On 28/04/2019 at 09:06, Roger Mellie said:

Our forward line already sucks. You want to go with those two as our key forwards (assuming TMac stays back)?

Why not? Smith did ok last week. Keilty deserves a chance and Weid needs to go back to the NFL and learn how to mark a ball.

So many weird new posters.

In: O.McDonald

Out: Viney

Won’t satisy anyone’s bloodlust, but I’m fine with that.

TMac to go forward again. Weideman stays in. We need to figure out how to make that combination work again - it’s far too important for the future to abandon now. It’s reason #1 why we’ve been garbage.

Not too interested in any other fringe player swaps, though I wouldn’t be averse to having a look at Keilty.

  On 28/04/2019 at 11:24, Nasher said:

In: O.McDonald

Out: Viney

Won’t satisy anyone’s bloodlust, but I’m fine with that.

TMac to go forward again. Weideman stays in. We need to figure out how to make that combination work again - it’s far too important for the future to abandon now. It’s reason #1 why we’ve been garbage.

Not too interested in any other fringe player swaps, though I wouldn’t be averse to having a look at Keilty.

Not sure why we'd bring in Oscar here. Who's his match up and what does he bring to the side that we don't already have with Frost, Hore and Hibberd?

Given Hawthorn's KPF stocks are pretty thin, I wouldn't be bringing in another defensive tall. I'd be looking at more pace for the likely Hawthorn spread on the G. 

I'd be looking at Spargo or Sparrow to replace Jack. Spargo is probably the more likely.

 

out- Garlett, Viney, ANB, Smith

in- Spargo, Sparrow, Baker, Preuss

if some of our guys aren't contributing much id rather we try get some games into some of the younger blokes and try to find some replacements for them instead. 

 

 

 

 

At the risk of sounding Werridee'ish, I'd like to propose a team for this coming week, and my reasoning for it:

I believe our problems are fixable with the talent we currently have available, and can be turned around in a relatively short period of time, with the right approach - and a few tweaks. In short my premise is that our main problem is with our mids, and their poor delivery into our forward 50. We have no problem with getting the ball into our 50 - enough times to win a game if we convert - its just that our delivery is so bad, our forwards do not stand a chance in hell - with the obvious outcome being turning the ball over and speedy delivery of the ball to the other end of the ground. One solution, i feel, is to place our best ball users into the middle.

I also feel Jones best position now is to replace Nev in the back pocket. And a suggestion by another poster of placing Petracca onto a back flank to bring him into the game more, I also like. Brayshaw is a great ball gatherer, and around goals his kicking is far better than his sub standard field kicking. So i like him on a forward flank - taking Traccs position.

For what it is worth, here is my team (assuming current injury status):

Jones, Frost, Hore

Petracca, Hibbert, Lewis

Fritsch, Melksham, Salem

Hunt, Weideman, Brayshaw

Garlett, TMac, T Smith

Gawn, Oliver, Harmes

I/C Stretch, Keilty, Lockhart and Sparrow.

 

  On 28/04/2019 at 11:32, A F said:

Not sure why we'd bring in Oscar here. Who's his match up and what does he bring to the side that we don't already have with Frost, Hore and Hibberd?

Given Hawthorn's KPF stocks are pretty thin, I wouldn't be bringing in another defensive tall. I'd be looking at more pace for the likely Hawthorn spread on the G. 

I'd be looking at Spargo or Sparrow to replace Jack. Spargo is probably the more likely.

 

I dunno mate, just assumed we’d need two talls. Haven’t watched a red second of Hawthorn this year. If we don’t, so be it. The point was I want TMac back in to the forward line.

  On 28/04/2019 at 11:38, Nasher said:

I dunno mate, just assumed we’d need two talls. Haven’t watched a red second of Hawthorn this year. If we don’t, so be it. The point was I want TMac back in to the forward line.

I reckon Hore is doing a good enough job as interceptor / 2nd KPB. I reckon we can play Tom forward this week, because I doubt he'd have a match up down back anyway.

