FA & Trade Whispers

[Ethan Tremblay 30,823]

27 minutes ago, Is Dom Is Good said:

2nd round?

It would make it much easier to swallow. I just don't think I'm ready to let go of Hogan yet. 

[DistrACTION Jackson 8,542]

14 minutes ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

It would make it much easier to swallow. I just don't think I'm ready to let go of Hogan yet. 

Start preparing yourself.... at least that way you will be extra happy if he stays.

[Felix 92]

Melbourne will get pick 3, a player and a extra $1,000,000 in the salary cap.

 

If the midfield is as good ss is supposed to be. We shouldn't have problems getting the ball inside 50 for a score.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

19 hours ago, Flamingdees said:

I think we are still along way from a destination club. 

I don't agree. Even though some interstate clubs are fantastic, I think destination clubs are still essentially the Melbourne-based clubs and Geelong.

Hawthorn and Geelong aside, I reckon the MFC is the next cab off the rank at the moment given its list, the turnaround in its operations and coaching staff, and the rich history that can now be unlocked and enjoyed by this band of brothers. The Bulldogs are clearly well ahead of us in terms of performance, but the narrative to the Dees is sexier.

Convincing quality players and coaches to join the Melbourne Football Club is no longer an issue IMO. It's a good vehicle now.

 

[Sir Why You Little 36,955]

3 hours ago, Ron Burgundy said:

I don't agree. Even though some interstate clubs are fantastic, I think destination clubs are still essentially the Melbourne-based clubs and Geelong.

Hawthorn and Geelong aside, I reckon the MFC is the next cab off the rank at the moment given its list, the turnaround in its operations and coaching staff, and the rich history that can now be unlocked and enjoyed by this band of brothers. The Bulldogs are clearly well ahead of us in terms of performance, but the narrative to the Dees is sexier.

Convincing quality players and coaches to join the Melbourne Football Club is no longer an issue IMO. It's a good vehicle now.

 

Way to early to talk like this...

[stuie 7,374]

3 hours ago, Ron Burgundy said:

I don't agree. Even though some interstate clubs are fantastic, I think destination clubs are still essentially the Melbourne-based clubs and Geelong.

Hawthorn and Geelong aside, I reckon the MFC is the next cab off the rank at the moment given its list, the turnaround in its operations and coaching staff, and the rich history that can now be unlocked and enjoyed by this band of brothers. The Bulldogs are clearly well ahead of us in terms of performance, but the narrative to the Dees is sexier.

Convincing quality players and coaches to join the Melbourne Football Club is no longer an issue IMO. It's a good vehicle now.

 

Tell that to Prestia, Marchbank, O'Meara etc...

 

[DistrACTION Jackson 8,542]

30 minutes ago, stuie said:

Tell that to Prestia, Marchbank, O'Meara etc...

 

How do you know if we were even chasing them hard?

[stuie 7,374]

24 minutes ago, Is Dom Is Good said:

How do you know if we were even chasing them hard?

Not the point. The point is about young players and destination clubs.

Ridiculous to say we're the next destination club after Hawthorn and Geelong. Even Hibberd hasn't officially nominated us yet.

 

[Redleg 40,815]

2 hours ago, stuie said:

Tell that to Prestia, Marchbank, O'Meara etc...

 

Let's be realistic with these three. 

Prestia received a godfather offer from Tigers, end of story. 

Marchbank has been dealing with SOS all year and they have a relationship. He is also going to a club with several former team mates, is guaranteed getting a game and will no doubt be on bigger bucks than with GWS. 

O'Meara has had 2 serious injuries. He damaged both Patellas badly and then a Patella tendon. He hasn't played a full game in 2 years. Only a few quarters in a lower competition.

He is a massive risk to any club. 3 clubs pulled out after Medical testing. 

Few clubs could take the risk. The Bombers because they could get him for nothing. The Hawks because they have won 4 flags and are immune to criticism from fans or media. If he fires great if not they will say they tried. For them he could be high risk and high reward. If a bust, so what. They are also getting Tom Mitchell.

We can not be criticised in any of these instances. 

[stuie 7,374]

Just now, Redleg said:

Let's be realistic with these three. 

Prestia received a godfather offer from Tigers, end of story. 

Marchbank has been dealing with SOS all year and they have a relationship. He is also going to a club with several former team mates, is guaranteed getting a game and will no doubt be on bigger bucks than with GWS. 

O'Meara has had 2 serious injuries. He damaged both Patellas badly and then a Patella tendon. He hasn't played a full game in 2 years. Only a few quarters in a lower competition.

He is a massive risk to any club. 3 clubs pulled out after Medical testing. 

Few clubs could take the risk. The Bombers because they could get him for nothing. The Hawks because they have won 4 flags and are immune to criticism from fans or media. If he fires great if not they will say they tried. For them he could be high risk and high reward. If a bust, so what. They are also getting Tom Mitchell.

We can not be criticised in any of these instances. 

I'm not criticising at all, I'm being realistic about the pecking order of destination clubs, and the reality is we're still a long way behind and it's laughable that the poster I was replying to thinks we're 3rd in line behind Geelong and Hawthorn.

 

[daisycutter 29,600]

4 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Let's be realistic with these three. 

Prestia received a godfather offer from Tigers, end of story. 

Marchbank has been dealing with SOS all year and they have a relationship. He is also going to a club with several former team mates, is guaranteed getting a game and will no doubt be on bigger bucks than with GWS. 

