he's not a team player 

5 minutes ago, ManDee said:

And 19 goals combined from Cox & Hogan

See my entire commentary on Cox. They also have Reid and Mihocek.

Hogan was offloaded for a reason.

Look at the goal kicking table. Cameron, Hawkins, Lynch, Kennedy, Darling, Finlayson. Only Ben Brown comes from a club not in contention for the flag. 

West Coast, Richmond, GWS, Geelong, Collingwood. All of them have quality KPF’s.

The MFC is not in development mode. We have gone through the rebuild and recruited to challenge these teams. 

I have no doubt internally the club will already be having this discussion.

10 minutes ago, Pennant St Dee said:

You get 6 points for one dead in front and 6 points for flashy goals.

Jeff Garlett continues trying to kick flashy highlight goals as he has done since coming back into the side when he could 

a) run further and invite contact and handball to a teammate free who the opponent has just run off

b) run further and kick a simple goal as opposed to trying to dribble a goal from 25m+ out or on some ridiculous angle 

c) play the %'s and feed it off to a teammate in a much better position as opposed to trying to dribble a goal from 25m+ out or on some ridiculous angle 

Those examples above have happened on numerous occasions which along for his lack of forward pressure and constant avoidance of physical contact are why he's not a team player 

You also get inspired as a supporter of the team seeing moments of skilful brilliance. 

2 minutes ago, Mel Bourne said:

You also get inspired as a supporter of the team seeing moments of skilful brilliance. 

I get inspired by players backing into packs, sprinting to make a spoil to prevent an easy mark or score against,  crashing a pack and putting their body on the line to bring a ball to ground for a teammate, I get inspired by chase down tackles or a player continuing to chase down an opponent when all is lost to apply enough pressure to cause a skill error.

Those attributes are what makes successful teams and regular 4 points will inspire me along with being regular finals contenders.

That's how I roll Mel, very much meat and potatoes.

Liam Ryan's mark over Max was great, but his 70m run to get there impressed me more

3 minutes ago, Pennant St Dee said:

I get inspired by players backing into packs, sprinting to make a spoil to prevent an easy mark or score against,  crashing a pack and putting their body on the line to bring a ball to ground for a teammate, I get inspired by chase down tackles or a player continuing to chase down an opponent when all is lost to apply enough pressure to cause a skill error.

Those attributes are what makes successful teams and regular 4 points will inspire me along with being regular finals contenders.

That's how I roll Mel, very much meat and potatoes.

Liam Ryan's mark over Max was great, but his 70m run to get there impressed me more

Uh....I’m not exactly ignorant to the many aspects of the game that inspire and make for successful teams. Just talking about a thing I saw this morning.

However if you were to watch a highlight reel of players backing into packs, sprinting to make a spoil to prevent an easy mark or score against,  crashing a pack and putting their body on the line to bring a ball to ground for a teammate, chase down tackles or a player continuing to chase down an opponent when all is lost to apply enough pressure to cause a skill error then you won’t see many clips of our players either. Which is the most unfortunate point I’m trying to make. We may not technically be on the bottom of the ladder but we sure are when it comes to highlight reels, and that speaks to our season and the club right now. Flat, uninspired and uninspiring. 

 

 

39 minutes ago, Pennant St Dee said:

You get 6 points for one dead in front and 6 points for flashy goals.

Jeff Garlett continues trying to kick flashy highlight goals as he has done since coming back into the side when he could 

a) run further and invite contact and handball to a teammate free who the opponent has just run off

b) run further and kick a simple goal as opposed to trying to dribble a goal from 25m+ out or on some ridiculous angle 

c) play the %'s and feed it off to a teammate in a much better position as opposed to trying to dribble a goal from 25m+ out or on some ridiculous angle 

Those examples above have happened on numerous occasions which along for his lack of forward pressure and constant avoidance of physical contact are why he's not a team player 

These r the reasons y I don't think Garlett should b in the side going 4ward. If he played the percentages & drew the player I would happily have him,  but he will never do it so 4 me I'd rather play someone else who would. Garlett would break 2 many hearts if we ever made a Granny.

21 minutes ago, Pennant St Dee said:

I get inspired by players backing into packs, sprinting to make a spoil to prevent an easy mark or score against,  crashing a pack and putting their body on the line to bring a ball to ground for a teammate, I get inspired by chase down tackles or a player continuing to chase down an opponent when all is lost to apply enough pressure to cause a skill error.

