Round 6 Non MFC games

[dees189227 12,430]

5 minutes ago, Diamond_Jim said:

slightly off topic but Melbourne Victory had the semi final sewn up...2-1... and Sydney scored a goal with 15 seconds to go.

Now off to extra time for 30 minutes

I have not  a lot of interest in soccer but flicked over hoping the victory win just to shove it up sydneyfc just as that own goal by Antonis  was scored. The victory were 15 seconds away from a grand final. That is just devastating. 

anyway we cop the saints next week. Im already dreading it. Its just something about us playing teams that shouldn't win or havent won a game yet that we always come across and somehow we lose to them. anyway lets get over tomorrow first. 

[Diamond_Jim 12,629]

27 minutes into extra time and the Victory score !

3 minutes plus added time to go !

[Diamond_Jim 12,629]

27 minutes into extra time and the Victory score !

3 minutes plus added time to go !

[Dee Zephyr 19,269]

1 minute ago, Diamond_Jim said:

27 minutes into extra time and the Victory score !

3 minutes plus added time to go !

It’s all happening, assistant coaches receiving red cards now. A lot of fire in this one.

[Diamond_Jim 12,629]

Soccer can be fun !!

Red card! And another! Sydney FC 2-3 Melbourne Victory

This is ridiculous. What is going on.

Somewhere in the aftermath of that Antonis goal, Victory assistant coach JP DeMarigny has run onto the pitch and appeared to have thrown a punch at Sydney FC’s David Carney!!

We stop for a VAR review; and the assistant coach is shown a red card.

We stop again, and Victory’s goalkeeping coach has been sent to the stands as well; replays suggest he too has run on to choke Carney!!

Apparently Matt Simon and Mattias Sanchez have also been booked. What is going on. Like actually.

And now Zullo’s been booked. For footballing reasons though.

[Diamond_Jim 12,629]

7 minutes into added time in extra time and we have a stoppage

Muscat going off his head at the delay !!

[Diamond_Jim 12,629]

From the Guardian... a beautiful description:

Full-time: Sydney FC 2-3 Melbourne Victory

And this white whale of a football game, this remarkable, indefinable, indescribably game of soccer is over!!

Melbourne Victory have won, Besart smiles again. Muscat sprints onto the field to congratulate his players. And the rain falls on Graham Arnold.

Goodness gracious. What is it about A-League semi-finals??

[Diamond_Jim 12,629]

Just to expand...

Sydney has been way on top all year

Melbourne Victory have had an up and down season.

The coach of Sydney takes over the national team after the world cup. He stayed to coach Sydney to the premiership.

Melbourne play Newcastle in the final...

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,294]

....shows you how good tonights games of footy have been...snoozefest!

[low flying Robbo 979]

56 minutes ago, Diamond_Jim said:

Just to expand...

Sydney has been way on top all year

Melbourne Victory have had an up and down season.

The coach of Sydney takes over the national team after the world cup. He stayed to coach Sydney to the premiership.

Melbourne play Newcastle in the final...

I too flicked it on after the Hawks game finished. If it were up to me we'd be watching it but was in a Hawks supporting household. My heart sank when Antonis scored the OG. I figured that was game set and match. So good to see him seal the winner! We haven't been able to beat Sydney in a few years but this one was glorious! Suffer in your jocks Arnie! And Brosque. Love to see those smug pricks miss out on the GF. So much arrogance in the Sydney camp.

[TRIGON 4,791]

8 hours ago, Diamond_Jim said:

Soccer can be fun !!

Red card! And another! Sydney FC 2-3 Melbourne Victory

This is ridiculous. What is going on.

Somewhere in the aftermath of that Antonis goal, Victory assistant coach JP DeMarigny has run onto the pitch and appeared to have thrown a punch at Sydney FC’s David Carney!!

We stop for a VAR review; and the assistant coach is shown a red card.

We stop again, and Victory’s goalkeeping coach has been sent to the stands as well; replays suggest he too has run on to choke Carney!!

Apparently Matt Simon and Mattias Sanchez have also been booked. What is going on. Like actually.

And now Zullo’s been booked. For footballing reasons though.

Coaches replicating fan behaviour?

[Diamond_Jim 12,629]

Seemed to be a decent crowd at the Hawks v Saints game in Launceston last night.

