Post Match Discussion

[dees189227 12,373]

7615 at TIO Stadium was the crowd tonight. Was this more than last year?

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Number 2 picks since 2001:

Luke Ball

Daniel Wells

Andrew Walker

Jarred Roughhead

Daisy Thomas

Scott Gumbleton

Trent Cotchin

Nic Nat

Trengove

Harley Bennell

Stephen Conniglio

Jonathan ORourke

Too soon to tell on the last 2 but with the possible exception of Gumbleton I'd say JT looks way out of his league. I don't think the frustration is with his effort. The frustration is with his potential to have an impact with skill or speed that matches anyone on that list.

He looks to be going backwards.

guess what the first 8 guys on that list have in common.. they've all been around longer than JT

[DemonOX 8,787]

At parts it felt like neeld was still coaching. Our manning up was poor, we couldnt get it out of the middle and we still went down the line.

But my question is when they showed Craig in the coaches box he had todd and two others. Where were our assistant coaches. I didnt see Rawlings, brown or royal at all.

Neelds excellent coaching will take the boys a little while to get out of their system but they are well on the way.

The coaches box I think only had one camera angle and at the start of the coverage u saw Royal (that's our top midfield coach!) in the shot but after that it was just the V man and Craigy.

[Chook 15,012]

Neelds excellent coaching will take the boys a little while to get out of their system but they are well on the way.

The coaches box I think only had one camera angle and at the start of the coverage u saw Royal (that's our top midfield coach!) in the shot but after that it was just the V man and Craigy.

It's pretty much a two man band right now. I think the rest of 'em have been told to go stare at a wall for the next six weeks until their contracts are up.

[Nasher 33,607]

you would swear we lost by 100 reading this

Totally agree mate. Sometimes the mood on this forum is so misaligned with my own that I wonder what I missed.

[P-man 13,366]

Number 2 picks since 2001:

Luke Ball

Daniel Wells

Andrew Walker

Jarred Roughhead

Daisy Thomas

Scott Gumbleton

Trent Cotchin

Nic Nat

Trengove

Harley Bennell

Stephen Conniglio

Jonathan ORourke

Too soon to tell on the last 2 but with the possible exception of Gumbleton I'd say JT looks way out of his league. I don't think the frustration is with his effort. The frustration is with his potential to have an impact with skill or speed that matches anyone on that list.

He looks to be going backwards.

Yep. You can only put your head in the ground and say "he'll come good" for so long. It's frustrating, but probably just have to accept that he has limitations, and go from there.

He still has time on his side, and I think his skills are fine. It's his leg speed and decision-making that are so restricting.

[Ted Lasso 19,311]

I would have thought Dawes would be more worthy than Trengove of this weeks demonland hanging? 500k a year and he was shown up bigtime by fitz today, granted he has played some good games this year for us and his leadership has been impressive but we are paying him alot of money so he really should be showing abit more touch.

[The heart beats true 18,110]

Cool, you guys can defend Trengove and in a way I admire your support for him. I'm just very worried that he's going to be just a handy second tier player when what we should have got was an A grader.

[DeeSpencer 25,477]

Yep. You can only put your head in the ground and say "he'll come good" for so long. It's frustrating, but probably just have to accept that he has limitations, and go from there.

He still has time on his side, and I think his skills are fine. It's his leg speed and decision-making that are so restricting.

Id argue that Wells, Walker, Roughead and Thomas were no more advanced by the same stage of their careers.

The leg speed will limit the way he plays but possibly not how well he plays. Led the way comprehensively with tackles again today.

[Undeeterred 3,123]

Cool, you guys can defend Trengove and in a way I admire your support for him. I'm just very worried that he's going to be just a handy second tier player when what we should have got was an A grader.

I think he is the same boat as the rest of our top end midfielders.

He needs a stable and environment and some help. Amazing what will happen once those two things are in place.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Totally agree mate. Sometimes the mood on this forum is so misaligned with my own that I wonder what I missed.

me too, and I consider myself quite a pessimist by nature

[DeeSpencer 25,477]

I would have thought Dawes would be more worthy than Trengove of this weeks demonland hanging? 500k a year and he was shown up bigtime by fitz today, granted he has played some good games this year for us and his leadership has been impressive but we are paying him alot of money so he really should be showing abit more touch.

I would've liked him to hold some more but he still worked damn hard. Really Fitzy's performance was very good for a greasy night but it was his speed that allowed him to play small that set up the performance.

It's fairer to compare Dawes' performances of the last two weeks to the big forwards at the other end in Hawkins, Pods and Merrett and there wasn't much between them

[Grapeviney 9,712]

Jack Viney, how I love thee

[P-man 13,366]

Id argue that Wells, Walker, Roughead and Thomas were no more advanced by the same stage of their careers.