O'Meara has had 2 serious injuries. He damaged both Patellas badly and then a Patella tendon. He hasn't played a full game in 2 years. Only a few quarters in a lower competition.

He is a massive risk to any club. 3 clubs pulled out after Medical testing. 

Few clubs could take the risk. The Bombers because they could get him for nothing. The Hawks because they have won 4 flags and are immune to criticism from fans or media. If he fires great if not they will say they tried. For them he could be high risk and high reward. If a bust, so what. They are also getting Tom Mitchell.

We can not be criticised in any of these instances. 

i'd still like to see how dorks could get o'meara + mitchell without giving up too much

[DV8 2,271]

40 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Let's be realistic with these three. 

Prestia received a godfather offer from Tigers, end of story. 

Marchbank has been dealing with SOS all year and they have a relationship. He is also going to a club with several former team mates, is guaranteed getting a game and will no doubt be on bigger bucks than with GWS. 

O'Meara has had 2 serious injuries. He damaged both Patellas badly and then a Patella tendon. He hasn't played a full game in 2 years. Only a few quarters in a lower competition.

He is a massive risk to any club. 3 clubs pulled out after Medical testing. 

Few clubs could take the risk. The Bombers because they could get him for nothing. The Hawks because they have won 4 flags and are immune to criticism from fans or media. If he fires great if not they will say they tried. For them he could be high risk and high reward. If a bust, so what. They are also getting Tom Mitchell.

We can not be criticised in any of these instances. 

The clubs who can roll the dice with injuries are the power clubs, with elite foundations, set in stone.

We're not there yet.

[Redleg 40,815]

52 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

i'd still like to see how dorks could get o'meara + mitchell without giving up too much

It will involve players plus their picks which are not great. 

[Redleg 40,815]

57 minutes ago, stuie said:

I'm not criticising at all, I'm being realistic about the pecking order of destination clubs, and the reality is we're still a long way behind and it's laughable that the poster I was replying to thinks we're 3rd in line behind Geelong and Hawthorn.

 

We are probably now in top 6 of Melb clubs as a destination club and success will improve that. 

[Flamingdees 227]

In my view for Victorian destination clubs in order  

First Bracket - Hawthorn, Collingwood, Geelong. 

Second Bracket - Essendon (up there with the top bracket a few years ago and will get there again), Richmond, Carlton. 

Third Bracket - Melbourne, Saints, Dogs, North. 

Still think we are a way off, we haven't made finals in past 10 years and have had how many bottom four finishes in that time.....

 

[binman 42,609]

Just now, Flamingdees said:

In my view for Victorian destination clubs in order  

First Bracket - Hawthorn, Collingwood, Geelong. 

Second Bracket - Essendon (up there with the top bracket a few years ago and will get there again), Richmond, Carlton. 

Third Bracket - Melbourne, Saints, Dogs, North. 

Still think we are a way off, we haven't made finals in past 10 years and have had how many bottom four finishes in that time.....

 

I reckon players who are moving clubs place likely success at the top of their list what clubs are a destination club. To that end i'd have Dogs in that top group and sainst and Dees in the second. 

[Gator 17,261]

7 minutes ago, Flamingdees said:

In my view for Victorian destination clubs in order  

First Bracket - Hawthorn, Collingwood, Geelong. 

Second Bracket - Essendon (up there with the top bracket a few years ago and will get there again), Richmond, Carlton. 

Third Bracket - Melbourne, Saints, Dogs, North. 

Still think we are a way off, we haven't made finals in past 10 years and have had how many bottom four finishes in that time.....

 

So you think Suckling would have gone to Carlton ?

There's no way Carlton are more of a destination club than Footscray, or us for that matter. 

We're an MCG club, which also gives us an advantage. 

[Flamingdees 227]

Not sure if one or two good years makes you a destination club. 

Need a sustained period of success both on and off the field. 

[Sir Why You Little 36,955]

Managers now pick up the phone when it rings. 

It wasn't always like that

[stuie 7,374]

5 minutes ago, ProDee said:

So you think Suckling would have gone to Carlton ?

There's no way Carlton are more of a destination club than Footscray, or us for that matter. 

We're an MCG club, which also gives us an advantage. 

Sorry "ProDee", but the facts go against you.

 

[Guest]

34 minutes ago, Flamingdees said:

In my view for Victorian destination clubs in order  

First Bracket - Hawthorn, Collingwood, Geelong. 

Second Bracket - Essendon (up there with the top bracket a few years ago and will get there again), Richmond, Carlton. 

Third Bracket - Melbourne, Saints, Dogs, North. 

Still think we are a way off, we haven't made finals in past 10 years and have had how many bottom four finishes in that time.....

 

Richmond and Carlton aren't ahead of the Dogs or even North in recent years...

[Flamingdees 227]

Just my opinion fellow Demonlanders. 

[Bring Back Barassi 552]

word around the traps is that Chip Frawley wants back in... wants to play finals again before he retires

[Cards13 9,117]

18 minutes ago, Bring Back Barassi said:

word around the traps is that Chip Frawley wants back in... wants to play finals again before he retires

Hahha good one.

[rjay 24,852]

1 hour ago, ProDee said:

So you think Suckling would have gone to Carlton ?

There's no way Carlton are more of a destination club than Footscray, or us for that matter. 

We're an MCG club, which also gives us an advantage. 

 

1 hour ago, stuie said:

Sorry "ProDee", but the facts go against you.

 

So who have Carlton landed since Judd?