Trade Radio Discussion

[Dee-licious 1,954]

So in summary, our trade period has been a four pick downgrade in the second round, Toumpas and Howe for Melksham and Kennedy.

Absolutely brilliant stuff.

and dont forget that 3rd round pick......

If GWS get our 2nd rounder for Bugg I'm going to scream .

[Redleg 41,715]

Toumpas is worth a sh!tload more than pick 50!

He appears to be pick 29.

It is Kennedy and 50 for Howe. That is pathetic. For a regular 100 game player we get a kid who can't make the Pies side and pick 50. If true that is just terrible.

[rpfc 28,832]

So in summary, our trade period has been a four pick downgrade in the second round, Toumpas and Howe for Melksham and Kennedy.

Absolutely brilliant stuff.

And ND50.

Shuffling deckchairs but who cares, unless we are talking getting in a game changer and they rarely change clubs - it's all small potatoes...

[Weekends at Bernie's 64]

If we had got pick 32 that port got, the deal seems pretty fair. Josh Mahoney talks about how there going to drive a hard bargain and delivers that

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

I hope this is seriously just a pisstake.

Absolutely fuming right now.

because everyone around here rates Toumpas and Howe so much

come off it

[DSP 1,488]

Got to be a joke.

Has to be.

[MadAsHell 4,217]

So in summary, our trade period has been a four pick downgrade in the second round, Toumpas and Howe for Melksham and Kennedy.

Absolutely brilliant stuff.

Don't forget our extra 3rd round pick!

[rpfc 28,832]

How about we save the meltdown for when we get fleeced by clubs taking best 18 players?

[Nasher 33,617]

because everyone around here rates Toumpas and Howe so much

come off it

Funny, isn't it? They're surplus to requirements, right up until the point where the other clubs agree.

[What 18,810]

Wow, couldn't even get two 2nd rounders for Toump and Hoiwe, Depressing stuff considering the trade we had lined up with the Suns.

In summary, [censored] off Jeremy Howe you pea hearted tattooed lazy [censored].

[dazzledavey36 55,453]

because everyone around here rates Toumpas and Howe so much

come off it

Meh.. normally id argue this point with anyone else but because its you il just skim straight through you.

[whatwhat say what 23,064]

No one rushing to defend Mahoney now...

Pretty ordinary seeming deal the mfc.

[Guest]

and dont forget that 3rd round pick......

If GWS get our 2nd rounder for Bugg I'm going to scream .

And ND50.

Shuffling deckchairs but who cares, unless we are talking getting in a game changer and they rarely change clubs - it's all small potatoes...

Don't forget our extra 3rd round pick!

Ah yes, pick 50. Game changer.

[Guest]

and dont forget that 3rd round pick......

If GWS get our 2nd rounder for Bugg I'm going to scream .

We gave up a 2nd rounder for Frost last year, I fully expect it.

I wonder if Collingwood threatened to pull the QB games off us. Cant think of any other reason why we continually be happy to do whatever they want.

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

Has anyone kept tally of what picks GWS have.

Reason being can we offer 29 for Bugg or another pick as well?

[Bang Bang Bang 5,839]

The way I have painted it is Toumpas for Kennedy which seems fair. Both are living off their U/18 potential and done sweet bugger all in the AFL to date. Both lack composure.

Which leaves Howe for pick 29 and 50, seems like a poor result. I think Howe is worth two picks in the 29-35 range.

We better use 50 on Bugg and not 29...

[DeeMfc 621]

He's in talks with Carlton & St Kilda so not that entrenched.

That's good then. Apparently good mates with Dom Tyson too.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Funny, isn't it? They're surplus to requirements, right up until the point where the other clubs agree.

It's as if people don't understand that we actually have our own free will and have deliberately decided to make this deal. It wasn't forced on us. They obviously have their reasons.

[SaberFang 7,151]

Geez, and I thought 25 for Melksham was bad.

[MadAsHell 4,217]

Only was to salvage is trade picks 29, 46 and 50 to Sydney for Pick 14.

Trade Picks 6 & 14 to Gold Coast for Picks 3, 35 & Gorringe.

Trade 35 for Bugg and a later pick.

Then maybe package Grimes with our 4th round pick for a pick upgrade and get a 2nd live pick back up there.

[Mach5 4,768]

I'm yet to see this deal confirmed, so not sure why all the meltdowns...

[Redleg 41,715]

How about we save the meltdown for when we get fleeced by clubs taking best 18 players?

Come on, that is a pathetic deal for us, if that is what it is.

[DistrACTION Jackson 9,552]

The way I have painted it is Toumpas for Kennedy which seems fair. Both are living off their U/18 potential and done sweet bugger all in the AFL to date. Both lack composure.

Which leaves Howe for pick 29 and 50, seems like a poor result. I think Howe is worth two picks in the 29-35 range.

We better use 50 on Bugg and not 29...

If Redden is worth pick 17 there is no chance Howe is worth two second rounders...

[3Dee 1,153]

Melbourne recruiters, officially Bugged out.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Meh.. normally id argue this point with anyone else but because its you il just skim straight through you.

yeah I wouldn't want a logical point to slow down your pizzing and moaning and crying like a little girl as usual

fair dinkum you are soft