Defining Moments

[Deestroy All 14,266]

I agree with the Kent hit. He didn't flinch, got smashed and jogged off. It set the standard and I thought we were much harder than them all day.

The end to end Tyson goal was a thing of beauty and defined how [censored] ugly we've been to watch over recent years, and the great football we Demons supporters have not been able to enjoy. Gave me goosebumps.

[Red and Bluebeard 2,084]

I was wondering about that myself. He's taken it from right on the line. I guess it was fading towards the post, so he couldn't know that it was going through and if you ignore that little fact it was a great bit of play.

Agreed, but I still reckon Jonesy thinks Watts and Garlett own him a goal between them ...

[pineapple dee 2,892]

A few that haven't been mentioned yet:

Jack Watts set shot from the boundary. I was right behind it, and from the moment it left his boot it never looked anything but perfect.

JKH turning in board and hitting Tyson perfectly in stride, and Tyson finishing it off like a star.

vandenBerg's massive smother that eventually led to Nathan Jones' goal.

Garlett running away from a centre bounce for a long goal … nice way to answer a GC score, that was!

Garlett deftly dispossessed Prestia at the centre bounce then and ran onto the loose ball, sped off and we know the rest. How good is it by the way to yell out JEFFFFFF !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! again

[jane02 3,748]

I agree with the Kent hit. He didn't flinch, got smashed and jogged off. It set the standard and I thought we were much harder than them all day.

The end to end Tyson goal was a thing of beauty and defined how [censored] ugly we've been to watch over recent years, and the great football we Demons supporters have not been able to enjoy. Gave me goosebumps.

Just watching the replay now I've had a big lunch and done the Easter/family thing.

Kent went down so hard but is such a tough nut. Love the way Frost and HL went straight in - HL was really, really angry. Getting a very different vibe already compared to previous seasons. I'm loving the replay.

[sue 9,102]

Just watching the replay now I've had a big lunch and done the Easter/family thing.

Kent went down so hard but is such a tough nut. Love the way Frost and HL went straight in - HL was really, really angry. Getting a very different vibe already compared to previous seasons. I'm loving the replay.

Watts came in pretty quickly too, though because he bent over, he was easily pushed over.

Speaking of leadership the commentators didn't bag Ablett when he didn't congratulate that Coutts(?) guy for his first ever goal even though he was standing very close. Admittedly the game was effectively over at the time, but I can imagine the all round bagging that eg. Grimes would have got for that.

[jane02 3,748]

Watts came in pretty quickly too, though because he bent over, he was easily pushed over.

Speaking of leadership the commentators didn't bag Ablett when he didn't congratulate that Coutts(?) guy for his first ever goal even though he was standing very close. Admittedly the game was effectively over at the time, but I can imagine the all round bagging that eg. Grimes would have got for that.

You are correct. I couldnt take my eyes off HL. Watts came in pretty quickly as well. Great stuff.

[deanox 9,914]

not being picky (well, maybe just a tad) but that great tap down by wattsy to garrlett for the goal

.......watching the replay 10 times, he could have just let the ball go through and it would have been a goal

all's well that ends well i suppose - lol

My thoughts were that when you run and jump at a ball on the goal a couple of things happen. A) you don't know where the ball is with respect to goal, post etc so if you can mark you usually mark to make sure of it, unless you have approached the ball shower and are confident you can shepherd it through. B) you don't know if there is an opponent coming to touch it through.

It is better than "fly for the mark, not be able to take it, and rush it across for a behind". I think he decided to tap it down when he raised he want going to mark it and I'm Ok with that. Especially because it worked.

Goal of the round?

[Davos 917]

One day.

[What 18,810]

[sydneydee 687]

not being picky (well, maybe just a tad) but that great tap down by wattsy to garrlett for the goal

.......watching the replay 10 times, he could have just let the ball go through and it would have been a goal

all's well that ends well i suppose - lol

It looked to me that it would have been a point if Watts didn't Palm it back into play. I thought it was brilliant play

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

The fact that Melbourne actually played like a team was a defining moment for me.

[Deestroy All 14,266]

Not wanting to neck myself 20 minutes into the season was refreshing too.

