Sylvia is a better footballer than Vince - perhaps not in 2009, but definitely in 2014.

That said, I think Vince will be a better footballer for the MFC in 2014 than Sylvia.

Unfortunately a huge talent just never lived up to expectations due to laziness. I wish him well except when they play us!

Why do you say that?

Vince has him covered in every stat in 2013.

More disposals, more goals, more marks, higher disposal efficiency - all despite spending less time on the ground than SYlvia

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_player_compare?tid1=2&pid1=1638&tid2=12&pid2=1383&type=A&fid1=S&fid2=S

And they are the same age.

Give me Vince over Sylvia any day of the week

I just want someone who will have a crack week in, week out. NOT when he feels like it, or when we are already 100 points down.

That is VINCE.

Why would we get Adams if he didnt even wanna talk to us.

Screw him.

He may not have wanted to talk to us before, now that we have the 3V's who knows he may see there is going to be far better opportunity with Melbourne than Collingwood financially, and possibly opportunity in getting game time as well, as he may find it harder to break into the Collingwood lineup than ours. Though I am not sure he is the player Roos and co want though. They seem to have a player or swap in mind with our number 9 pick as they seemed to think the player they actually want in the draft would probably still be available for our no 9 pick, which means they have a specific target instead of trying to take what many think is just the best. We still have the rookie draft, free agency and PSD draft to come so there will probably need to be some more list changes coming up to make room.

I reckon Sylvia will dominate at Freo next year.

That's why they matched the MFC contract that was on the table. Lyon's no idiot.

Censored word above = id iot.

Don't know why that word's censored to be honest.

None at all....I few on here were getting a tad impatient last week.

I'm so looking forward to 2014.

Now to bed down Chip, and I'll be over the moon.

I get you now.

They'll probably re-emerge before too long, especially if they listen to that idiot Barrett.

Heard someone say the other day that Mahoney is seen as one of the rising stars of football admin world.

Censored word above = id iot.

Don't know why that word's censored to be honest.

funny that, same thing just happened to me when describing Barrett

Edited October 18, 201311 yr by Roosy's Bruisers

I reckon Sylvia will dominate at Freo next year.

That's why they matched the MFC contract that was on the table. Lyon's no [censored].

Censored word above = id iot.

Don't know why that word's censored to be honest.

Can we please make the words "star" and "elite" censored too?

They are more offensive than any other word as they destroy newly drafted/traded players at our club.

Sylvia is a better footballer than Vince - perhaps not in 2009, but definitely in 2014.

That said, I think Vince will be a better footballer for the MFC in 2014 than Sylvia.

Unfortunately a huge talent just never lived up to expectations due to laziness. I wish him well except when they play us!

I think Vince is a much better footballer than Silvia and I've never believed he (Silvia) to be a huge talent. It was the things he lacked that held him back not laziness. Silvia will play a role at Freo but will not be a star.

Anyone else think that we should try and pick up a key defender with one of our later picks. Unless we are thinking of playing Hogan or Watts back we only have Dunn & Pedersen as back up tall defenders.

Anyone any thoughts?

Anyone else think that we should try and pick up a key defender with one of our later picks. Unless we are thinking of playing Hogan or Watts back we only have Dunn & Pedersen as back up tall defenders.

Anyone any thoughts?

Yes I agree we need to get another running back.

hopefully the Roos team can get some of ours going better.

re the Key defender I hope we draft a kid to understudy the key back role.

we need to trade back into the 2nd & 3rd rounds to grab a good kid. young grimes could be handy too.

I think Vince is a much better footballer than Silvia and I've never believed he (Silvia) to be a huge talent. It was the things he lacked that held him back not laziness. Silvia will play a role at Freo but will not be a star.

Agree to disagree.

That said, whilst I'd like to be proven correct as a keyboard warrior, I hope you're right in that he won't star at Freo.

I reckon he will though. Expect quite a few goals from him from the 50 arc.

I think Vince is a much better footballer than Silvia and I've never believed he (Silvia) to be a huge talent. It was the things he lacked that held him back not laziness. Silvia will play a role at Freo but will not be a star.

Unless Sylvia improves his attitude and consistency I doubt that he will be an automatic member of Freo's best 22 each week.

funny that, same thing just happened to me when describing Barrett

Can we add Barrett to the list of censored words!

Sylvia is a better footballer than Vince - perhaps not in 2009, but definitely in 2014.

That said, I think Vince will be a better footballer for the MFC in 2014 than Sylvia.

Given nothing much has been able to get Silvia to produce his best for us consistently after 10 years and probably 10 coaches, its a big call to suggest that moving west will, but i think in time you may be right in that he will play better for freo, not sure he will play better or more consistently than Vince though. I suspect that Silvia will initially get even more complacent at the start with Freo, until he finds he is not getting games in the 1st, then we may start to see him apply himself.

I'd love for us to package a player and pick 40 for a pick in the 20's to try snare a solid Mid who slides

any chance we are still in the hunt for daniel cross?

Sylvia is a better footballer than Vince - perhaps not in 2009, but definitely in 2014.

That said, I think Vince will be a better footballer for the MFC in 2014 than Sylvia.

I agree that Sylvia is a better footballer but he is not a natural midfielder. Vince is and will fill our needs more than a forward that can pinch hit in the middle

Why do you say that?

Vince has him covered in every stat in 2013.

More disposals, more goals, more marks, higher disposal efficiency - all despite spending less time on the ground than SYlvia

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_player_compare?tid1=2&pid1=1638&tid2=12&pid2=1383&type=A&fid1=S&fid2=S

And they are the same age.

Give me Vince over Sylvia any day of the week

Those stats are so close that you cannot use them to compliment your argument.

any chance we are still in the hunt for daniel cross?

Hope so.

If we land him, we then have a midfield. A fair dinkum midfield.

Something last season, I had thought we were 100 years from.

Hope so.

If we land him, we then have a midfield. A fair dinkum midfield.

Something last season, I had thought we were 100 years from.

It's amazing what a proper administration team can do. Set actual realistic objectives and identify the major hole within our team that needs improvement.

Vince is a far better midfielder than Sylvia, while Sylvia is more damaging ahead of the ball.

Vince >> Sylvia

Sylvia is a hopeless mid. He can't handball, is hopeless in close, spends his life tackling at stoppages, because he can't get the first tough - reads the play poorly, and rushes his dispoal because he always thinks he has someone up his clacker. Sylvia is a very good finisher and is suited to a flank with the occasional run on the ball.

Vince kills him and hurts the opposition far more with his disposals.

It seems all the trading we needed to do, we have done and in a flurry of activity within the space of 48 hours. Anything extra we get out of the remainder of the trade period will just be a bonus.

I dont think we need Cross now that Bernie Vince has come on board.

I dont think we need Cross now that Bernie Vince has come on board.

I think we do Don

We need depth in midfield maturity & some will play HFF maybe HB etc.

atmo we have to be sure our recruits can get on the park & so Cross should be needed. I imagine our ND P9 selection will need some time to adjust & develop.

& maybe some contracted players may yet get traded out.