The only way that this trade makes ANY sense to me is if Collingwood give their first round pick as well in the deal. Or some other combination of pick swapping. Surely MFC is not stupid enough to consider this otherwise. Surely.

Dawes and welli will be at MFC this week. Pick 13 and stef Martin.

Mark my words

Dawes and welli will be at MFC this week. Pick 13 and stef Martin.

Mark my words

Marked. I think it's overs but I could live with that.

Dawes and welli will be at MFC this week. Pick 13 and stef Martin.

Mark my words

You're on fire tonight DF.

Dawes and welli will be at MFC this week. Pick 13 and stef Martin.

Mark my words

Praying you're right. This will make my year.

Marked. I think it's overs but I could live with that.

Likewise, 13/14 for Wellingham and Martin for Dawes. 13/14 for Wellingham is overs but Stef for Dawes is about right. Would make big Q their FF and Stef their back up ruck, which if I was I Pies fan I'd prefer. Lynch doesn't have the mobility to be their back up ruck and would be much more useful to them on the lead.

I'll take that deal.

Don't fall for it. Obviously wishful thinking from Collingwood!

No,No! a thousand times NO! We MUST get two high quality young MID FIELDERS in this draft. Nothing less will do. Wellingham has proven ability and could be useful, BUT, if Melbourne doesn't interest him then he can move back to the West and join the Weagles.

Dawes and welli will be at MFC this week. Pick 13 and stef Martin.

Mark my words

So that's you on record stating pick 4 for Caddy and pick 13 and Martin for Dawes and Wellingham?

13 and Martin for Dawes and Wellingham I could get used to...

PS I'd hate to have you part of my crew if we were in the mob. You'd be known as "Timmy the Squeeler" lol

Geoff Walsh has confirmed that the MFC has put pick 4 on the table for Dawes and wellingham!

I don't like using our pick 4 for a "quick fix" improvement to our team.

We could be giving away a genuine star to gain a B and a C grade.

Argggggh.

Geoff Walsh has confirmed that the MFC has put pick 4 on the table for Dawes and wellingham!

When and where did he confirm that?

I still don't get why we would force Wellingham to come to Melbourne when he doesn't want to?

What's the point?

We are a joke if we trade pick 4 for these two.

It reeks of short term gain to bolster Neeld's win-loss ratio. What a disgrace.

When and where did he confirm that?

I still don't get why we would force Wellingham to come to Melbourne when he doesn't want to?

What's the point?

We are a joke if we trade pick 4 for these two.

It reeks of short term gain to bolster Neeld's win-loss ratio. What a disgrace.

It was on one of the Facebook trade pages claiming that Geoff Walsh has confirmed thismorning the only Place I can think he may have actually confirmed this is SEN or another radio station perhaps?

He said on SEN this morning.

He said on SEN this morning.

Surely not true, please....

Let's hope it's a ruse to get the Eagles to pay a bit more for Wellingham. I can't believe that we'd give pick 4 for those two in a draft as good as this (even given our recent record)

Hope pick 4 is not true. I'd prefer a cheap version of Dawes to sit along side Clark (white?) and to keep getting elite mids from draft. Maybe pick 13 for wellingham, maybe.

Its official. Thats what we have put up for those two players. I think its crazy overs, why not pick 13 and a player?

Geoff Walsh from Collingwood FC has confirmed that Melbourne have put pick 4 up to secure Dawes and Wellingham

Link to come

Geoff Walsh has confirmed that the MFC has put pick 4 on the table for Dawes and wellingham!

No Way. Not even if we don't have to use pick 3 on Viney. if we do this I'll be mad as hell. It does smell of desperation.

Another thread....

This is absolute lunacy, and IF confirmed as in above info from Jonesbag and in link to another thread "Is your support of MFC unconditional"?

Not if this trade ensues!

What is going on?

Edited October 7, 201213 yr by picket fence

Sorry about creating another thread. It was more of me being lazy and ceebs looking for the pre existing thread

Walsh said Melbourne were interested in Wellingham but did not mention pick 4.

Can we please ban all references to Facebook pages?

Wtf is Walsh doing blabbing rubbish ?

Wtf is Walsh doing blabbing rubbish ?

He simply said Melbourne were interested, did not mention pick 4 whatsoever.

He simply said Melbourne were interested, did not mention pick 4 whatsoever.

That makes more sense cheers

So many seem jumpy and adding 3 and 5 and getting 27