Let’s see:

- absolutely petrified

- runs around contests

- drops chest marks

- slow

- can’t lay tackles

- pretty good actor in TV commercials

ill need time to think about this..

7 minutes ago, Beetle said:

Let’s see:

- absolutely petrified

- runs around contests

- drops chest marks

- slow

- can’t lay tackles

- pretty good actor in TV commercials

ill need time to think about this..

Currently leading our tackles...

2 minutes ago, deanox said:

Currently leading our tackles...

Well I stand corrected. This is why I’ll need to think about it.

23 minutes ago, Beetle said:

Well I stand corrected. This is why I’ll need to think about it.

Take your time.

At the game, his tackling has been good

Looks completely overwhelmed otherwise 

18 minutes ago, P-man said:

Take your time.

Nah...drop and delist thanks.

He’s looked good this quarter 

Just now, Roost It said:

He’s looked good this quarter 

I agree with you Roost, but stand by my thoughts.

4 minutes ago, Beetle said:

Nah...drop and delist thanks.

agreed not sure what positives he offers. Rather keep Trengove.

1 minute ago, Beetle said:

I agree with you Roost, but stand by my thoughts.

Yeah. Stand by your thought that the leading tackler on the ground can’t lay a tackle. Good lad.

4 minutes ago, P-man said:

Yeah. Stand by your thought that the leading tackler on the ground can’t lay a tackle. Good lad.

I said I stood corrected on his tackling stats at that point P-Man. His second half tackling has also been very good.

I stand by my thoughts he isn’t up to it and adds very little.

Instead of attempting to belittle me, enlighten me on his upside?

Edited July 14, 20187 yr by Beetle

He’s been good this qtr

jonathan brown just commended his tackles

Just now, Beetle said:

I said I stood corrected on his tackling stats at that point P-Man.

I stand by my thoughts he isn’t up to it and adds very little.

Instead of attempting to belittle me, enlighten on his upside?

Oh many pardons. Am I belittling you? I‘m terribly sorry. 

Please return to your zealousness to sink the boot in. I’ll stop hurting your feelings.

 

Done enough to stay in

barely saw Hannan today but often miss him

Fritsch can do it all

2 minutes ago, P-man said:

Oh many pardons. Am I belittling you? I‘m terribly sorry. 

Please return to your zealousness to sink the boot in. I’ll stop hurting your feelings.

 

Not sure where the so called hurt feelings come into it, but thanks for the pompous reply.

Now as per my previous post, please let me know your thoughts on JKH’s positive future at the Melbourne Football Club.

Why did you ignore half his post? What is JKH's upside?

I don't see it either. But I think he gives it a real go. I'm just not sure he's fast enough to lock down a position.

 

I thought he did alright today. Finished with plenty of tackles and looks hungry for the ball

 

Has definitely improved since his last game

Edited July 14, 20187 yr by low flying Robbo

Did enough in last qtr to keep his spot. Tackle count good. We need guys who hunt down tackles

He tackled strongly and he was quite neat with the ball at times and quick to release.  Had some poor moments but worth another chance.  Probably playing in a position not suited to him as well (wing).

yes i think its a bit premature to start calling for his delisting. his first game in a while and he did a lot better than some others. Showed a little give him a little more time, he could be pretty handy.

First half was soft as always.

Got in some late game tackles.

Is and always will be depth.

JKH hadn't played at AFL level for a while

Worked his way into the game

1 minute ago, Satyriconhome said:

JKH hadn't played at AFL level for a while

Worked his way into the game

Agree,  and with 9 tackles he's earnt another crack despite the slow start .

In for another week of the key to getting a game is being a competitor.

His job shouldn't be to get 40 touches. That's what we have Clarry and Gus for. If he gets blokes thinking twice when taking their time to size to their options, then keep him in.

Did a great kick to Hogan for a goal. 8 tackles Give him some credit