WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - SAM WEIDEMAN

[CBDees 3,167]

Why are the first two names i think of when it comes to drafting KPF'S early are Luke Molan and Lucas Cook?

If Charlie Curnow is available at 6 we'll take him. Otherwise expect us to draft a midfielder like Mathieson, Tucker, Balic etc.

Remember we are pick 7.

[Viscount Cardwell 188]

Do we need Weideman, when we have King, King should be ready in 12 months, when will the weed be ready ?

[dazzledavey36 56,318]

Do we need Weideman, when we have King, King should be ready in 12 months, when will the weed be ready ?

King is a couple of years away. Weideman is already a lot more physically mature than King.

[DeeSpencer 26,672]

Do we need Weideman, when we have King, King should be ready in 12 months, when will the weed be ready ?

Both could impact next year or take 5 years, you never know with big blokes.

My main concern on Weideman is he looks like a big tall but not a 2nd ruck. So if you have him, Hogan and a 2nd ruck in a forward line how will they work together?

North played 3 talls this year but Waite, Petrie and Brown are all very mobile and they didn't need a great 2nd ruck given Goldy can do so much.

If our future plans right now are the 2 Max's ruck combination and Hogan, then that would be better complimented with a 3rd tall like Curnow than a 197cm player.

[whatwhat say what 23,853]

weideman's ceiling is higher than any of the other supposed tall 'forwards'. both francis and curnow are more third talls - and curnow is more a mid-forward and francis more a defender. weideman and burton are genuine key forwards, while the twins are more ruck-forwards.

i really hope we get this kid.

[dazzledavey36 56,318]

I think quite obvious that Weideman if still available is a must pick at 7. Need another big key forward because lets be honest Hogan will eventually return back home to WA at some point in his career, so id rather stock up on a talented key forward now while we have the chance.

Sam Skinner is another i wouldn't mind at one of our later picks.. 197cm key forward or back who was MVP for Vic Country in the under 16s. Did his knee this year but should be right for the start of pre season.

[Redleg 42,152]

With Fletcher and Carlisle gone I think the Bombers will be keen to grab a big forward to help Joe, as Hurley and Hooker will probably fill the defensive spots.

Therefore unless they rate someone higher, i don't see him slipping to us. If somehow Francis and Weideman are there at GC pick, I think they will take Francis.

Anyway who really knows?

[Little Goffy 14,961]

I think quite obvious that Weideman if still available is a must pick at 7. Need another big key forward because lets be honest Hogan will eventually return back home to WA at some point in his career, so id rather stock up on a talented key forward now while we have the chance.

Sam Skinner is another i wouldn't mind at one of our later picks.. 197cm key forward or back who was MVP for Vic Country in the under 16s. Did his knee this year but should be right for the start of pre season.

Geez Dazzle you're on the sads about Hogan today - in two different threads. Though both relevant.

Hogan will stay at Melbourne over Freo because it will be a career path choice between emulating Norm Smith or Matthew Richardson.

(For the record, Richardson has played in just three finals, for one win, Norm Smith played in 16, for 10 wins, 1 draw, 5 losses, including a triple-premiership which he was a decisive factor in. Just in case anyone forgets!)

As for the complex issue of who fits where, personally I wouldn't mind a structure of 2xCHF and one resting ruckman at FF.

I think the 'modern game' demands a workrate from CHF that is more than any one player can contribute. By alternating who goes for the searching lead and who lurks menacingly in and out of the forward 50, both CHFs are always offering a target while also allowing for variation in the intensity of effort/comparative rest.

I think it would be very good, especially for a young team, to have certainty that there will always be someone there to kick to when they look up.

[DemonLad5 1,642]

I am getting pretty nervous that Te bombers will snap up Weideman and Francis at 4 & 5, GC take Curnow at 6. No key forwards left. Hopefully they take curnow and Francis and the Suns take a midfielder

[rpfc 29,024]

As a club, we shouldn't make decisions based on what a player may or may not do in 2 years time.

Let's just fake some confidence in ourselves shall we?

[CBDees 3,167]

I am getting pretty nervous that Te bombers will snap up Weideman and Francis at 4 & 5, GC take Curnow at 6. No key forwards left. Hopefully they take curnow and Francis and the Suns take a midfielder

Hopefully they take WEIDEMAN and Francis, leaving us CURNOW!

