FA & Trade Whispers

[Willmoy1947 4,089]

2 hours ago, Satyriconhome said:

 

 

Saty, i do not always like or agree with what you say, however i do appreciate that you do respond and respectfully.

[Demonsterative 3,020]

4 hours ago, Satyriconhome said:

So you are telling me anonymous posters on an internet board do  

not sure where you are coming from with that comment  

seems a bit bizarre  

 I am not friends with players   I chat to them at training and functions    as I have the social skills to come out from behind my keyboard and do that

You seem more intent on trolling than contributing to the thread which was about us looking at Motlop and then Jeff Garlett was brought up, in my opinion, in an erroneous manner

I'm not trolling, I barely post now days. It's frustrating how you believe you feel the need to champion every player on the MFC list, then tell everyone your conversations with the players. By your own admission you are not friends with the players, so therefore the depth of your conversations and validity is not worth the keyboard your writing on.

 

HINT - poeple are tried of hearing about your conversations with the players. Try to keep em to yourself.... 

[Return to Glory 8,441]

7 minutes ago, Demonsterative said:

I'm not trolling, I barely post now days. It's frustrating how you believe you feel the need to champion every player on the MFC list, then tell everyone your conversations with the players. By your own admission you are not friends with the players, so therefore the depth of your conversations and validity is not worth the keyboard your writing on.

 

HINT - poeple are tried of hearing about your conversations with the players. Try to keep em to yourself.... 

Nah, it's all fun. The nuttier, funnier, combative and weirder the better. Go Dees.

[PaulRB 6,363]

Melksham, Hibberd, Motlop would all be top 22 players based on their past evidence, which to my mind equals us improving. 

They also add experience and fill the 24-26 age group where we are poorly represented.

Which is good.

[Demonsterative 3,020]

6 minutes ago, Return to Glory said:

Nah, it's all fun. The nuttier, funnier, combative and weirder the better. Go Dees.

Like everything, in the right doses. Now it's boring 

[Earl Hood 6,086]

27 minutes ago, Demonsterative said:

I'm not trolling, I barely post now days. It's frustrating how you believe you feel the need to champion every player on the MFC list, then tell everyone your conversations with the players. By your own admission you are not friends with the players, so therefore the depth of your conversations and validity is not worth the keyboard your writing on.

 

HINT - poeple are tried of hearing about your conversations with the players. Try to keep em to yourself.... 

I for one am happy to hear what Saty has garnered from talking directly to players. Not sure what some people's problems are with it all, it adds to our insight into what is going on down at the club. Much of the interest in this forum is about what people have heard from contacts close to the club, and of course we take it all with a grain of salt until verified by events. 

[Return to Glory 8,441]

35 minutes ago, Demonsterative said:

Like everything, in the right doses. Now it's boring 

Come on man. Saty loves the club. He talks to players from the club and he gets out amongst it and enjoys airing his views. I say good on Saty.

[Demonsterative 3,020]

9 minutes ago, Earl Hood said:

I for one am happy to hear what Saty has garnered from talking directly to players. Not sure what some people's problems are with it all, it adds to our insight into what is going on down at the club. Much of the interest in this forum is about what people have heard from contacts close to the club, and of course we take it all with a grain of salt until verified by events. 

If Jeff Garlett blamed his lack of form on his team mates lack of good ball movement into the forward line and coaches for asking him to step out of a forward pocket and play different roles when the season was basically over to a supporter/club member, he should be seriously line managed. 

Im not saying all Saty's post are not worthy, but his bias and need to champion every player by backing it up with a 'quote' from players who know to give supporters 'the party line quotes/conversations' is over stating his knowledge. 

[Demonsterative 3,020]

2 minutes ago, Return to Glory said:

Come on man. Saty loves the club. He talks to players from the club and he gets out amongst it and enjoys airing his views. I say good on Saty.

I agree R2G, I love the passion and the efforts of Saty.... Just not his need to defend every negative post on aplayer. I forget the name of the poster who stupidly made the comment that Jeffy stop trying after his contract renewal. Dumb!

But over kill is tiresome

[Yossarian 1,820]

Not worth the effort, Demonsterative. Just block him like the rest of us.

[Dante 2,739]

25 minutes ago, Demonsterative said:

I agree R2G, I love the passion and the efforts of Saty.... Just not his need to defend every negative post on aplayer. I forget the name of the poster who stupidly made the comment that Jeffy stop trying after his contract renewal. Dumb!

But over kill is tiresome

I'm the poster you're referring to and I simply said his form dropped after we extended his contract, I never said he stopped trying, that was an inference made by the other poster you're referring too.

Thats the problem, things get taken out of context by him and all of a sudden it's taken as fact.

ive got him on ignore because I'm sick of his grandstanding and derailing of every thread he gets on to.

 

 

 

[DV8 2,271]

7 hours ago, ProDee said:

As for Motlop...

Apart from Dangerwood and perhaps Caddy the Cats don't have an abundance of contested ball winners.  

Motlop is outside, but in a team full of contested ball winners (Tyson, Viney, Jones, Oliver, Vince, Brayshaw, Petracca) I reckon Motlop could be the icing that's missing.

In 4 of the last 5 years he's kicked at least 26 goals.  We only had 3 players kick over 26 this year and 2 last year.  Only Hogan kicked more than Motlop in 2016.

I'm not sure why some are quick to dismiss him.  He may just fit better in our side than the current Cats' side.

I don't like any who are too outside, too soft, & not contesting the hard ball.