[jimcor 212]

Late in the 3rd quarter, after garland had been slammed backwards into the plastic grass on the boundary, Hogan went up to the the GC player (Day?) and abused him at length. Day(?) backed off almost apologetically and maybe a little fearfully. Nice to see someone a bit frightening in red & blue. For me, the first since Byron Pickett to be genuinely scary. Frightening (in a very warm way) to think what he's going to be like when he gains some confidence!

[obbafan 128]

And how about Hogan deciding he was a mid fielder for a while there and doing good work.

[Phadraig 760]

The Tyson goal and Lumumba goal were the moments for me. I might have a short memory but that Tyson goal was like I was watching a good team for once. I used to be very biased by my ill feelings against Lumumba because of some of the things he had said in interviews but I think he is going to be a very good player for us and that was a fantastic goal when we needed it. The Hudson commentary was great as well

[Red and Bluebeard 2,084]

Cross to Salem for our last goal and almost on the same spot as the Essendon game last year is worth a mention ....

Edited April 5, 2015 by Red and Bluebeard

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

The more I think about it, the defining moment was at the selection table on Thursday night.

A lot of people here said it was the best looking Melbourne team on paper in a number of years and as harsh as it sounds, not seeing Bail, Matt Jones, McKenzie and Grimes (although I thought his NAB Cup was solid) was reassuring.

[Moneider96 1,045]

Cross to Salem for our last goal and almost on the same spot as the Essendon game last year is worth a mention ....

It was a completely different spot, but I get what you're saying.

[SaberFang 7,151]

The team winning was probably a bittersweet moment for those dropped, formerly best 22 players. Another poster observed that Roos probably gave them a final chance to take their game to another level in the NAB Cup, but all 3 just delivered more of the same (poor disposal, poor tackles, frees against).

Not their fault, they're just limited footballers. The decision has obviously been made to inject games into our youth now, due to their far higher ceiling.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

The team winning was probably a bittersweet moment for those dropped, formerly best 22 players. Another poster observed that Roos probably gave them a final chance to take their game to another level in the NAB Cup, but all 3 just delivered more of the same (poor disposal, poor tackles, frees against). Not their fault, they're just limited footballers. The decision has obviously been made to inject games into our youth now, due to their far higher ceiling.

For me, these players can still play a part (if they dominate in the VFL) but none of them should be relied upon too heavily and nor should more than one or two be in the team at the same time.

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

My thoughts too, it feels like we've found our ideal players, and the players that were just listed are now the backup/depth they should have been. They are battlers who can fill a role but their weaknesses are too much to cover if they all start in the team

[Red and Bluebeard 2,084]

It was a completely different spot, but I get what you're saying.

I was sitting in the same spot each time, so perhaps that went to my head ...

[FarNorthernD 5,861]

Cross to Salem for our last goal and almost on the same spot as the Essendon game last year is worth a mention ....

Yes, the last of our 17 goals.

A bit of frenetic play, Garlett looking to goal and can't, handballs under pressure to Cross, Cross then to Salem. Time slows momentarily, Salem makes a cup of tea, eats a bickie, reads a book, pats the dog and then kicks the ball. Goal umpire stands on that spot that marks the mid point between the two posts and looks to the heavens as the footy sails directly over her nose.

The defining bit? Was the fact that pretty much everyone of us knew that the only place that ball was going after Christian's kick was back to the centre square.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,212]

Was such a commanding grab, he was like a magnet the way the ball and the play just got drawn to him and he floated in front of everyone like a graceful Godzilla.(or perhaps just God)

Great kick from Viney to the hot spot too.

Yep, didn't see much of the fumbles he exhibited during the NAB Challenge either. He's made for playing in the middle of the G not in the middle of nowhere.

[monoccular 17,427]

Yes, the last of our 17 goals.

A bit of frenetic play, Garlett looking to goal and can't, handballs under pressure to Cross, Cross then to Salem. Time slows momentarily, Salem makes a cup of tea, eats a bickie, reads a book, pats the dog and then kicks the ball. Goal umpire stands on that spot that marks the mid point between the two posts and looks to the heavens as the footy sails directly over her nose.

The defining bit? Was the fact that pretty much everyone of us knew that the only place that ball was going after Christian's kick was back to the centre square.

Salem does create time, doesn't he. Great to watch. Not too many in the competition can do that so well.