When and who was the last elite Star the MFC had. A bloke that dominated the game and on his day no body could stop him.

Juice Newton...

simon godfrey

Edited September 3, 201212 yr by dazzledavey36

So if we get one star, say somebody like G Ablett or Chris Judd, we will win every game and the premiership, just like Carlton or Gold Coast have, you need twenty two players who can play.....if the whole team improves you will find one or two of our highly derided players will raise their game to another level....Nathan Jones managed that this season....imagine how good he could become if he has another 21 hard seasoned bodies around him

The Wizard!

Robbie. No doubt. Week in week out.

Neita

We've had highlight reel players recently but no genuine stars.

Neitz when on the top of his game could be unstoppable, but was an exception rather than the rule.

And I am not sure if the OP was implying it would automatically lead to premierships, but perhaps bemoaning our inability or just downright bad luck in findinging a star/superstar.

So if we get one star, say somebody like G Ablett or Chris Judd, we will win every game and the premiership, just like Carlton or Gold Coast have, you need twenty two players who can play.....if the whole team improves you will find one or two of our highly derided players will raise their game to another level....Nathan Jones managed that this season....imagine how good he could become if he has another 21 hard seasoned bodies around him

or you could just answer the question....?

When and who was the last elite Star the MFC had. A bloke that dominated the game and on his day no body could stop him.

David Schwartz, on his day nobody could stop him.

Jakovitch. Flower.

We have one on our list, if he could just get his sh!t together. L Jurrah.

Remember the thread that was started a couple of years back asking if LJ was a star or not? Someone might care to dust off the cobwebs so we can go back and have a look waht was written. (apologies for being slightly off topic).

Isaac Weetra.

Flower.

as a consistent star ... go back to 1975-85. Robert Flower.

Others have threatened , Gerard Healy (before Swans), Lyon, Synes, Schwartz and Neitz. But none where consistently in the league top 10-20 players.

Our kids have no ICON to follow , like the Judd, Ablett, Franklin, Hird, Buckley, Koutoufides, Carey, Lockett, Voss, Kelly, Ruccuito types etc etc.

WE NEED A STAR

Jurrah could be, just have to get him out there.

Suprised no-one mentioned our last brownlow, Woey

Alistair Nicholson

Jimmy Stynes was pretty handy on a consistent basis.

He didn't miss many games through injury either.

Juice Newton...

I wanted to "Like", but I can't bring myself to.

Flower, Neita and Jacka

Cameron Hunter

Tie between Isaac Weetra, Luke Molan, Steven Armstrong and Brent Grgic

Robbie Flower.

Since then we've just had "good" players.

Nick Smith.

Who else could have 3 years without a game then play in a final?

What is the point answering the question, what they are going to come out of retirement and play next season, this self flaggelation gets tiresome, no wonder other clubs find MFC amusing, it has supporters who can never let go of the past