He's likely to be playing on O'Brien, so there's a chance he could get busy. 

  On 28/04/2019 at 11:36, Demon Dude said:

out- Garlett, Viney, ANB, Smith

in- Spargo, Sparrow, Baker, Preuss

if some of our guys aren't contributing much id rather we try get some games into some of the younger blokes and try to find some replacements for them instead. 

 

 

 

 

Why O why we keep coming back to Spargo. The guy had 13 disposals (50 odd Dream team points in the two's), wasted his kicks and we want him back after this one game. He needs a block in the two's to show something first.

  On 28/04/2019 at 11:36, Neil Crompton said:

At the risk of sounding Werridee'ish, I'd like to propose a team for this coming week, and my reasoning for it:

I believe our problems are fixable with the talent we currently have available, and can be turned around in a relatively short period of time, with the right approach - and a few tweaks. In short my premise is that our main problem is with our mids, and their poor delivery into our forward 50. We have no problem with getting the ball into our 50 - enough times to win a game if we convert - its just that our delivery is so bad, our forwards do not stand a chance in hell - with the obvious outcome being turning the ball over and speedy delivery of the ball to the other end of the ground. One solution, i feel, is to place our best ball users into the middle.

I also feel Jones best position now is to replace Nev in the back pocket. And a suggestion by another poster of placing Petracca onto a back flank to bring him into the game more, I also like. Brayshaw is a great ball gatherer, and around goals his kicking is far better than his sub standard field kicking. So i like him on a forward flank - taking Traccs position.

For what it is worth, here is my team (assuming current injury status):

Jones, Frost, Hore

Petracca, Hibbert, Lewis

Fritsch, Melksham, Salem

Hunt, Weideman, Brayshaw

Garlett, TMac, T Smith

Gawn, Oliver, Harmes

I/C Stretch, Keilty, Lockhart and Sparrow.

 

I dunno mate, we tried one of our better ball users in Melk in the guts last week and he turned it over heaps as well. I believe it has more to do with our midfield set ups myself. we don't like using wingers and just like to bang it forward instead. good teams look to hit up a short 20m kick these days then try to shift defences to catch out the zone. seems to happen to us a fair bit anyway.

  On 28/04/2019 at 11:45, Docs Demons said:

Why O why we keep coming back to Spargo. The guy had 13 disposals (50 odd Dream team points in the two's), wasted his kicks and we want him back after this one game. He needs a block in the two's to show something first.

because he's young and Jeffy is not. like I said if jeffys not contributing i'd prefer we get games into Spargo.

Fair chance Preuss will come straight back in.

  On 28/04/2019 at 11:47, Demon Dude said:

because he's young and Jeffy is not. like I said if jeffys not contributing i'd prefer we get games into Spargo.

Jeffy at least makes the opposition nervous.

They look at Spargo & have little fear that he can stick a tackle even if he can catch them.

Harsh but true at the moment...

  On 28/04/2019 at 12:44, rjay said:

Jeffy at least makes the opposition nervous.

They look at Spargo & have little fear that he can stick a tackle even if he can catch them.

Harsh but true at the moment...

im not sure jeffy makes oppo nervous anymore though. I guess it all depends on whether you think Jeffy will be given another contract at years end. I don't think he will, so with this year being pretty much a write off, i'd be planning for the future instead.

  On 28/04/2019 at 12:58, Demon Dude said:

im not sure jeffy makes oppo nervous anymore though. I guess it all depends on whether you think Jeffy will be given another contract at years end. I don't think he will, so with this year being pretty much a write off, i'd be planning for the future instead.

Spargo isn't physically strong enough for AFL football at the moment.

Also not fast & needs something if he's going to be the future...

  On 28/04/2019 at 13:06, rjay said:

Spargo isn't physically strong enough for AFL football at the moment.

Also not fast & needs something if he's going to be the future...

yet Spargo didn't have a problem with not being strong enough last year, and Jeffy has never been strong either. I don't buy it.

