My 3 word player analysis V Gold Coast Suns

[joeboy 3,162]

N.Jones - pressure weighing down

Dawes - unfit and unhelpful

Viney - tried but flawed

Frawley - had little presence

Byrnes - was a liability

Sylvia - gave a damn

McKenzie - bereft of skills

Dunn - tried but failed

Strauss - loose and dumb

Garland - was rarely sighted

Nicholson - dumb and dumber

Sellar - bereft of skills

Evans - was on field

Kent - had no impact

Tapscott - fumbled and failed

Davey - limited and flawed

Gawn - seemed to care

Howe - wasted natural talent

Spencer - was easily beaten

Bail - probably on field

M.Jones - had limited effect

Terlich - unwarranted overconfident attitude

[Gorgoroth 12,786]

Sylvia: gave a damn......... Except when he was expected to chase he chose when too and when not too.

Dawes: ball kicked over his head or on top.

[Little Richard 6,219]

N.Jones - pressure weighing down

Dawes - unfit and unhelpful

Viney - tried but flawed

Frawley - had little presence

Byrnes - was a liability

Sylvia - gave a damn

McKenzie - bereft of skills

Dunn - tried but failed

Strauss - loose and dumb

Garland - was rarely sighted

Nicholson - dumb and dumber

Sellar - bereft of skills

Evans - was on field

Kent - had no impact

Tapscott - fumbled and failed

Davey - limited and flawed

Gawn - seemed to care

Howe - wasted natural talent

Spencer - was easily beaten

Bail - probably on field

M.Jones - had limited effect

Terlich - unwarranted overconfident attitude

I would much rather a few of the other guys had the confidence to take the game on like Terlich.

[buck_nekkid 5,831]

Sylvia? Really? Ran around the outside of packs, 10 direct turnovers, kicking efficiency about 50%. Flashy goal in the last, 3 quarters too late.

Viney, Dawes, Howe, Garland , Gawn and Sellar get pass marks. The rest, not.

[Dr. Mubutu 784]

MFC - Viney for God

[45HG 1,539]

Sylvia - ha

[Deano74 156]

N.Jones - pressure weighing down

Dawes - unfit and unhelpful

Viney - tried but flawed

Frawley - had little presence

Byrnes - was a liability

Sylvia - gave a damn

McKenzie - bereft of skills

Dunn - tried but failed

Strauss - loose and dumb

Garland - was rarely sighted

Nicholson - dumb and dumber

Sellar - bereft of skills

Evans - was on field

Kent - had no impact

Tapscott - fumbled and failed

Davey - limited and flawed

Gawn - seemed to care

Howe - wasted natural talent

Spencer - was easily beaten

Bail - probably on field

M.Jones - had limited effect

Terlich - unwarranted overconfident attitude

The Herald sun summed it up for me with the following - Jack Viney played his best game for the club, Matt Jones kept trying and Gawn again showed something, but that was about it.

[spirit of norm smith 15,559]

AFL standard
Howe - Our best. If he could kick straight he would bag 5-6.

Gawn - liked his game. Big man. Has the edge.

N.Jones - tagged again. No one cuts out his tagger to help.

Sylvia - showed why he is in our top 5 players. Frustration let him down.
Viney - tried but flawed

M.Jones - classy disposal. Our best rookie this year.
Strauss - showed some run and carry. Nice goal. A keeper.

Terlich - trier

Tapscott - showed some grunt. but also fumbled too much

Frawley - was he playing !!
McKenzie - hmmm - bereft of skills
Dunn – trier.
Garland - holding back a tidal wave. trier.
Sellar - trier
Evans - trier
Kent - overwhelmed. trier. leave in to get some games into.
Dawes - no one at magpieland cried when he left. One effort player.

To be omitted:
Spencer – 2^nd rate. VFL Dev squad.
Bail – ohhh. Back to vfl. Fell over. Missed tackles etc etc
Nicholson - dumb and dumber and dumb and dumber 2
Byrnes - VFL standard (drop)
Davey - limited and flawed. Missed 2 easy goals

[spirit of norm smith 15,559]

Sylvia? Really? Ran around the outside of packs, 10 direct turnovers, kicking efficiency about 50%. Flashy goal in the last, 3 quarters too late.

Viney, Dawes, Howe, Garland , Gawn and Sellar get pass marks. The rest, not.

Dawes ?? pushed off the footy. One effort. Poor elbow swing. Tried to mark on chest not hands. he was poor.

[Return to Glory 8,398]

Neeld - needs to resign

[What 18,810]

Viney - tried but flawed

Oh come on.......... the kid is a gun and thats the best you could do?

[buck_nekkid 5,831]

Dawes ?? pushed off the footy. One effort. Poor elbow swing. Tried to mark on chest not hands. he was poor.

Thought for limited opportunities Dawes kicked some nice passes that had the forwards leading to the the ball. He took a couple of marks, contested a bit, and fluffed a few. For first game back, I'd give him a 'pass'. Lots of room for him to improve. Nice if players could kick to his advantage.

[Dr. Mubutu 784]

Call me crazy, but I've found myself agreeing with Bluey on one point tonight.

Howe plays like an absolute millionaire; best player in the U-7's.

If he could bring some variety to his game, it'd be a breath of fresh air.

His one 'screamer' today: made it look harder than it was.