The leg speed will limit the way he plays but possibly not how well he plays. Led the way comprehensively with tackles again today.

I will applaud anyone who doubles the number of tackles of anyone else on the field. His effort is not to be questioned.

But offensively, his lack of speed is having a clear impact. Opposition players eyes must light up when he gets the ball because he's so painfully slow in everything he does. You also up your tackle count when you're always second to the ball.

[DemonOX 8,787]

I just want to see us win

I am over losing

I want my kids to c us win

I want that winning feeling back and I'm sure the players do to.

[Ted Lasso 19,311]

I would've liked him to hold some more but he still worked damn hard. Really Fitzy's performance was very good for a greasy night but it was his speed that allowed him to play small that set up the performance.

It's fairer to compare Dawes' performances of the last two weeks to the big forwards at the other end in Hawkins, Pods and Merrett and there wasn't much between them

He is alot like trenners in that he is great at the defensive side of things and the next step will come from adding more offensive potency, would love to see him become a 40-50 goal a year forward

[Young Dee 1,303]

It's a bit gloomy on here today!

We lost by 20 points (one of our smallest margins for the year)

Brisbane recently bet north and Geelong!

Improvement is all I ask for and that's what I got today so I am happy (cant run before you learn to walk)

Least we all know now that our midfield will be the key to us improving (and I think it would make a huge difference)

Hope we can get that priority pick and trade it for an established mid (23-26)

[Young Dee 1,303]

I would have thought Dawes would be more worthy than Trengove of this weeks demonland hanging? 500k a year and he was shown up bigtime by fitz today, granted he has played some good games this year for us and his leadership has been impressive but we are paying him alot of money so he really should be showing abit more touch.

Do you think fitzy would have played nearly as we'll if Dawes didn't play (Dawes would be getting the best defender and is probably looking forward to Clark returning and a midfield that actually knows how to kick to a leading forward)

[Pates 9,660]

I gave up on Trengove becoming a gamebreaker last year, I see him being able to hold a spot as a contributer but he just does not seem to have the attributes he first had when he came to the club.

They had a fair go today, but lacked the patience and poise when needed. When we needed goals, we just seemed to miss them.

Some good signs there but I really thought we could get the win tonight.

Edited July 20, 2013 by Pates

[Ted Lasso 19,311]

Do you think fitzy would have played nearly as we'll if Dawes didn't play (Dawes would be getting the best defender and is probably looking forward to Clark returning and a midfield that actually knows how to kick to a leading forward)

It's hard to say, fitz started well and then they tightened up on him abit, i'd say they're fighting it out for the 3rd forward spot next year though

[jumbo returns 6,739]

Yeah but we will pick him up and round 1 he will only have a handful of touches and people on here will call for him to be traded.

Are you seriously alluding we'll get our pick wrong?

Outrageous, Sir! Or Madam!

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

I gave up on Trengove becoming a gamebreaker last year, I see him being able to hold a spot as a contributer but he just does not seem to have the attributes he first had when he came to the club.

They had a fair go today, but lacked the patience and poise when needed. When we needed goals, we just seemed to miss them.

Some good signs there but I really thought we could get the win tonight.

trengove and watts missed three goals between them by a whisker, the amount we lost by

[DeeSpencer 25,477]

trengove and watts missed three goals between them by a whisker, the amount we lost by

and the Watts dropped chest mark!!! Shudders.

Was at a crutial time and Byrnes hit him on the chest 35m out!

And the lose defending by Dunn to let Lisle get the first goal!

Plenty of simple small errors.

[NowWeKnow 130]

Midfield midfield midfield. My kingdom for a midfield.

Loved viney almost moved the game from excruciating to mildly frustrating.

Didn't Brisbane do well out of the 2008 draft - Rich, Redden and Rockliff - that could have been our midfield!

I know its easy looking through the retrospectascope but in this case it is probably of some interest given we were dead keen on taking Redden but missed out by waiting for him to fall to pick 35 and it wouldn't have been a huge stretch to have picked up Rockcliff with our late pick (#51) given he fell along way from expectations to be picked-up in the PSD. As for Rich, at the time it wouldn't have been totally out of the question to have picked him up given he was one of 3 being touted as #1 ( but I'd still take Jack both then and now - please don't turn this into "we shouldn't have picked Jack Watts" thread).

As for our picks #1 Watts, #17 Blease, #19 Strauss, #35 Bennell, #51 Jetta. I guess that seemed a pretty fair return at the time but I can't help thinking about this everytime we play the Lions.

Edit: Oh yeah, Rohan Bail at pick 64 was apparently our revenge on Brisbane for taking Redden as they were keen on him at pick 69 - take that Brisbane Lions.

Edited July 20, 2013 by NowWeKnow

[Chook 15,012]

We conceded about 70 points from turnovers. That is why we lost. In fact, it's why we lose every week.