  On 28/04/2019 at 13:10, Demon Dude said:

yet Spargo didn't have a problem with not being strong enough last year, and Jeffy has never been strong either. I don't buy it.

Buy what you like...but go back and watch.

He had the same problem & it hasn't been fixed.

He gets run over & run through, can't stick a tackle & I think that's a liability.

Particularly when he also doesn't hit the scoreboard.

  On 28/04/2019 at 13:59, rjay said:

Buy what you like...but go back and watch.

He had the same problem & it hasn't been fixed.

He gets run over & run through, can't stick a tackle & I think that's a liability.

Particularly when he also doesn't hit the scoreboard.

Yeah I know what Spargos deficiencies are, but what I can't buy is using them as a reason not to play him when Jeffy has the same issues but is at the end of his career. Us not making finals will be the worst thing that could happen to the likes of Jeffy, and Lewis, who are out of contract. As soon as finals arent possible the coaches will look to move on from them pretty quickly imo.

  On 28/04/2019 at 09:41, Demons11 said:

Doesn’t deserve it?  You are a clown.

The bloke deserves all the accolades coming his way for what he has given the club.  

 

So you don't agree with my opinion. Ok, but you might refrain from name calling. Show some respect. 

  On 28/04/2019 at 14:15, Demon Dude said:

Jeffy has the same issues

No Jeffy doesn't have the same issues as Spargo.

Jeffy's are in the head.

He has 'X' factor, he's a known goal kicker, he's fast & he can tackle.

These are all issues we can only wish Spargo had without the mental fragility.

  On 28/04/2019 at 21:32, rjay said:

No Jeffy doesn't have the same issues as Spargo.

Jeffy's are in the head.

He has 'X' factor, he's a known goal kicker, he's fast & he can tackle.

These are all issues we can only wish Spargo had without the mental fragility.

Well put rjay.

just read the Casey review. Sparrow in for Viney.

  On 28/04/2019 at 21:32, rjay said:

No Jeffy doesn't have the same issues as Spargo.

Jeffy's are in the head.

He has 'X' factor, he's a known goal kicker, he's fast & he can tackle.

These are all issues we can only wish Spargo had without the mental fragility.

Jeffy used to be those things, but he's not anymore. Except for still being mentally fragile that is. He might show the odd bit of his old self from time to time, but not enough.

Some of you guys must still think we are going to play finals this year. We aren't. Time to plan for the future. I would rather give games to Spargo and Chandler than Jeffy now. Their output would be on similar levels to Jeffy, but at least they come with some possible upside for the future.

Weid should stick it out.... there is really nobody else in s forward structure for the long term, not smith or keilty. Maybe a working through a tough spell will make him a better footballer. Time will tell.

  On 28/04/2019 at 23:02, Demon Dude said:

Jeffy used to be those things, but he's not anymore. Except for still being mentally fragile that is. He might show the odd bit of his old self from time to time, but not enough.

Some of you guys must still think we are going to play finals this year. We aren't. Time to plan for the future. I would rather give games to Spargo and Chandler than Jeffy now. Their output would be on similar levels to Jeffy, but at least they come with some possible upside for the future.

Read my other posts and you will know this is not the case.

May and Lever will make a difference, plus getting some K's into some of the others but we're not good enough this year.

...but there is no use putting games into players who are not ready and to my mind not going to be AFL level players...

I don't see the upside in having a player on the ground who can't carry his weigh and at least offer a contest.

We just don't have the talent at Casey, and the injury list is hurting us.

The only one I would have a good look at is Sparrow and I think his best position will be in defence rather than as a mid.

Time to try him there and give him some games to develop.

Jeff has to play, he can run through the middle as well now and again. 

Sparrow for Viney - give the kid a month.

Keilty - maybe - need a look at him but this is the thing at the moment as we devoid of hope and spark, a bloke who kicks 2 in a reserves game looms as a great white hope. Idelaly you put a Keilty in when we are going well, not when we are struggling.

Cant drop Weid IMO.. show him some support and he might come through.