2015 Player Review - # 40 Mark Jamar

[Demonland 73,992]

The former All Australian ruckman has slowed down in recent years and after a good start was left out in preference to the younger big men and finished off his playing career at the club in the finals at Casey.

Games MFC 2015 5

Career Total 155

Goals MFC 2015 2

Career Total 56

Games CSFC 2015 16

Goals CSFC 2015 9

Keith "Bluey" Truscott Memorial Trophy 34 votes

[MadAsHell 4,217]

Reckon he'll get picked up as a delisted free agent by the Cats as ruck insurance.

[poita 3,929]

Should have been traded after 2012, but instead we gave him a fat new 3 year contract - thanks again, Neeldy. I can only assume his selection in the early rounds was aimed as motivation for Gawn, because Jamar was pretty ordinary for the most part. It was good to see him go back to Casey and do everything he could to help the Scorps out.

[jnrmac 20,311]

Should have been traded after 2012, but instead we gave him a fat new 3 year contract - thanks again, Neeldy. I can only assume his selection in the early rounds was aimed as motivation for Gawn, because Jamar was pretty ordinary for the most part. It was good to see him go back to Casey and do everything he could to help the Scorps out.

And who would have rucked for us in 2012?

[jamarkmywords 28]

Mark my words - the decision to delist Jamar was made far too hastily and has the potential to damage the fabric of our great club. The way we treat our club stalwarts is a disgrace. He had at least another 2 good seasons in him - not to mention that a lot of the development of Gawn is attributable to Jamar's tutelage.

[dazzledavey36 56,000]

Mark my words - the decision to delist Jamar was made far too hastily and has the potential to damage the fabric of our great club. The way we treat our club stalwarts is a disgrace. He had at least another 2 good seasons in him - not to mention that a lot of the development of Gawn is attributable to Jamar's tutelage.

Sorry Mrs Jamar but your son was cooked.

[jamarkmywords 28]

Sorry Mrs Jamar but your son was cooked.

I'm not saying he was still best 22 on a weekly basis however the leadership and guidance he provided to our younger players was underrated by many. I've no doubt that if we don't redraft him as a mature age rookie one of the contending teams with a ruck shortage (e.g. Bulldogs) will pounce

[Spirit of the Demon 256]

Should have been traded after 2012, but instead we gave him a fat new 3 year contract - thanks again, Neeldy. I can only assume his selection in the early rounds was aimed as motivation for Gawn, because Jamar was pretty ordinary for the most part. It was good to see him go back to Casey and do everything he could to help the Scorps out.

It never ceases to amaze me how people lay the blame for all list management decisions during his coaching career on Mark Neeld.

If he's to blame for those then what about the shockers that were made during Neale Daniher's time or Dean Bailey's? There were a lot more and they were far worse.

You really need to get your facts straight.

[Biffen 12,949]

I'm not saying he was still best 22 on a weekly basis however the leadership and guidance he provided to our younger players was underrated by many. I've no doubt that if we don't redraft him as a mature age rookie one of the contending teams with a ruck shortage (e.g. Bulldogs) will pounce

Not much room for non jumping rucks in the big league .

He had his day and tried his best. He just got old.

[Je Roos Salem 661]

No resentment towards Jamar. Played a role and most of the time did it reliably. He was on the decline but had to fill the spot till Gawn was right. Now we have to figure out if Gawn can build his tank to ruck 90% like Goldstein or if we will groom someone else to take 30-40% of the load