[KingDingAling 3,758]

I think quite obvious that Weideman if still available is a must pick at 7. Need another big key forward because lets be honest Hogan will eventually return back home to WA at some point in his career, so id rather stock up on a talented key forward now while we have the chance.

Sam Skinner is another i wouldn't mind at one of our later picks.. 197cm key forward or back who was MVP for Vic Country in the under 16s. Did his knee this year but should be right for the start of pre season.

Good pedigree, his old man was a good player, coached down in Mid Gippy. But according to my old man, Sam's Grandfather was a very, very good centreman. Sam should fill out, both his old man and Grandfather were stocky blokes. He'd be a good pick up for us, I think he'll be a good player.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Do we need Weideman, when we have King, King should be ready in 12 months, when will the weed be ready ?

...... we don't have king. he is only potential. "a maybe, or maybe not", at this stage, & if he does a knee, or something? Watt then?

.... what if Hogan gets out for a year, or more??? or forever. We need a key forward specialist, as a partner for Hogan, & preferably a rough tough one, who can also be like a clark keating as well, & smash-in in the ruck, for our future.

[DemonLad5 1,642]

Hopefully they take WEIDEMAN and Francis, leaving us CURNOW!

100% sure that the Suns would snap up Curnow

[CBDees 3,167]

100% sure that the Suns would snap up Curnow

That would leave us with neither Curnow or Weideman (contrary to every single Phantom draft that is going around).

[mog 58]

If Weideman, Curnow, and Francis are gone at pick 7 would Ryan Burton be worth taking or would that be a bit high?

All Australian as a bottom-ager before missing this year with broken leg.

Before his broken leg last year, he would have been rated higher then those 3.

[DemonLad5 1,642]

Hopefully dons take Curnow ahead of Weidman which I expect they will. They won't take both. Suns won't take Weideman.

[Wilson7 2,689]

King is a couple of years away. Weideman is already a lot more physically mature than King.

Definitely, Dawes & Pederson will be gone at the end of the year, we need another quality tall forward.

[monoccular 17,760]

Geez Dazzle you're on the sads about Hogan today - in two different threads. Though both relevant.

Hogan will stay at Melbourne over Freo because it will be a career path choice between emulating Norm Smith or Matthew Richardson.

(For the record, Richardson has played in just three finals, for one win, Norm Smith played in 16, for 10 wins, 1 draw, 5 losses, including a triple-premiership which he was a decisive factor in. Just in case anyone forgets!).........

...more a matter of in case anyone (else) is old enough to remember :-))

Can anyone tell me, is the Weed a mobile tall or a lumberer? Can / will / does he ruck?

[whatwhat say what 23,853]

he won't ruck. he's a key forward.

[CBDees 3,167]

100% sure that the Suns would snap up Curnow

Don't you think that our FD discussed this at length when GC agreed to exchange picks 3 and 6? I am sure that we came to an understanding as to who we both were going to target. (Not so confident about Essendon playing ball though!)

[M C 221]

Don't you think that our FD discussed this at length when GC agreed to exchange picks 3 and 6? I am sure that we came to an understanding as to who we both were going to target. (Not so confident about Essendon playing ball though!)

They would have spoken about it, but at the time it wouldn't have had too much meaning given we only knew about pick 10 at the time. I don't think upgrading to pick 7 was planned at that stage, so who GC took at pick 6 wouldn't really have been too much of a worry (as they could go at pick 7/8/9 anyway, before they got to our pick)

[The Great Pretender 480]

Not sure if anybody has considered this but Kieren Collins is a fair sized unit and a strong key position defender who some believe is not that far behind Weitering.

I don't believe Essendon will pass over Weideman if we take a mid with pick 3. Collins might well be the player to go for with 7.

[DeeMfc 621]

Not sure if anybody has considered this but Kieren Collins is a fair sized unit and a strong key position defender who some believe is not that far behind Weitering.

I don't believe Essendon will pass over Weideman if we take a mid with pick 3. Collins might well be the player to go for with 7.

On Collins. Weideman himself mentions that Collins is the hardest player he has played against.

See Here -

[Davos 932]

On Collins. Weideman himself mentions that Collins is the hardest player he has played against.

See Here -

Yeah, Jack Viney at one point said Jimmy Toumpas was the best player he's played with. Cool.