Those attributes are what makes successful teams and regular 4 points will inspire me along with being regular finals contenders.

That's how I roll Mel, very much meat and potatoes.

Liam Ryan's mark over Max was great, but his 70m run to get there impressed me more

This has probably whats gotten lost amongst the commentary with that mark. His work rate to push hard forward was awesome to watch. Wanted the ball the moment he pushed away from the wing.

3 minutes ago, Mel Bourne said:

Uh....I’m not exactly ignorant to the many aspects of the game that inspire and make for successful teams. Just talking about a thing I saw this morning.

However if you were to watch a highlight reel of players backing into packs, sprinting to make a spoil to prevent an easy mark or score against,  crashing a pack and putting their body on the line to bring a ball to ground for a teammate, chase down tackles or a player continuing to chase down an opponent when all is lost to apply enough pressure to cause a skill error then you won’t see many clips of our players either. Which is the most unfortunate point I’m trying to make. We may not technically be on the bottom of the ladder but we sure are when it comes to highlight reels, and that speaks to our season and the club right now. Flat, uninspired and uninspiring. 

 

 

Yes Mel I agree with you there, it's improved in the last month with some selfless acts and once confidence improves you will see a few more moments of brilliance which comes with belief.

ND's speech to the playing group was all about that, show courage in difficult times, conduct yourself in the right manner 

https://www.zerohanger.com/report-victorian-club-interested-in-luring-darling-30427/?utm_source=Facebook&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=AFL+Zero+Hanger

 

Probably no creditability, I think the guy is a [censored] but if he was open to a move to Vic I hope we chase him... God he tmac and weid would be a handful of a forward line.

1 hour ago, Mel Bourne said:

You also get inspired as a supporter of the team seeing moments of skilful brilliance. 

Fair point but I'd rather see bagfuls of goals with dull monotony + a flag thanks.

Ephemeral highlights reel goals < dead boring clockwork bags + a flag

Maybe we can turn this into a tangible debate about which of Cameron or Whitfield we'll take as a free agent next year?

 

23 minutes ago, GCDee said:

https://www.zerohanger.com/report-victorian-club-interested-in-luring-darling-30427/?utm_source=Facebook&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=AFL+Zero+Hanger

 

Probably no creditability, I think the guy is a [censored] but if he was open to a move to Vic I hope we chase him... God he tmac and weid would be a handful of a forward line.

Like it! Good find GCDee.

A look at the 2020 FA list also sees Kennedy, Tomahawk, Daniher, Cameron, Patton and a few others named.

Whether through FA or direct trading there are moves to be made by the Dees this off season. 

Darling is a terrific player. Would be a huge get. 

1 hour ago, Superunknown said:

Fair point but I'd rather see bagfuls of goals with dull monotony + a flag thanks.

Ephemeral highlights reel goals < dead boring clockwork bags + a flag

They often go hand in hand. 

We were caught short with lack of tall forwards.

Tmac seemed to be a star so that cant be helped. 

Weid was really an unknown quantity with a small ammount of games.

Smith and Preuss wete not real contenders so where was our third?

Tmac and Weid could have gone out on injuries and even though they have had little impact it was always a gamble having 2.

Lets bypass interstate candidates who may want to go home and anyone who has done a k knee.

Cameron obviously would be awesome.

On 6/6/2019 at 8:29 PM, Gunna’s said:

Tom Boyd?

why not, if he committed, 1 yr contract on a performance based salary,  he would solve our second ruck problem, get the boys to get around him a bit,  and just let him play, no big contract pressure, you play well you get rewarded, if it don't work out so be it, invest little for a potential high reward, 

Today is the perfect day for Garlett to prove that he is a big game player. Regardless, we need a young aggressive forward in the draft. Someone, ready made if possible. We cannot trade for one, too expensive, won’t happen.

42 minutes ago, Thehardtackler said:

Today is the perfect day for Garlett to prove that he is a big game player. Regardless, we need a young aggressive forward in the draft. Someone, ready made if possible. We cannot trade for one, too expensive, won’t happen.

Unfortunately, according to draft watchers, it’s a midfielders draft among the top 20 - 30 picks this year. 

Anyway, there’s no such thing as a ‘ready made’ 18yo key forward.

We must and I believe we will trade for one, or possibly look at a FA. Goodwin’s honeymoon is over. He knows he needs W’s and plenty of them in 2020 or it’s job on the line time. 

