6: Dunn

5: Pedersen

4: Jones M

3: Jones N

2: Vince

1: McDonald

(6) Pedersen- The best game I have seen him play. He was fantastic.

(5) Dunn- I prefer him in the backline.

(4) N. Jones- A typical workhorse performance. Perhaps not as influential as usual, but he was still very good.

(3) Cross- Just the role model that our young players need

(2) McDonald- Held Buddy very well; was unlucky to have the soft free kick called against him.

(1) M. Jones- I'm a big fan of this guy. Great run all night long.

Unlucky: Vince, JKH

Edited April 26, 201411 yr by Good Times Grimes

6. Pedersen (sad state of affair when he is our best but truth be told he was great )

5. M. Jones

4. Dunn

3. T Mac

2. N. Jones

1. Vince

Worst players: anyone whose 1st name begins with a J but does not have their surname begin with a V.

6. M Jones

5. Dunn

4. N Jones

3. Pedersen

2. Vince

1. Cross

Typo: Name spelling correction.

Edited April 27, 201411 yr by La Dee-vina Comedia

If Pedo continues to improve, it might be time to learn to spell his name.

6: Dunn

5: Pedersen

4: Jones M

3: Jones N

2: Vince

1: McDonald

Addendum:

Had the game been one quarter long (the last) I'd have given votes to C Salem. Nice debut (and if he's only 183 cm I'll eat my hat/cap).

JKH also improving each week!

Nathan Jones now well in front.

77. Nathan Jones

43. Lynden Dunm

42. Dom Tyson

26. Daniel Cross

25. James Frawley

23. Tom McDonald

17. Jack Watts

16. Matt Jones Bernie Vince Jack Viney

14. Jeremy Howe

12. Chris Dawes

11. Cam Pedersen

10. Jack Grimes

6. Rohan Bail Alexis Georgiou Jimmy Toumpas

3. Dean Terlich Jack Trengove

2. Shannon Byrnes Jake Spencer

Jack Watts more votes than Jack Viney

LOL

Unofficial Tally (sample of 10 votes taken)

• N Jones - 256
• Dunn - 139
• Tyson - 116
• Cross - 111
• Frawley - 84
• Pedersen - 81
• Watts - 65
• Viney - 63
• M Jones - 57
• McDonald - 45
• Vince - 43
• Dawes - 41
• Grimes - 36
• Howe - 29
• Spencer - 23
• Georgiou - 20
• Bail - 18
• Byrnes - 10
• Toumpas - 9
• Terlich - 8

Trengove 3

JKH 2

Jamar 1

Best 5 per round (in order):

Rd 1 (St K): Watts, N Jones, Dunn, Tyson, Vince

Rd 2 (WC): N Jones, Dunn, Tyson, Cross, Frawley

Rd 3 (GWS): Tyson, Pedersen, Howe, McDonald, Cross

Rd 4 (Car): N Jones, Frawley, Grimes, Spencer, Bail

Rd 5 (GC): N Jones, Viney, Dawes, Frawley, Cross

Rd 6 (Syd): Dunn, Pedersen, M Jones, N Jones, Vince

Most consistent (tally of top 5ers):

N Jones - 5

Cross - 3

Frawley - 3

Tyson - 3

Dunn - 3

Pedersen - 2

Vince - 2

Watts - 1

Viney - 1

Dawes - 1

Howe - 1

McDonald - 1

Grimes - 1

Bail - 1

Spencer - 1

M Jones - 1

Edited April 27, 201411 yr by P-man

A bit late but thread isn't closed so....

6. Dunn

5. N Jones

5. Cross

3. Pedersen

2. Vince

1. M Jones

6. M.Jones

5. Pedersen

4. Vince

3. Dunn

2. Jamar

1. N. Jones

Edited April 27, 201411 yr by GM11

6. Pedersen

5. Dunn

4.M Jones

3.N. Jones

2. Vince

1.Cross

6. Dunn - our backline General

5. Cross - great defensive job on McVeigh and took some great contested marks when pressure was on

4. Pederson - would get the 6 votes based on effort alone, loved his game

3. N Jones - a benchmark Jones game

2. M Jones - provide great run

1. Grimes - really solid game

Honourable mentions to J Viney - some great work in congestion but let down by his finish, M Jamar - better than he's been for 2 years and will be good for the run, C Dawes - love his defensive effort.

Dishonourable mentions to J Watts and J Howe for not putting pressure on the ball carrier. I reckon we'd have been a 3 goal better side with Salem starting on and Watts as sub and Clisby/Nicholson in place of Howe purely based on our ability to trap ball in our fwd half.

Dunn

Pedersen

Jamar

M Jones

Cross

Vince

In reverse order:

1. Cross
2. Vince
3. N. Jones
4. M. Jones
5. Pedersen
6. Dunn

plus very impressed by Salem and love JKH

6. Pederson (best game of 4 quarters I have seen from him)

5. Dunn (still likely to do stupid silly agro things that cost us 50m penalty)
4. Jones M (has improved out of site)
3. Jones N. (does what he does best)
2. McDonald (he sucked Franklin in)
1. Vince (Played well but kicking was atrocious)

6. Dunn

5. Pederson

4. M . Jones

3. Cross.

2. Vince

1. N Jones.

6 - Lynden Dunn

5 - Tom McDonald

4 - Cam Pedersen

3 - Nathan Jones

2 - Alex Georgiou

1 - Daniel Cross

Georgiou is criminally underrated by Melbourne supporters

6. Nathan Jones (i am just getting more impressed with this guy, each game he plays)

5. Matt Jones (best i've ever seen him play)

4. Lynden Dunn (Proving to be a real asset)

3. Bernie Vince (loving the 28 kicks)

2. Tom Mcdonald (solid all night)

1. Cam Pederson (best game as a demon)

core group

n jones m jones cross dunn pedersen mcdonald vince grimes viney tyson dawes frawley

improving

jetta jkh salem (impressed)

battled on

jamar byrnes terlich georgiou bail

all show, no guts

watts howe ... MUST LIFT

Edited April 29, 201411 yr by spirit of norm smith

6 Pederson
5 Dunn
4 NJones
3 MJones
2 Vince
1 Cross