6. James Frawley

For his post match interview when Matt Burghan asks how he thinks we will go against Freo. "Yeah, it will be a good challenge, fly up there in a plane". Love his interviews.

1. Davey (was everywhere today and realy think that his most damaging position is that rebounding spot (defensive wing to back flank) we need someone to create play from there)

2. Garland (Really finding composure and confidence)

3. Terlich (Really playing a role in the team - similar to Matty Whelan?)

4. M Jones (Just is playing like a miny N Jones - love his composure in congestion and one of the few you won't see handballing to a player in a worse position)

5. Dawes (Massive presence, made me have no dought that he is a leader and loved when he applauded one of the center clerances and then the whole team applauded it)

6. Dunn (Probably the most underated player on here at the moment - is defensive but then also has the ability/confidence to drift off his man and do damage)

Just to tough to pick!

Would have had Dawes up near the top if it wasn't for his 3rd quarter

Wow. Didn't see that coming.

He's not underrated. He's a hack.

6.Terlich

5.Davey

4. N.Jones

3. Frawley

2. Garland

1. Magner

Biggest positive was having to give a lot of thought to who got in Dawes Dunn Howe & Jamar all had good games and Sellar played his role well down back

6 Terlich

5 Davey

4 jones N

3 Dawes

2 Garland

1 Magner

6.Terlich

5.Davey

4. N.Jones

3. Frawley

2. Garland

1. Magner

Biggest positive was having to give a lot of thought to who got in Dawes Dunn Howe & Jamar all had good games and Sellar played his role well down back

Garland - no! What did he do, stop Jake King! Howe! Double no! He couldn't buy a kick forward and wasn't great as loose man down back.

6 - Dunn. Kept his man to two disposals for the game and kicked two goals while playing as full back.

5 - Terlich. Team high tackles, plenty of the ball and he's demanding it off half back and taking responsibility for setting up the play.

4 - Davey. A very welcome return to form from him. Could have had more goals had he been selfish in his play, and set up plenty of attacking moves with his precise kicking.

3 - Jamar. I know people will say he didn't do enough around the ground, but he had more hitouts than the entire opposition and that made a huge difference to our work in the middle.

2 - Magner. We've missed his hardness at stoppages. He makes a huge difference to our ability to get first chance at the ball.

1 - N Jones. As always, works hard all day through the middle. Had a hard time today, but he stuck to it and mostly broke even with Cotchin.

Despite the poor finish, we had some players out there this week ... 6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1

6. Terlich

5. Davey ( Wonderful to be able to give him votes again)

4. Frawley

3. N. Jones

2. Garland

1. Magner

6 Terlich

5 Davey

4 Magner

3 MJones

2 Dawes

1 Dunn

sellar goes alright down back. should leave him there and let him settle. provide some competition for mcdonald. cant hold a mark but perhaps thats just confidence and may improve with a string of games in the back line. he is NOT a forward Neeldy

And Watts is NOT a backman Neeldy

Garland - no! What did he do, stop Jake King! Howe! Double no! He couldn't buy a kick forward and wasn't great as loose man down back.

i thought this was an opinion site howe working tirelessly to draw his opponent away from the hole in front of dawes when he was leading. he prevented tiges going two up on dawes. when down back stood in the hole in front of vickery & riewoldt. was prepared to go 2nd/3rd man up when needed. garland beat his man made the decision several times to attack the loose ball and provide some rebound.

6:Terlich

5:Davey

4:Dawes

3:Magner

2:Jones M.

1:Jones N.

In what is a really disappointing year it's good to see two good players in Terlich and Jones M emerge from the state based comps.

6 - Davey ( creative and sublime disposal )

5 - Frawley ( loves the Riewoldt contest , and held his own despite the regularity of entry)

4 - Dunn ( good at both ends , and his kicking to advantage was noted )

3 - Howe ( excellent with the ball, but I wish he'd get it more)

2 - Terlich ( sees ball and gets it )

1 - Magner ( an encouraging return )

Dunn's "kicking to advantage"? Really? Apart from his two goals (which were both excellent kicks), I thought his kicking was quite poor.

6. Davey (it's nice to see good foot skills again)

5. Garland

4. Terlich

3. Jamar

2. M Jones

1. N Jones

Toss up between Magner and the Jones boys for the last two spots.

Dunn's "kicking to advantage"? Really? Apart from his two goals (which were both excellent kicks), I thought his kicking was quite poor.

Agreed. Basically butchered every kick-in he took.

6 - Terlich

5 - Davey

4 - N Jones

3 - Magner

2 - Garland

1 - M Jones

At last a possible challenger to Nathan Jones?

PROGRESS VOTING ROUND 8

70. Nathan Jones

55. Colin Garland

47. Matt Jones

39. Jack Viney

36. Jeremy Howe

34. Dean Terlich

31. Colin Sylvia

26. Jack Grimes

24. Aaron Davey

23. Shannon Byrnes Michael Evans

19. James Frawley

16. Max Gawn

12. James Magner

11. Luke Tapscott

8. Mitch Clark

6. Lynden Dunn Tom McDonald

4. Jordie McKenzie Jack Trengove Jack Watts

2. Rohan Bail Mark Jamar

1. Sam Blease Chris Dawes

It is very refreshing to see that Nate Jones is no longer getting the six points very week. This isn't a reflection on him as he continues to produce week-in week-out, but rather on the fact that there are now others in the side who are giving him a hand and working hard as well. This as much as anything is a sign that things are improving for us.