Scully finishes 4th in Sheedy Medal

[tarzan16 40]

why are we talking about him???

[sue 9,126]

Living in NSW I get to see the GWS game every damn week and I have no doubt if Scully was no. 4 at GWS, it is reasonable to expect Demon players will fill the first 3 place getters in the Brownlow.

(I must admit my main interest in watching those boring matches is to see Scully get smashed one way or another. Turns out it was always one way so I don't have to feel guilty about wishing physical harm on him.)

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,602]

hahah - sucked in - they have to lie to justify...

[Philthy 284]

Why are we even talking about the piece of sh*t? He isn't a Melbourne player!

[Gippsland Dee 367]

as far as i can tell atm, melbourne got the better end of the deal, provided we draft well with the compo picks. He has had no better than a mediocre season and is definitely not worth the $2 million a season or whatever he is getting! He also has knee tendon/ligament issues so they will have to manage that well, probably will never play a full season!

We don't want people like him around the club anyway despite his talent, we need people who are trustworthy and don't lie!

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

why are we talking about him???

Get over it.

[Keepin up with the Joneses 48]

hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahahahahahahaha

[Striker475 696]

hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahahahahahahaha

QF my reaction

[Hannibal 5,814]

What a farce. It's come to light tonight that there was no round by round voting in the GWS B&F. The voting was an assessment done retrospectively at the end of the year. What a joke.

And Scully must should be embarrassed. Although I acknowledge he's an innocent beneficiary in club politics.

[Jaded No More 68,972]

I think I deserve 5th place in the GWS B&F for resisting the urge to run Tom Scully over in a shopping centre last weekend.

I'm a team player!

[biggestred 5,125]

I think I deserve 5th place in the GWS B&F for resisting the urge to run Tom Scully over in a shopping centre last weekend.

I'm a team player!

if you were a team player youd have hit him and reversed back over him just to check.

giles came 5th..... talk about robbed

[demoniac 1,336]

I think I deserve 5th place in the GWS B&F for resisting the urge to run Tom Scully over in a shopping centre last weekend.

I'm a team player!

Thats not 'Buy In'!

[Jaded No More 68,972]

if you were a team player youd have hit him and reversed back over him just to check.

giles came 5th..... talk about robbed

True that, I mean he was the biggest low life in IKEA, and that says something!

I did push in front of him at the cash register at another store though. Serves the [censored] right *small victories*

[Sir Why You Little 37,119]

Tom must have paid for the venue. Only way he could be credited wth 4th.

An AFL FARCE.

[Redleg 41,398]

So the first Sheedy medal is devalued by controversy and is nothing short of a shambles. A political vote to save face, by a club that overpaid an ordinary footballer and person. Hope his contract leads to salary cap problems in the future.

PS. Apparently his contract is now affecting the clubs ability to deal with Giles. Oh the joy.

Edited September 13, 2012 by Redleg

[dees189227 12,395]

That is so stupid how they pick there best and fairest. Dont even call it the best and fairest. You cant sit down at the end of the season and just rate each player. It now makes sense how Scully came 4th.

[angrydee 842]

So the first Sheedy medal is devalued by controversy and is nothing short of a shambles. A political vote to save face, by a club that overpaid an ordinary footballer and person. Hope his contract leads to salary cap problems in the future.

PS. Apparently his contract is now affecting the clubs ability to deal with Giles. Oh the joy.

And it appears (according to the hun, that is) that Giles has walked out of GWS

[keep13alive 78]

So the first Sheedy medal is devalued by controversy and is nothing short of a shambles. A political vote to save face, by a club that overpaid an ordinary footballer and less then moral person. Hope his contract leads to salary cap problems in the future.

PS. Apparently his contract is now affecting the clubs ability to deal with Giles. Oh the joy.

Fixed

[jnrmac 20,154]

So the first Sheedy medal is devalued by controversy and is nothing short of a shambles. A political vote to save face, by a club that overpaid an ordinary footballer and person. Hope his contract leads to salary cap problems in the future.

PS. Apparently his contract is now affecting the clubs ability to deal with Giles. Oh the joy.

Karma. Scully should be further embarrassed.

[Guest fitness]

The top 10 B&F finishers are listed on their website here. It didn't get much of a mention but apparently Phil Scully ran 11th.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I wish someone in the media had the balls to ask Luke Power (with his close association with the AFLPA) how he felt about Phil Scully taking the wages of his teammates.

[daisycutter 29,701]

The top 10 B&F finishers are listed on their website here. It didn't get much of a mention but apparently Phil Scully ran 11th.

I think you'll find it was Philfy who finished 4th, not HWFUA ---- LOL

[Jonesbag 487]

Williams 'there is no way that Jonathan Giles could have finished below Tom Scully in this year Best & Fairest at the club'.

Funny how the former assistant is sinking the boots in as well :D :D

Also looks like Giles is packing his bags

Where is that smug pr&ck gubby allen now?

[Baldylordy 1]

Who is this guy you are all talking about, is he the one that won tattsloitto thanks to the AFL and moved to Blacktown NSW

[Sir Why You Little 37,119]

Williams 'there is no way that Jonathan Giles could have finished below Tom Scully in this year Best & Fairest at the club'.

Funny how the former assistant is sinking the boots in as well :D :D

Also looks like Giles is packing his bags

Where is that smug pr&ck gubby allen now?

I don't think Choco has a high regard for GW$...& he should know!!!!