Hell No To Knights!!

[mjt 640]

At least swooper could coach, them the days.

[Jarka 767]

Brett Ratten would be a good choice, did pretty well at Carlton with an ordinary list albeit with a handful of stars. They treated him really poorly.

[Grimes Times 1,278]

Experienced coaches I'd prefer to Matthew Knights

1. Paul Roos (lead candidate)

2. John Worsfold (if West Coast continue their current form he may become available)

3. Rodney Eade (Runs on the board with Swans & Dogs and probably more stable then Williams)

4. Mark Williams (See Eade's cooments. Bonus, coached Power to premiership)

5. Brett Ratten (Got Carlton to three consecutive finals series after 7 years out. Was flying last year until injuries)

6. John Northey (Dream of mine and ticks all boxes. Age is the obvious barrier)

7. Dean Laidley (Did a decent job with North. They were always a tough team to play under Laidley)

8. Garry Ayres (Decent coaching career in AFL and has had sustained success at Port Melbourne).

Edit: Forgot Laidley.

Dont rule out Clarkson as silly as it sounds.

If Haw bomb out of the finals, buddy leaves he might think Ive taken this group as far as i can time for somebody else to have a go. I'll take the 5 year offer from melb now instead of coach the last year of my current contract and run the risk of not getting another one.

Or he might win the flag with Haw and then think the same thing.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Dont rule out Clarkson as silly as it sounds.

If Haw bomb out of the finals, buddy leaves he might think Ive taken this group as far as i can time for somebody else to have a go. I'll take the 5 year offer from melb now instead of coach the last year of my current contract and run the risk of not getting another one.

Or he might win the flag with Haw and then think the same thing.

it might not be great for us though when his family has him committed to an insane asylum after leaving arguably the power club of the competition to go to the biggest shambles since Fitzroy

[Weedster 174]

Experienced coaches I'd prefer to Matthew Knights

1. Paul Roos (lead candidate)

2. John Worsfold (if West Coast continue their current form he may become available)

3. Rodney Eade (Runs on the board with Swans & Dogs and probably more stable then Williams)

4. Mark Williams (See Eade's cooments. Bonus, coached Power to premiership)

5. Brett Ratten (Got Carlton to three consecutive finals series after 7 years out. Was flying last year until injuries)

6. John Northey (Dream of mine and ticks all boxes. Age is the obvious barrier)

7. Dean Laidley (Did a decent job with North. They were always a tough team to play under Laidley)

8. Garry Ayres (Decent coaching career in AFL and has had sustained success at Port Melbourne).

Edit: Forgot Laidley.

Yep, must be an experienced coach, at whatever cost. Any of your top 4 for me, none of your next, though any (except Swoop, even though he was great for us IN 1987 - 26 years ago!!) would be great choices as assistants.

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,078]

Not only experienced. We need a coach that either played in a premiership side - or preferably - has coached a side (senior coached a side) to a premiership. One who has built lists like eade or Williams would also be ideal.

Roos has never constructed a solid list - he inherited Eades.

A mate thinks neeld was talked up by Malt so he would leave the pies to undermine Buckley.

[ThreeOneSix 953]

I agree HELL NO to Knights, only because I don't think he is a good fit for us.... The bloke can obviously coach.

A good fit for us is currently being interviewed on the Couch, it's a crying shame that Ken Hinkley isn't coach of MFC.

To listen to Hinkley tonight, just frustrates me more.

Could tell that Paul Roos was nearly gobsmacked on Hinkley, Roos was asking all the right questions, it's the only time this year Roo's hasn't talked about himself.

[Dee1987 277]

It's a bit alarming when the entire Essendon playing group didn't respect Knights back in 2010!

[[email protected] 101]

Former Bomber CEO Peter Jackson backs Matthew Knights' five-year term

• MIKE SHEAHAN
• HERALD SUN
• OCTOBER 02, 2009 12:00AM

Hopefully all the Peter Jackson supporters like this (and there seems to be a majority of them)... Is he the Messiah ?? He will NEED to be...

[DeeZee 6,853]

It's a bit alarming when the entire Essendon playing group didn't respect Knights back in 2010!

Who said the playing group didnt respect him?

[drbosommd 0]

My Opinion -

Experienced coaches I'd prefer to Matthew Knights

1. Paul Roos

2 Mark Williams

3.John Worsfold

4. Neal Daniher .

5. Dean Laidley
6. Rodney Eade
7. Brett Ratten
8. Garry Ayres

In-experienced coaches I'd prefer to Matthew Knights

1. Brad Green

2 . Robbie Flower

3. Katut.

4. myself .

5. that guy that wore the Money suit to the first GWS game ...

6 .anyone ... really anyone but knights .

[Tatu 416]

Mark Stevens ‏@Stevo7AFLnow

Don't rule out Matty Knights in Melb discussions .. Peter Jackson obviously rates him, being talked up at Geel

would make a great mids coach....

[Tatu 416]

Mark Stevens ‏@Stevo7AFLnow

Don't rule out Matty Knights in Melb discussions .. Peter Jackson obviously rates him, being talked up at Geel

would make a great mids coach....

Would much rather Ayres over Knights

why not both?

[dee-eee 231]

Tut tut everybody.............. isn't it mandatory to consult Garry Lyon on this subject ?

[RickyJ45 392]

Lethal for sure -- is a better option

PJ already got burnt on Knightmare - so unless he is interested in revisiting bad memories and the beginning of the end at windy pill....NO!

[Courtney_Fish 183]

I'm surprised that nobody mentioned Sheedy. I know there may be a problem with how he wasn't treated well by us in the past but he knows how to relate to players and brings a lot more than just coaching such as how to use the media. He's sharp as a tack. A few of us were screaming for him in the past and in retrospect, they may have been right.

How does he get on with PJ?

Coach aside, I'm at least as eager get our recruitment right.

Edited June 5, 2013 by Courtney_Fish

[Swampfox 190]

I cannot think of a better record as player and coach than Leigh Mathews

IMO he is the best option alive

Does it guarantee success ?

Nope

Bit harsh on Matty Knights

after all he did come from Merbein

So did Hassa Mann

Edited June 5, 2013 by Swampfox