What is our new game plan under Neeld?

[heartbeatstrue 57]

Anyone?

(if I write anything just now about what I watched today it's likely to be defamatory)

[Bitter but optimistic 22,241]

What a fantastic question! Maybe I'm dumb but I couldn't see any plan whatsoever.

[Stinga02 2]

#1. After mark or free kick.

a. Do not play on!!!!!

b. Take 10 steps from mark.

c. MUST kick directly over mark.

d. NEVER change direction.

e. Don't direct kick, just kick as long as possible to an outnumbered contest.

#2. Kick-ins.

a. Play on to self but only after allowing the opposition to know you are about to do it.

b. Wait till you are rushed with kick. Hold onto ball until about to get bumped/tackled.

c. Direct the ball as close to boundry about 60m out.

d. Ruckman/talls are never to occupy the area close to boundry. KEEP AWAY!!!!

e. Repeat over and over because opp are too stupid to ever work this out.

Edited March 31, 2012 by Stinga02

[Bitter but optimistic 22,241]

#1. After mark or free kick.

Do not play on!!!!!Take 10 steps from mark. MUST kick directly over mark. NEVER change direction. Don't direct kick, just kick as long as possible to an outnumbered contest.

Thanks for that. Now I can see our ineptitude in a whole new light.

[Stinga02 2]

Went today hoping that NAB cup style was Neeld forcing the players to practice some certain sequences and patterns so that they are familar during the season when they are needed.

For example, the long kick down the boundry line to a contest because all other options are exhausted - switch of play, chip kick through press, run and carry through zone, etc.

Disappointed to find out (way before quarter time) that this was our one and only style.

I've read its based off pies but I thought they hug the boundry from back post to about 70 out and then direct the last kick into the 50 towards the middle. We seem to continue the hug all the way to the point post.

Also, I'm sure Ive seen the ball occassional go through the centre square when a pies player is free.

We seem to treat the square as if the ropes have been introduced to keep the spectators off.

I suppose though that today there was a fine line between players and spectators "running" around in the jumper.

Edited March 31, 2012 by Stinga02

[heartbeatstrue 57]

One pretty significant indicator I think was sometime in the second half, Trengove jogging off to the bench after a Lions goal - he was stopped in his tracks by some signal from the bench, and expressed his bewilderment by holding both hands palm out to those giving the instructions as if to say "what the f***'s going on?"

Then with an expression of annoyance he turned and ran to the centre for the bounce.

It wasn't a good look from one of our captains.

My interpretation was that Trenners was as mystified by what was going on with the Fat Controller & his henchmen on the bench as the rest of us, but who knows what was really happening out there?

[Guest Gotzy15]

#1. After mark or free kick.

a. Do not play on!!!!!

b. Take 10 steps from mark.

c. MUST kick directly over mark.

d. NEVER change direction.

e. Don't direct kick, just kick as long as possible to an outnumbered contest.

#2. Kick-ins.

a. Play on to self but only after allowing the opposition to know you are about to do it.

b. Wait till you are rushed with kick. Hold onto ball until about to get bumped/tackled.

c. Direct the ball as close to boundry about 60m out.

d. Ruckman/talls are never to occupy the area close to boundry. KEEP AWAY!!!!

e. Repeat over and over because opp are too stupid to ever work this out.

Haha love it. At least we can have a laugh about it..... for now

[Die Hard Demon 1,224]

Went today hoping that NAB cup style was Neeld forcing the players to practice some certain sequences and patterns so that they are familar during the season when they are needed.

For example, the long kick down the boundry line to a contest because all other options are exhausted - switch of play, chip kick through press, run and carry through zone, etc.

Disappointed to find out (way before quarter time) that this was our one and only style.

I've read its based off pies but I thought they hug the boundry from back post to about 70 out and then direct the last kick into the 50 towards the middle. We seem to continue the hug all the way to the point post.

Also, I'm sure Ive seen the ball occassional go through the centre square when a pies player is free.

We seem to treat the square as if the ropes have been introduced to keep the spectators off.

I suppose though that today there was a fine line between players and spectators "running" around in the jumper.

This definitely seems to be the one and only gameplan we've implemented. Neeld seemed to be completely non reactive. It was a shamble. There were no glimpses of it coming off or being a potentially good plan. Unfortunately it seems that were stuck with it. Thats what the players have been practising all pre season, and thats what theyre going to have to learn to get right. So realistically were back to square one. New coach, new gameplan, more waiting. Godddddd im frustrated.

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,294]

One pretty significant indicator I think was sometime in the second half, Trengove jogging off to the bench after a Lions goal - he was stopped in his tracks by some signal from the bench, and expressed his bewilderment by holding both hands palm out to those giving the instructions as if to say "what the f***'s going on?"

Then with an expression of annoyance he turned and ran to the centre for the bounce.

It wasn't a good look from one of our captains.

My interpretation was that Trenners was as mystified by what was going on with the Fat Controller & his henchmen on the bench as the rest of us, but who knows what was really happening out there?

I noticed a couple of times today a lot of confusion on the bench

[Swampfox 190]

the more players in your team able to effectively to execute the game plan has a major influence on the game result

It is simple really

[P-man 13,366]

#1. After mark or free kick.

a. Do not play on!!!!!

b. Take 10 steps from mark.

c. MUST kick directly over mark.

d. NEVER change direction.

e. Don't direct kick, just kick as long as possible to an outnumbered contest.

#2. Kick-ins.

a. Play on to self but only after allowing the opposition to know you are about to do it.

b. Wait till you are rushed with kick. Hold onto ball until about to get bumped/tackled.

c. Direct the ball as close to boundry about 60m out.

d. Ruckman/talls are never to occupy the area close to boundry. KEEP AWAY!!!!

e. Repeat over and over because opp are too stupid to ever work this out.

Are you an insider..cause this is eerily close.

You have to question, is it worth instilling this for an entire season if they aren't the right type of players to implement it? The impact of players like Blease who can provide a bit of run and carry are effectively nullified.

I don't recall ever witnessing such a one dimensional style. It was insipid.

[Arsene Wenger 72]

I think most in this thread are confusing what our gameplan is with what they saw yesterday and interpreted from that.

2 different things.

[Webber 10,468]

#1. After mark or free kick.

a. Do not play on!!!!!

b. Take 10 steps from mark.

c. MUST kick directly over mark.

d. NEVER change direction.

e. Don't direct kick, just kick as long as possible to an outnumbered contest.

#2. Kick-ins.

a. Play on to self but only after allowing the opposition to know you are about to do it.

b. Wait till you are rushed with kick. Hold onto ball until about to get bumped/tackled.

c. Direct the ball as close to boundry about 60m out.

d. Ruckman/talls are never to occupy the area close to boundry. KEEP AWAY!!!!

e. Repeat over and over because opp are too stupid to ever work this out.

Beautiful, and completely accurate. In summary, play the MOST predictable game ever to hit the paddock, in turn becoming the easiest team in the AFL to play against........didn't we hear something to the polar opposite uttered by Mr. Neeld when he took the job. This gameplan CANNOT make us harder to play against.