Not sure why but my first impression was of the afterglow resulting from thermal annihilation !!

Not quite a warm and fuzzy feeling lol

My first thought too when I saw it - or the landscape 5 minutes after the final siren MFC vc WCE

I like it. Shows all the fit KPFs in a visual format. Clever

POST OF THE YEAR SO FAR!

I would have to say that i'm not always simpatico with Osiliks views but Dunn deserves a spot on our banner. In my humble opinion he is in our top 8 players and is arguably our most consistent player and perhaps our most underrated player.

He misses few games through injury, hits targets by hand and foot, is good in the air and rarely gets beaten one on one. Seriously how many other players on our list could tick all those boxes.

If it's arguing against one Nate Jones then it will lose, hands down, every single time.

I've never rated Dunn but funnily enough I do agree that he is in our top 8 most consistent performers (unfortunately I just see that as a representation of where our list is at).

I also don't think he's banner-worthy just yet. Maybe it's that mo etched in my memory from the past few years (I still picture him with it) but he's just never been a marketable player in my opinion.

If it's arguing against one Nate Jones then it will lose, hands down, every single time.

Yep, fair call. Would you accept one of our second most consistent player?

Simply put Roos, Jones and Grimes.

That's all that is needed.

I actually just write Demonland with a pic of Roos and leave it as that.

Yep, fair call. Would you accept one of our second most consistent player?

For now, yes. But I would love to have this chat again this time next year!

PS In regards to the banner, I personally wouldn't mind seeing some faces from the Team of the Century (keep in mind I'm a newcomer so forgive me if it's been done before). Ron Barassi, Jim Stynes, Norm Smith, Robbie Flower to name a few. There are some absolute legends in that team.

Jim Stynes is forever in the banner, I can see him now

How about a pic of the side in a boat with out a paddle going up [censored] creek.

Yeah lets go without current players. It only seems to jinx them.

and the ghosts appear

If I have such powers then I really need to figure out how to use it for good instead of evil. Either that or work out a way to monetise it.

Put a couple of filth players up, see what happens?

not sure why you would take the old one down without first thinking of a replacement

I quite like it

not sure why you would take the old one down without first thinking of a replacement

What makes you think I haven't?

I know what players and images I'm going to use I just haven't finished it yet.

I also like the suspense. I wanted to do it before the season started but life got in the way.

not sure why you would take the old one down without first thinking of a replacement

think....

I think we should just wait yo see who stands up consistently this year and add them as we go.

Jones is a given.

Put whoever's fit on the banner.

Should be plenty of room for all of them.

If Matthew Whelan doesn't make this incarnation of the banner I'll crack it Dale Kickett style.

from left to right,

Trengove, Garland, Jones, Roos, Grimes, Watts, Dunn

From left to right: Cursed spaced.

Just do it

Howe has got to make it up this time .

Paul Roos and all of his Melbourne premiership players.

Wonder who the bald bloke is...