POST GAME DISCUSSION

[Buzzy 992]

7 hours ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

A lot of things to like about today but my favourite by far was after the boys sung the team song and Kent walked past the camera, and yelled "Who farted?!" before putting his face into his jumper. 

 

I actually thought that wasn't a great look when there's a camera in your face.  What is he, 8 years old?

[640MD 3,375]

Can any one give me an idea where I can see a replay  never wanted to watch one before   Cheers

[Deemented Are Go! 3,677]

Now let's see if the media will focus on how crap Collingwood were or how well we played?! 

 

[Cards13 9,117]

7 minutes ago, 640MD said:

Can any one give me an idea where I can see a replay  never wanted to watch one before   Cheers

On the AFL site they have "watch the full replay" link.

 

http://www.afl.com.au/match-centre/2016/4/coll-v-melb

[jnrmac 20,058]

It's the first game in a long while where the umps have not been a factor. Hardly noticed them.

[640MD 3,375]

5 minutes ago, Cards13 said:

On the AFL site they have "watch the full replay" link.

 

http://www.afl.com.au/match-centre/2016/4/coll-v-melb

Thanks

[Dees2014 2,377]

13 hours ago, CityDee said:

Frosty !!! Showing why he may be ahead of Dawes with athleticism and effort and some finish . Hasn't played many games but looked to have started  his journey today - what you said . Lols this guy will be massive for us . 

When we get our finals side in I can't see him getting a game. For me his strengths are undoubtably his size and his speed. His biggest weakness is his kicking. Those who can't reliably kick will not play in our future champion sides. 

That also applies to players such as Tyson who has a habit of shanking his kicks particularly for goal, although that seemed to have improved over the last couple of weeks to his credit.

[leave it to deever 17,511]

11 hours ago, AdamFarr said:

  11 hours ago, Undeeterred said:

There was so much to like about today. Firstly, I'm definitely a WTF are those selections culprit and I'm totally happy to have got it wrong.

A few general thoughts:

• the chemistry is sensational and there's a real sense on field of these guys playing for each other. They will all come through the age brackets around the same time and in a few years that will play out very nicely for us

Yea how was the push and shove towards the end in the forward line wen they all came in to back up the melb player who just goaled i think it was tyson or frost. I love the way hogan struts in and starts pulling cwood payers off his team mates.

[leave it to deever 17,511]

8 hours ago, fndee said:

I have watched the replay, viewed the post match videos, had beer and wine and read every post on this thread. I can confidently say we are on our way.

If I wasn't technically challenged there would be the Sunnyboys singing "I'm a happy man"

 

 

.                                                          In this bit here

 

 

.

Here you go

 

https://www.google.com.au/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwjS8_3L6pbMAhVlKKYKHddYBjEQ3ywIHTAA&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DtsDBpTwu6Ew&usg=AFQjCNFMT5bKp52769JEQB377N2C0UIF3Q&bvm=bv.119745492,d.dGY

[Dees2014 2,377]

12 hours ago, AdamFarr said:

Anyone notice how many left footers we have in the team now? We've gotta learn to run to the correct side to give to those players and ensure they're on the left side.

Wagner, Salem, Bugg, Viney, Kent, Kennedy, Tyson. Have I missed any? Hello, Hawthorn.

Watts, Brayshaw, N.Jones - equally good both sides.

[drdrake 3,163]

Great to get the win, but really, don't get ahead of ourselves.  Some of the turnovers were horrific and until we get these out of our game we will continue to be hit and miss. 

Frost is like a 3 year old Colt, might need to be gelded to get that consistency.  The open goal that should have been in the last minute of the 3rd, what a goal it would have been he just got a little bit excited.

Happy with the win, need to improve for next week.

[Skuit 10,031]

Two quick questions re. umpiring decisions. The touched off the boot Treloar point that went to the goal review after a marking contest. Is this within the laws of review system? It seems if a field umpire calls touched then it could have an impact on the following contest. And the Frost free on the 3/4 time. Pedo picks up the ball after the free is awarded and is absolutely dumped. Can 50m be awarded to the kicker if a teammate is impinged in the process of returning the ball? Just curious (Read: I was one of those with a chunk of cash on a 39+ win).

[Adam The God 30,220]

3 hours ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

He (Oliver) seemed to be on the bench most of the first quarter so maybe were saving him for later in the game? He definitely set up at least one goal out of the middle with his vision, strength to stand up in the tackle and repeat effort.

Yep, it's incredible that we have one two guys that barely play more than 50% of the match and we don't get shown up on the spread. It has to be a testament to our more mature players' fitness that they can cover these guys. Don't listen to Dave Misson on the injury front, but he appears to be working wonders in his actual job.

[Forest Demon 4,681]

1 minute ago, Skuit said:

Two quick questions re. umpiring decisions. The touched off the boot Treloar point that went to the goal review after a marking contest. Is this within the laws of review system? It seems if a field umpire calls touched then it could have an impact on the following contest. And the Frost free on the 3/4 time. Pedo picks up the ball after the free is awarded and is absolutely dumped. Can 50m be awarded to the kicker if a teammate is impinged in the process of returning the ball? Just curious (Read: I was one of those with a chunk of cash on a 39+ win).

That is actually a good question. After hearing touched, the defender has every right to shepherd it through for a point. Would be unfair to then go upstairs and decide it wasn't touched.

[Adam The God 30,220]

35 minutes ago, jnrmac said:

It's the first game in a long while where the umps have not been a factor. Hardly noticed them.

I thought we got a very good go to be honest.

