Jonathan Giles

[juzzk1d 1,354]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2014-09-18/giant-wants-out

Requested a trade out.. Can show he can Ruck and play forward.

Could do something in a package deals that see us land both Frost and Giles?

[rpfc 27,597]

Leuenberger!

[Demonoid11 2]

I'd take Giles over Leuey, he's more agile and hits the pack harder and less injury prone.

[juzzk1d 1,354]

I'd take Giles over Leuey, he's more agile and hits the pack harder and less injury prone.

Not to mention will come at a lower cost. Not being able to break into a side and demanding a trade decreases his currency.. I could potentially see a fair package deal that could see us land both Frost and Giles.

[Deemotivated 550]

Leuenberger!

Good player but you will never get full value out of his injury prone body.

[TeamPlayedFine39 8,187]

What would Giles be worth in a trade?

or

What would a Frost/ Giles double cost us?

[the grint 71]

Frost, Giles and Shiel for pick 3 and ~40 and Blease

[dee-luded 2,958]

Frost, Giles and Shiel for pick 3 and ~40 and Blease

I'd take Giles over Leuey, he's more agile and hits the pack harder and less injury prone.

if he's from the Clark Keating mold, grab him?

[Demonoid11 2]

Frost, Giles and Shiel for pick 3 and ~40 and Blease

This would make me one happy Dee's Supporter, would fill our voids and then all we need is another key position forward.

[juzzk1d 1,354]

Frost, Giles and Shiel for pick 3 and ~40 and Blease

Blease & Giles both aren't getting games at their respective clubs.. Therefore this should be seen as a straight swap. Personally I believe Shiel is worth pick 3 alone, however if GWS were to trade Shiel it would be in order to draft Petracca, and with us holding pick 2 and Saints pick 1 he won't fall to them.

[the grint 71]

Yeah im pretty convinced we wont be targeting the names everyone says we are. Tyson and Vince came from nowherr and I expect Roos has a similar strategy this year. North have quite a few quality players who arent getting a game.

Back on topic though, I wouldnt mind getting Giles and fazing out poor Russian

[CBDees 3,162]

Blease & Giles both aren't getting games at their respective clubs.. Therefore this should be seen as a straight swap. Personally I believe Shiel is worth pick 3 alone, however if GWS were to trade Shiel it would be in order to draft Petracca, and with us holding pick 2 and Saints pick 1 he won't fall to them.

It will if we trade pick 2 instead of 3. I would be happy if we ended up with Sheil and Brayshaw!

[juzzk1d 1,354]

IN: Shiel, Frost, Giles, Brayshaw

Out: Pick 2, Pick 40, Blease // Pick 3 (Consumed on Brayshaw)

boom

[SaberFang 7,141]

Pick 3 and Toumpas for Dangerfield.

Tappy/Strauss to anyone for 4th rounder.

Pick 2, 20 & 4th rounder for Shiel, Giles and Frost.

Clark trade for Lamumba.

Robinson trade for Blease.

3rd rounder F/S for Stretch.

Gwilt, ROK and/or Clint Jones as DFA.

Seems like a good off season to me.

(will stop day dreaming now)

Edited September 18, 2014 by Lamashtu

[Bendigo Demon 115]

I don't want to predict what we should or shouldn't trade for Giles, but I certainly think that he is the type of person we need, Has showed he can play at the level, but struggles for opportunities with Sandilands and Clarke in front of him.

[TheoX 1,218]

I don't want to predict what we should or shouldn't trade for Giles, but I certainly think that he is the type of person we need, Has showed he can play at the level, but struggles for opportunities with Sandilands and Clarke in front of him.

Huh? He's from GWS.

[CBDees 3,162]

Pick 3 and Toumpas for Dangerfield.

Tappy/Strauss to anyone for 4th rounder.

Pick 2, 20 & 4th rounder for Shiel, Giles and Frost.

Clark trade for Lamumba.

Robinson trade for Blease.

3rd rounder F/S for Stretch.

Gwilt, ROK and/or Clint Jones as DFA.

Seems like a good off season to me.

(will stop day dreaming now)

Don't mind your scenario generally with the exception of Toumpas. I feel that both Toumpas and Trengove [who many here want to trade] should be retained at least until the end of next year as i suspect that both will wnd up long term gun players for the MFC under Roos. Apart from GWS how many other Clubs have their members clambering to trade off thier No. 2 and No. 3 draft picks?

[dee-luded 2,958]

Blease & Giles both aren't getting games at their respective clubs.. Therefore this should be seen as a straight swap. Personally I believe Shiel is worth pick 3 alone, however if GWS were to trade Shiel it would be in order to draft Petracca, and with us holding pick 2 and Saints pick 1 he won't fall to them.

Shiel will be back in Vic next year one way or another. GWS have the ability to get something for him this season, as he has 1Yr of contract to go.

If the Saints use P-1 on Petracca or other, We have the ability to negotiate with Shiel & GWS, for Shiel & extras. IF the saints trade P-1 to GWS were up the ditch..

I'm very keen to get both Shiel & Jaksch into red & blue... as they are both definately coming back home to Vic in the next 12 months, P-3 + something, to get them both over the line.

[dee-luded 2,958]

Pick 3 and Toumpas for Dangerfield.

Tappy/Strauss to anyone for 4th rounder.

Pick 2, 20 & 4th rounder for Shiel, Giles and Frost.

Clark trade for Lamumba.

Robinson trade for Blease.

3rd rounder F/S for Stretch.

Gwilt, ROK and/or Clint Jones as DFA.

Seems like a good off season to me.

(will stop day dreaming now)

Like... but don't think I want robinsoon in red & blue surely we could do better with blease than him... blease for Waite?

[hillie 41]

I know his rellies in Adelaide. Wants to go back to SA with port Adelaide. Watch this space.

He is related also to jack Hannath of freo who we had promised a spot to. This has nothing to do with where he is going but just puttin it out there