The What Do You Think of the New Clash Guernsey Poll

[Pates 9,660]

35 minutes ago, Forest Demon said:

If this has been ticked off by the AFL, they may as well just do away with clash strips.

It's ticked off for certain teams, eg vs the Saints if we had our home strip we would have a dark back making it (theoretically) harder to distinguish on TV, which is why they've forced us to wear the white strip. With the red back you don't have that problem. Hopefully they'll let us wear it against a few others as well. 

[daisycutter 29,743]

42 minutes ago, Forest Demon said:

If this has been ticked off by the AFL, they may as well just do away with clash strips.

?

[ManDee 7,222]

54 minutes ago, Forest Demon said:

If this has been ticked off by the AFL, they may as well just do away with clash strips.

[Forest Demon 4,681]

6 hours ago, daisycutter said:

?

Given other comments like "it is basically the same as our home jumper", and "I forgot it was even a clash jumper", and others thinking it was our new home jumper, I think it is pretty obvious what I was getting at.

I would love to wear the red and blue every week, and if the powers that be tick this one off, then I am delighted. But personally, I would have expected if the AFL wanted clash jumpers, they would want them to be, you know, less clashy.

Obviously this isn't unique, as many other teams have similar subtle changes, so obviously we have said, stuff it, if they can all do it than so can we.

[ManDee 7,222]

 Really!

Oh, now I see why we cant have red & blue.

[Forest Demon 4,681]

3 minutes ago, ManDee said:

 Really!

Oh, now I see why we cant have red & blue.

I assume you are having a dip at me, and again, completely missing my point. I think most AFL clash jumpers are a joke, and as I said, we obviously saw other teams and decided if it was good for them, it was good for us.

Richmond's little bit of yellow down the side another great example of a clash jumper joke.

If they don't enforce proper clash jumpers, may as well just wear the home jumper and white shorts.

[ManDee 7,222]

25 minutes ago, Forest Demon said:

I assume you are having a dip at me, and again, completely missing my point. I think most AFL clash jumpers are a joke, and as I said, we obviously saw other teams and decided if it was good for them, it was good for us.

Richmond's little bit of yellow down the side another great example of a clash jumper joke.

If they don't enforce proper clash jumpers, may as well just wear the home jumper and white shorts.

No, not at all.

I did think your earlier comment was odd, as I see it as a viable alternate strip. But the Collingwood & Essendon alternate strip show what a farce it really is. Good on us for having the red back. White shorts worked for years as you say.

[daisycutter 29,743]

2 hours ago, Forest Demon said:

Given other comments like "it is basically the same as our home jumper", and "I forgot it was even a clash jumper", and others thinking it was our new home jumper, I think it is pretty obvious what I was getting at.

I would love to wear the red and blue every week, and if the powers that be tick this one off, then I am delighted. But personally, I would have expected if the AFL wanted clash jumpers, they would want them to be, you know, less clashy.

Obviously this isn't unique, as many other teams have similar subtle changes, so obviously we have said, stuff it, if they can all do it than so can we.

but if it doesn't clash (where appropriate) then it is a genuine "clash jumper" the club has said they are using it for round 1 and "some other clash rounds". i suspect that at least this year it won't be the only clash jumper the club has to use.......but it's progress

[Vagg 2,439]

1 hour ago, ManDee said:

No, not at all.

I did think your earlier comment was odd, as I see it as a viable alternate strip. But the Collingwood & Essendon alternate strip show what a farce it really is. Good on us for having the red back. White shorts worked for years as you say.

I agree with you re Essendon.  But, not Collingwood!  (As much as I hate them!)  Their home jumper is mainly black (especially the back, which is all black, apart from the number).  Their alternate jumper is primarily white (the back being all white, except for the number).  While Eddie's joke of "we have white stripes on black, and as an alternate we have black stripes on white" might be a pain, the fact is that their alternate jumper really does satisfy the requirements, and I have no problem with it...

[Forest Demon 4,681]

18 hours ago, ManDee said:

No, not at all.

I did think your earlier comment was odd, as I see it as a viable alternate strip. But the Collingwood & Essendon alternate strip show what a farce it really is. Good on us for having the red back. White shorts worked for years as you say.

 

18 hours ago, daisycutter said:

but if it doesn't clash (where appropriate) then it is a genuine "clash jumper" the club has said they are using it for round 1 and "some other clash rounds". i suspect that at least this year it won't be the only clash jumper the club has to use.......but it's progress

Fair enough. I suspect our differing opinions is basically just I expect clash/away strips to be vastly different, and that probably comes from growing up watching as much soccer as footy. In soccer, an away strip is completely different, and it probably also explains why the white jumper never really bothered me as much as others. Although I did draw the line when Brock McLean came out in the long sleeve silver jumper.

[beelzebub 23,383]

The rationale, logic, argument that the filth pose is exactly what substantiates our use of a red back; it changes a predominantly dark blue jumper to a majorly red/lighter one.

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,884]

On Monday, February 20, 2017 at 5:14 PM, beelzebub said:

Nasher that AFL policy was hollow at best and farce in reality.

We only need 2 jumpers. Our real one and its new sibling. 

Red and Blue

Red and Blue

Not hard is it !!

Now we have ir lets just conveniently forget to ever take any others to games

Go Dees ( that red and blue team ) 

"Forget to ever take any others"?

Stuff that - BURN  all the white ones (just to be sure...).