I think it has been mentioned before but what do people think of North relocating to Tasmania on the basis that all away games are played in Tasmania and they play 11 in Melbourne. Sure it gives them an advantage but if North is going to survive it is either going to be on AFL money or with something radical like this.

It has the advantage of being a relocation without disenfranchising the existing fans and does not mean you have the draft compromises in the way that it was for GWS and GCS.

[sue 9,146]

39 minutes ago, Diamond_Jim said:

Seemed to be a decent crowd at the Hawks v Saints game in Launceston last night.

I think it has been mentioned before but what do people think of North relocating to Tasmania on the basis that all away games are played in Tasmania and they play 11 in Melbourne. Sure it gives them an advantage but if North is going to survive it is either going to be on AFL money or with something radical like this.

It has the advantage of being a relocation without disenfranchising the existing fans and does not mean you have the draft compromises in the way that it was for GWS and GCS.

If I understand you correctly, wouldn't that mean that all non-Melbourne based  teams would be playing their home game against North not at their own home ground ( that is, either in Tas or Melb as part of the 11 in Melb).  Wouldn't that be unfair on them?  

[Diamond_Jim 12,629]

Just now, sue said:

If I understand you correctly, wouldn't that mean that all non-Melbourne based  teams would be playing their home game against North not at their own home ground ( that is, either in Tas or Melb as part of the 11 in Melb).  Wouldn't that be unfair on them?  

Unfair .. yes but Tasmania needs either a lot of money or an innovative solution to make it work.

The Tasmanian games would be split between Launceston and Hobart in all probability so the permanent home ground advantage is reduced slightly.

Perhaps   the solution is better stated as 11 home games in Tasmania and then say 9 away games in Melbourne where Melbourne based North members have free entry. In reality North games are never sold out so you are not dudding the local Melbourne club.

Sharing of gate receipts can be done under a formula.

Of course the likes of Eddie and more particularly Jeff K will scream but something needs to happen.

[sue 9,146]

I like your out-of-the-square thinking, but I expect the howls coming from WA, QLD etc will drown out even those from Eddie and Jeff K.

[Mazer Rackham 14,971]

I don't know much about the economics of it, but it seems that first Hawks, then Roos, "expanded" into Tas and (esp Hawks) were lauded for their innovation and forward thinking.

But really, it was always a way of getting more revenue. The money goes out of Tas and into Vic. Wham bam thank you Tas.

Surely it is better for the money to stay in Tas and go back to Tas footy. God knows the grass roots is screaming out for it.

This comes across as a redistribution of wealth that is crippling Tas footy.

Give them their own goddam team as a reward for their long pedigree of football excellence and subsidise it the way GCS and GWS are.

[Diamond_Jim 12,629]

30 minutes ago, Mazer Rackham said:

Give them their own goddam team as a reward for their long pedigree of football excellence and subsidise it the way GCS and GWS are.

Then you would have the dreaded odd number of teams and I don't think anyone wants to bring back the floating bye.

A semi relocated North would still need AFL money but nowhere near as much as a new team.

Kennett says you need $50M per year to run a team.

[Cards13 9,117]

Higgins for Tigs is a gun. Our mate Lynden is a brain fade.

Edited April 29, 2018 by Cards13

[Diamond_Jim 12,629]

come on Richmond... could not stand a week of Collingwood hype

[beelzebub 23,383]

Pies looking good ..

Must go wash mouth out now...

[Guest]

35 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Pies looking good ..

Must go wash mouth out now...

I'm not sure who I want to win.

The reason why I want Collingwood to lose go without saying. Whatever makes Eddie sad usually makes me happy.

On the other hand, the bloody verbal reacharounds performed on Cotchin, Rance and Dusty by Hammer and the rest of his preppy mates is grating in the extreme. It is nearly as bad as Tim Lane and Geelong back in the day.

[What 18,810]

Get it done Freo.

The Eagles being 5-1 is a sickening thought.

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

Gee Pies are $5.30 to $1.14 and they are only 11pts down.

[Diamond_Jim 12,629]

punters must have known something ....now 30 points down

Edit ... a goal to the Pies means there is still a possibility

[Lucifers Hero 40,375]

Hopefully Rich and WCE win as Freo and Pies are the ones we will most probably be competing with to make the 8.

Edited April 29, 2018 by Lucifer's Hero