In order I’d be going hard at:

Ben Brown 

Jon Patton

Jack Darling

Charlie Dixon 

Edited June 10, 20195 yr by Matsuo Basho

On 6/5/2019 at 7:21 PM, Moonshadow said:

Or maybe we can wait until closer to the end of the season before presuming we are looking for a kpf for next year. 

I'm sure Mahoney and Todd Viney will be well advanced in looking at a variety of current players. Not sure ot will be a forward  to replace Tmac or Weid, who have clearly not been going at 100%.

Personally, I think an A grade mid with good pace and foot skills is a higher priority. Coniglio (FA) or Whitfield would be nice.

Not saying I wouldn't be happy with another kpf, just not Patton who has had 3 knee recos. Ben Brown would cost us 2020 first round pick. What would Tomlinson cost?

Given the potential yung-uns we have that includes several with AFL experience this year, we'd most probably be OK for KPD personnel but really, there are some at Casey who may warrant some thought in what is left of the 2-team season.

Some have the skills, needing experience and some have pace.

At the end of the day but at the start of next season, we had better have an improved game plan where not all 'great forwards to be'  have the pre-requisites of massive height and survivable pack-marking aptitudes ; by this it is meant that, if our gameplan might mature, we need some quick mid-sized players with versatility and agility (not omni-directionals) to really wreak havoc in pondering opposition heavyweights played down back (for them). 

On 6/5/2019 at 8:21 PM, John Demonic said:

If he and TMAC were swingmen, it would wreak all kinds of havoc on the opposition, having them move back or forward at a whim. Running into the 50 to spoil or mark on the run. You'd be terrified of a Steven May running back with the flight. The unpredictable factor could be one of our weapons. Goody might need to think outside the box for something like this, for 2020 to give us an advantage.

I'd suggest that is correct but it is an irony that Goodwin has yet to deploy a game plan that does exactly that with current personnel - that is, those who were or are not in injury recovery. It might have occurred at both forward and defensive zones - as demonstrated by Hore and surprisingly, the Trac, from time to time. 

On 6/7/2019 at 12:18 PM, GCDee said:

https://www.zerohanger.com/report-victorian-club-interested-in-luring-darling-30427/?utm_source=Facebook&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=AFL+Zero+Hanger

 

Probably no creditability, I think the guy is a [censored] but if he was open to a move to Vic I hope we chase him... God he tmac and weid would be a handful of a forward line.

Takes you back to the forward line of Schwarz and Lyon, in some ways, but not quite so clever or potent.

1 hour ago, Matsuo Basho said:

Unfortunately, according to draft watchers, it’s a midfielders draft among the top 20 - 30 picks this year. 

Anyway, there’s no such thing as a ‘ready made’ 18yo key forward.

We must and I believe we will trade for one, or possibly look at a FA. Goodwin’s honeymoon is over. He knows he needs W’s and plenty of them in 2020 or it’s job on the line time. 

In order I’d be going hard at:

Ben Brown 

Jon Patton

Jack Darling  ???

Charlie Dixon 

I think we need to trade for a mobile CHF.  

Not too tall,  but strong, aggressive and agile.   A modern version of Dermot would suffice.  A  Ross Glendinning,  or Malcolm Blight type of build,  and agility/mobility.  

 

Jon Patton, OK for a pocket role,  but I now think we can draft for this position.

...............................

 

I just read and watched the thread, Casey kid is a Kiwi. 

I hadnn't realised  Mykelti Lefau  was tall.   I had seen vision of him last year,  but I did not realise he is  6'-4"  tall. 

He moves well,  and is Quick, and agile...  could suit our  Key Wi needs.  ?  ???

Edited June 10, 20195 yr by DV8

1 hour ago, Matsuo Basho said:

We must and I believe we will trade for one, or possibly look at a FA. Goodwin’s honeymoon is over. He knows he needs W’s and plenty of them in 2020 or it’s job on the line time

We might trade for one, but Goodwin's job is not on  the line in 2020, when did he tell you it was?

54 minutes ago, drysdale demon said:

We might trade for one, but Goodwin's job is not on  the line in 2020, when did he tell you it was?

All AFL coaches understand, particularly those not in rebuild mode, that the W column determines job security. Has always been that way and always will be.

 

Okay. No more to debate.

The situation is diabolical.

Who are we going after?

 

Edited June 10, 20195 yr by Matsuo Basho