Edited February 22, 2017 by Rodney (Balls) Grinter

[Pennant St Dee 13,305]

On 2/21/2017 at 11:53 AM, Forest Demon said:

Given other comments like "it is basically the same as our home jumper", and "I forgot it was even a clash jumper", and others thinking it was our new home jumper, I think it is pretty obvious what I was getting at.

I would love to wear the red and blue every week, and if the powers that be tick this one off, then I am delighted. But personally, I would have expected if the AFL wanted clash jumpers, they would want them to be, you know, less clashy.

Obviously this isn't unique, as many other teams have similar subtle changes, so obviously we have said, stuff it, if they can all do it than so can we.

It is no different to the difference in the Collingwood home and Collingwood clash differential 

[Pates 9,660]

21 hours ago, beelzebub said:

The rationale, logic, argument that the filth pose is exactly what substantiates our use of a red back; it changes a predominantly dark blue jumper to a majorly red/lighter one.

What are the chances we'll be able to wear this one vs Essendon? Would be great to see us playing them in a strip that isn't white. 

Incidentally that's always one of my biggest bugbears with the fixture. We very rarely get a home match against Essendon. 

[TeamPlayedFine39 8,510]

This may fly in the face of popular opinion here, but the main confusion for players, crowds etc. is when the player's backs are turned.  This is resolved by the new red backed Melbourne guernsey and even the Collingwood one, which looks farcical in the above image, but when worn on match day makes the players quite easy to distinguish.  We probably spend too much time and attention focusing on the front of the jumper where there is already different colours and patterns - the backs of most jumpers are where the confusion lies.

FWIW I don't hate the idea of a white clash strip, I just hate most of the design choices we've made over the years.  Now that we have once again changed the tone of red on our jumpers (looks much lighter now) hopefully the League accepts this as an appropriate alternative.

[Vagg 2,439]

Kinda off subject, given it's not about MFC.  But, did anyone see the Richmond game the other night?  Richmond wearing yellow.  Guess what colour the dopey umpires were wearing?!  Yep!  YELLOW!!  Go figure...!

The teams may not have clashed.  (The AFL managed to get THAT bit right.)  But, kinda looked like Richmond had 21 players on the ground!! 

Who is the brilliant individual in the AFL in control of such matters?  My two yr old grand-daughter could do a better job!  Fair dinkum!!

 

[daisycutter 29,743]

25 minutes ago, Vagg said:

Kinda off subject, given it's not about MFC.  But, did anyone see the Richmond game the other night?  Richmond wearing yellow.  Guess what colour the dopey umpires were wearing?!  Yep!  YELLOW!!  Go figure...!

The teams may not have clashed.  (The AFL managed to get THAT bit right.)  But, kinda looked like Richmond had 21 players on the ground!! 

Who is the brilliant individual in the AFL in control of such matters?  My two yr old grand-daughter could do a better job!  Fair dinkum!!

 

yep, unbelievable, vagg. just shows how incompetent the afl manage the whole clash situation.

[Sir Why You Little 37,149]

32 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

yep, unbelievable, vagg. just shows how incompetent the afl manage the whole clash situation.

There is no management

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

Can we close this thread quickly and delete please mods!

I would hate for an AFL rep to trip over this and see that we're pretty pleased with a clash strip for the first time and that common sense has finally prevailed!

[Leoncelli_36 2,264]

We have set the precedent with the red back, the third alternative needs only be this. It is that simple. Even I, as a white jumper hater, would buy a jumper like this

[daisycutter 29,743]

1 minute ago, Leoncelli_36 said:

We have set the precedent with the red back, the third alternative needs only be this. It is that simple. Even I, as a white jumper hater, would buy a jumper like this

definitely better than the last "white" one.......if we have to have a second clash strip for some games

[Leoncelli_36 2,264]

4 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

definitely better than the last "white" one.......if we have to have a second clash strip for some games

we definitely 'have to' have a third jumper. AFL have mandated as such. Remember we had an all red jumper last year, which we managed to wear once.

[monoccular 17,576]

On 26/02/2017 at 8:35 AM, Vagg said:

Kinda off subject, given it's not about MFC.  But, did anyone see the Richmond game the other night?  Richmond wearing yellow.  Guess what colour the dopey umpires were wearing?!  Yep!  YELLOW!!  Go figure...!

The teams may not have clashed.  (The AFL managed to get THAT bit right.)  But, kinda looked like Richmond had 21 players on the ground!! 

Who is the brilliant individual in the AFL in control of such matters?  My two yr old grand-daughter could do a better job!  Fair dinkum!!

 

Barrie - this reminds me of that absolute farcical night we played Footscray a few years ago.......the night we wore the pink jumper........and the genius at AFLHQ put the maggots in pink  too.  Late in the game as we were attacking with a real chance of a rare win, one of our guys mistook a maggot for a player and passed to him....Dogs cleared it and saved the game.

As I recall DumbItriou made some smart arse comment and brushed it off. 

 

PS this 'clash jumper' is the best one yet. 

Edited February 27, 2017 by monoccular
PS

[daisycutter 29,743]

8 minutes ago, monoccular said:

 

PS this 'clash jumper' is the best "white" one yet. 

corrected above 

[beelzebub 23,383]

On 23/02/2017 at 10:20 AM, Pates said:

What are the chances we'll be able to wear this one vs Essendon? Would be great to see us playing them in a strip that isn't white. 

Incidentally that's always one of my biggest bugbears with the fixture. We very rarely get a home match against Essendon. 

I seem to recall they've worn a predominantly red jumper against our preferred home one. 

Same diff really.