[Mydee 288]

13 hours ago, Whispering_Jack said:

Just checked in on the trip home at Narita Airport, Tokyo where the Qantas counter is manned by Japan Airlines staff all decked out to greet me wearing red and blue.

What a great place this is?

 

Dispatch from Bangkok

 

To quote Paul Keating, who demeaned himself by becoming a member of the piggery also know as the Collingwood Football Club;- "That was the sweetest victory of all."

 

I found a wonderful pub in Bangkok called The Sportsman's Bar that had the direct link and ensconced myself there, in the company of another Demon supporter. Thai border security, immigration and prison officials had done an admirable job as there was not one Wobble person to be found there. 

 

Here, lubricated with a few Heinekens, and good company,  I was was able to take in a magnificent game. Even though it is not the same as being at the MCG where you can take in the magnificent vista of an AFL game unfolding in a frenetic atmosphere watching a game live on the big screen does have its advantages, at least the car is safely garaged and won't be keyed anor are you likely to  be waylaid by toothless wobble creatures in the carpark

 

Jack Watts set the pace with an early goal. the Collingwood rabble answered but like their overseas supporters they soon disappeared, unlike their supporters in Bangkok the players reappeared after half time, if for only a short time. Melbourne soon got back on top and went on to score a memorable victory. It was fantastic to see the man mountain dominate the center bounces  and the revamped center line taking full advantage of his dominance. For Jack Watts four magnificent goals may have been sweet revenge for what the pack attack he endured on debut. I suspect the consequent course of rabies injections following his scragging may have spurred him on. 

 

Ah life can be so good at times

[Dees2014 2,377]

11 hours ago, Undeeterred said:

There was so much to like about today. Firstly, I'm definitely a WTF are those selections culprit and I'm totally happy to have got it wrong.

A few general thoughts:

• the chemistry is sensational and there's a real sense on field of these guys playing for each other. They will all come through the age brackets around the same time and in a few years that will play out very nicely for us.
• I think we won the BenKen/Howe trade. LOL Jeremy
• Do you think Treloar regrets not expanding the job search beyond Collingwood and Richmond?
• Freeing Hogan up to go back or chase kicks through the centre square, has worked wonders for him. Truly his best position and he will be Carey-esqe. He'd also be mental to go to Freo next year, let alone the year after.
• Speaking of best positions, why have we been facking around with Jack Watts for so long playing anywhere other than as a running, marking forward?
• I didn't think Bugg did a lot, but then saw 29 touches and 9 tackles. He's a bit rough around the edges but good on him
• Hunt certainly didn't look out of place
• Wagner is so composed - wonderful.
• Dom Tyson is getting back to his best, so too bad haters
• Lumumba is amazing when he lowers his eyes. Why has he been bombing it for 2 years??
• Dunn and McDonald were really, really excellent today. Dunn's bullet passes were sensational and McDonald's defensive work was first class. Garland and Grimes are done.
• Brayshaw is underdone and makes way for Garlett
• Frost played his best game for us and brought a huge amount to the table. Just needs to kick goals.

I agree about Brayshaw. I have no doubt he will be one of our A graders in the future but seems underdone and tired at the moment. I hope it isn't a concussion issue. Best for him to go back to Casey starting with limited game time and building back up to optimal fitness and form. We need him not only up and firing for the second half of the year, but also to make sure of his longer term fitness.

[Skuit 10,031]

The difficulty with Brayshaw. I thought he got better as the day went on. Maybe just still adjusting to the rhythm and pace of AFL? Would dropping him back down to the 2's be a disservice then?

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

2 hours ago, jackaub said:

No body has mentioned Frosts goal off the interchange i will watch the replay tonight

The pies supporters around me were dumbstruck Fantastic opportunistic play.

When I saw him kick it from fifty on the run, I knew it was our day.

Frost. On the run. From 50. 

 

[Dees2014 2,377]

11 hours ago, KrazyJay said:

I think most, including myself, are probably guilty of forgetting he is even on the list sometimes...

He is no depth player on his day either... I am excited by what lies ahead over the next few years!

 

Any doubt about the Jake/Max combination is dispelled by watching the Geelong game from last year. It was awesome. Can't wait to see them both back in harness, but sadly I suspect not this year due to injury and fitness.

[mrtwister 652]

1 hour ago, 640MD said:

Can any one give me an idea where I can see a replay  never wanted to watch one before   Cheers

If you don't have an AFL Live pass, try this one.

 

http://www.afl.com.au/video/smart-replay

[red and blue forever 1,018]

What a great game that was!!!.

 

Loving watts as the third tall he is really growing in confidence, and even trying to throw his weight around a bit now.

Like seeing Hogan being played around the ground more, good for him to get his hands on it more as opposed to being stuck in the forward line.

 

WAGNER!!! what a great game from the kid, very positive start.

 

Hunt had a great debut as well and I am looking forward to watching him progress.

 

Maximus Gawnus will be classed as the best ruck in the competition by years end. well done maxy!!

 

Viney just keeps getting better and better

 

Matt jones has been good the last two weeks in my eyes perhaps he will make it after all.

 

Tyson and bugg both played the best they have for the year

 

the confidence we are showing is a brilliant thing and will see us win more than we will loose this year.

 

loving it!!!

 

 

oh yes, and finally.....

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[3Dee 1,153]

Even sweeter to hear my pies lovin' boss went to the VFL match as well. All emails in red and blue font today..

[mrtwister 652]

Melb_vs_Coll.mov Adams incident with Harmes at the end of the 4th quarter. I smell MRP.

Edited April 18, 2016 by mrtwister

[BarnDee 287]

1 hour ago, 640MD said:

Can any one give me an idea where I can see a replay  never wanted to watch one before   Cheers

afl site mate