But he must be better than Garlett in this regard & for consistency?  I would prefer to do better than to have 2 soft forwards.  But maybe we could take one step forward at a time. maybe get Motlop, & trade out Garlett?

But i would rather a Pickett in our front row.  With a name like that, he would have to be a hard ball winner as well.

[Akum 2,660]

8 minutes ago, DV8 said:

I don't like any who are too outside, too soft, & not contesting the hard ball.

But he must be better than Garlett in this regard & for consistency?  I would prefer to do better than to have 2 soft forwards.  But maybe we could take one step forward at a time. maybe get Motlop, & trade out Garlett?

But i would rather a Pickett in our front row.  With a name like that, he would have to be a hard ball winner as well.

This type of player is always inconsistent, with very few exceptions. They all go through a run of games when they don't do much and can't get near it, but they'll also have some great games where they seem to have the ball on a string and bob up everywhere.

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,396]

Was just reading Josh Schache rejected Brisbane's offer of a contract extension. Will be playing his mandatory 2nd year with the club that drafted him next year. 

Played 17 games, averaging 4 marks a game, kicked 16.18, the accuracy doesn't read well but having said that think I only saw him once and he went ok that day. Is he coming back to Victoria at the end of next year?

[DistrACTION Jackson 8,735]

6 minutes ago, Bombay Airconditioning said:

Was just reading Josh Schache rejected Brisbane's offer of a contract extension. Will be playing his mandatory 2nd year with the club that drafted him next year. 

Played 17 games, averaging 4 marks a game, kicked 16.18, the accuracy doesn't read well but having said that think I only saw him once and he went ok that day. Is he coming back to Victoria at the end of next year?

I really hope not.

[DeeZee 7,397]

Josh Scache will be gun , didn't get much supply this year playing with the lions.

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,396]

4 minutes ago, Is Dom Is Good said:

I really hope not.

Care to elaborate?

[Breggsy 123]

8 minutes ago, Bombay Airconditioning said:

Care to elaborate?

Don't really have much sympathy for the club but jees I feel for the supporters. Losing him after two years would be heartbreaking 

[Cards13 9,117]

6 minutes ago, Breggsy said:

Don't really have much sympathy for the club but jees I feel for the supporters. Losing him after two years would be heartbreaking 

After we went through something similar agree totally. Have to feel for the fans if he plays out the 2 years and looks to head  home because he is home sick and ends up somewhere like fing Cwood or Hawks.

[Dante 2,739]

29 minutes ago, Bombay Airconditioning said:

Was just reading Josh Schache rejected Brisbane's offer of a contract extension. Will be playing his mandatory 2nd year with the club that drafted him next year. 

Played 17 games, averaging 4 marks a game, kicked 16.18, the accuracy doesn't read well but having said that think I only saw him once and he went ok that day. Is he coming back to Victoria at the end of next year?

Probably waiting to meet the new coach and to get a picture of where the club is headed, I would if I played for Brisbane.

 

[jackaub 1,402]

6 hours ago, Akum said:

This type of player is always inconsistent, with very few exceptions. They all go through a run of games when they don't do much and can't get near it, but they'll also have some great games where they seem to have the ball on a string and bob up everywhere.

Except for E Betts

[Mickey 4,684]

4 minutes ago, Dante said:

Probably waiting to meet the new coach and to get a picture of where the club is headed, I would if I played for Brisbane.

 

Plus he will get a much better contract offer next year than this.

I wouldn't be too concerned about Schache leaving, if I recall pre-draft there was a lot of talk about him wanting to go to brisbane. Doesn't he have a family connection?

[dazzledavey36 54,946]

39 minutes ago, Mickey said:

Plus he will get a much better contract offer next year than this.

I wouldn't be too concerned about Schache leaving, if I recall pre-draft there was a lot of talk about him wanting to go to brisbane. Doesn't he have a family connection?

His old man played there and Josh was also a Brisbane supporter.

In saying that Josh's is very very close to his Mum who is a widow. I know for a fact Josh really struggled with homesickness as it was the first time he's ever been so far away from his mum aince his dad passed away.

Edited September 28, 2016 by dazzledavey36

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,396]

1 hour ago, Is Dom Is Good said:

I really hope not.

 

1 hour ago, DeeZee said:

Josh Scache will be gun , didn't get much supply this year playing with the lions.

 

54 minutes ago, Breggsy said:

Don't really have much sympathy for the club but jees I feel for the supporters. Losing him after two years would be heartbreaking 

 

39 minutes ago, Mickey said:

Plus he will get a much better contract offer next year than this.

I wouldn't be too concerned about Schache leaving, if I recall pre-draft there was a lot of talk about him wanting to go to brisbane. Doesn't he have a family connection?

 

27 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

His old man played there and Josh was also a Brisbane supporter.

In saying that Josh's is very very close to his Mum who is a widow. I know for a Josh really struggled with homesickness as it was the first time he's ever been so far away from his mum aince his dad passed away.

Appreciate all of that, thanks. 

Did anyone have ant constructive feedback on how he played in his first year?

 

cheers

[Ted Lasso 19,518]

29 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

His old man played there and Josh was also a Brisbane supporter.

In saying that Josh's is very very close to his Mum who is a widow. I know for a fact Josh really struggled with homesickness as it was the first time he's ever been so far away from his mum aince his dad passed away.

really feel for Josh, having to be an 18 year old key forward in that side with such huge expectations on him, i really think they'd do well to look at someone like Dawes just to provide him with some help/cover. and take the pressure off