WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB – JAKE MELKSHAM

[CBDees 3,167]

Read this type of thing every year, you are kidding yourself if you think it's a hasty decision. Fitz is not steak knives, he has zero value trade wise.

So what do you think of a straight swap (without steak knives)?

[Wilson7 2,688]

So what do you think of a straight swap (without steak knives)?

I like the straight swap CB, i would be delighted if the Dons accepted Dawes for Melksham, would do that deal in a heartbeat

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

I like the straight swap CB, i would be delighted if the Dons accepted Dawes for Melksham, would do that deal in a heartbeat

I would be delighted if ANYBODY accepts Dawes for anything.

[dee-luded 2,959]

The Afl is the inside word prosiding over its tribunial who issue the penalty, in gillins words the players have gone through enough so no suspension required . What a joke .

this is what I've been saying from day dot. its not the players the AFL & ASADA/WADA are after; but those who brought the shame into the game... They,,, have their man.

[GawnWithTheWind 604]

Can we give them Terlich and M.Jones for him?

[Leoncelli_36 2,264]

Can I ask a question that may have been asked by others earlier but i have not read it, what are we doing going after a c grade mid who may not play at all next year if WADA come down hard. What if we give up a player and get a bloke that cannot play. Isn't this fraught with danger??

[daisycutter 29,795]

Can I ask a question that may have been asked by others earlier but i have not read it, what are we doing going after a c grade mid who may not play at all next year if WADA come down hard. What if we give up a player and get a bloke that cannot play. Isn't this fraught with danger??

you are not the first poster to point out the elephant in the room

as for skill rating, different posters seem to rate him anywhere from c- to b

[KingDingAling 3,758]

Can I ask a question that may have been asked by others earlier but i have not read it, what are we doing going after a c grade mid who may not play at all next year if WADA come down hard. What if we give up a player and get a bloke that cannot play. Isn't this fraught with danger??

Yeah, it isn't a good idea. Poor trading IMO.

[Leoncelli_36 2,264]

I would like clarification from AFL or our club as to the ramifications on taking a player being investigated by WADA. We could potentially be the laughing stock of the comp (again) if we put all our eggs into the melksham basket and he can't even play. Meanwhile toumpas and wines help port back to the finals. It would be oh so Melbourne if that were to happen

[hardtack 10,689]

Can I ask a question that may have been asked by others earlier but i have not read it, what are we doing going after a c grade mid who may not play at all next year if WADA come down hard. What if we give up a player and get a bloke that cannot play. Isn't this fraught with danger??

Well, we have had experience with Hogan and Petracca who sat out a year before playing for the Dees... maybe they see a benefit in securing him now rather than risk his going elsewhere?

[Leoncelli_36 2,264]

Well, we have had experience with Hogan and Petracca who sat out a year before playing for the Dees... maybe they see a benefit in securing him now rather than risk his going elsewhere?

having a laugh arnt you? He is hardly a sought after player

[hardtack 10,689]

having a laugh arnt you? He is hardly a sought after player

I actually don't have any thoughts about him one way of the other... if we take him, fine... if we don't take him, fine. I know he has performed quite well against us in the past and I would not be at all surprised if he was on the radar of other clubs (that's something both you and I have no knowledge of). I suppose we will know more over the coming weeks.

[Leoncelli_36 2,264]

Yes HT but we are in need of improving our list quickly. Unlike other clubs, we arnt looking to add list depth players. This is Roos' last year and the aim is finals in 2016. You don't give up a pick 4 who has essentially had three years on the list to get an average 24 year old who may not play a game next year

[Adam The God 30,539]

Yes HT but we are in need of improving our list quickly. Unlike other clubs, we arnt looking to add list depth players. This is Roos' last year and the aim is finals in 2016. You don't give up a pick 4 who has essentially had three years on the list to get an average 24 year old who may not play a game next year

I'll say it again. We must have received word from WADA or the AFL that stipulates he won't receive a ban. Or at least, that it won't occur during the season.

Edited October 5, 2015 by AdamFarr

[Leoncelli_36 2,264]

No way that we could have been given such an assurance

[daisycutter 29,795]

I'll say it again. We must have received word from WADA or the AFL that stipulates he won't receive a ban. Or at least, that it won't occur during the season.

you don't seriously believe that do you?

the case is a re-trial from scratch and hasn't even commenced

[What 18,810]

you don't seriously believe that do you?

the case is a re-trial from scratch and hasn't even commenced

Not to mention its completely out of AFL jurisdiction and free of their corrupt influence

[bing181 9,343]

All the AFL can do here is offer some kind of relief in terms of allowing us to add a player at a later date. Though hard to see how useful that could be, given that it could easily be February before we/they get final verdicts.

If Melksham were suspended, and we could add to the list, I have the perfect proposition for a last-minute call-up: Daniel Cross.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,099]

AFL site is talking about us doing a three-way with Port and the Bombers. We give up Toumpas and get Melksham. I'd probably call that a good deal depending on the WADA outcome.

[Adzman 2,154]

My father in law is a mad Essendon man, and as a result I have had to sit through many essendon games on TV. I simply don't understand why we are going to fork out $$$ for Melksham. He isn't the player we are looking for, and a second rounder or Toumpas to then bring in melksham at 400k for 4 years isn't making us any better. Maddening!

[SaberFang 7,151]

Toumpas for... Melksham?

Uh... yeah, I'd rather take a punt on Toumpas coming good.

[ignition. 1,478]

After speaking to him my impression was that the deal is already done and I expect that he'll be signed as soon as trade week officially opens. This gives me comfort knowing the club is currently chasing other unknown targets.

So please GET AROUND HIM!

By all means he must prove himself and earn the respect of the club and its fans, however he shouldn't arrive with any negative connotations derived from the Essenscum supporter base.

Edited October 5, 2015 by ignition.

[Deestroy All 14,266]

What if Worsfold likes him and convices him to stay please.

[CityDee 738]

Toumpas is a bust , even if melksham is suspended for a year he will have more upside , the guy can play and has a couple ahead of him at the bombers . We need some players who can finish and he is one that can hit up lace out. Toumpas has played a good game or 2 this year and I wish him all the best at Port.

[Pipefitter 2,180]

Toumpas is worth a 3rd rounder, Bombers want a 2nd rounder for Melksham. This is a win.