WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - JACK VINEY

[rhaz 342]

Then fight like Hell to bring Jack Back.

lol. you seriously would let him go to another club, but its okay because we'll fight to get him back!?

Edited August 28, 2012 by rhaz

[dee-luded 2,958]

lol. you seriously would let him go to another club, but its okay because we'll fight to get him back!?

If they dummy bid, then yes.

I'd be very happy with 2 of Whitfield, Toumpas, Grundy, O'Rourke, Mayes, Kennedy, etc. then use Pick 13 & our 2nd Rnder... as well as trading in some maturity.

[BIG JIM 508]

Jack viney will come to the dees in the 2nd rnd because we will take martin with pick 3.

This is something i was told at the game Saturday watch this space.

GC will not bid in the mini draft 2012.

3. Martin

4. Toumpas

13.Stringer

24.Viney

[dee-luded 2,958]

Jack viney will come to the dees in the 2nd rnd because we will take martin with pick 3.

This is something i was told at the game Saturday watch this space.

GC will not bid in the mini draft 2012.

3. Martin

4. Toumpas

13.Stringer

24.Viney

OK, I see, GWS get pick 3 to go with their Pick 1. They want Whitfield & Grundy it seems.

GCSuns Pick 2 - who'll they take? Toumpas? Not Viney?

I'm happy with the list you've nominated thru your first 4 picks for us.

[mdemonski2 403]

Jack viney will come to the dees in the 2nd rnd because we will take martin with pick 3.

This is something i was told at the game Saturday watch this space.

GC will not bid in the mini draft 2012.

3. Martin

4. Toumpas

13.Stringer

24.Viney

So in this scenario, what us to stop gc bidding for viney?Doubt gc would take grundy with 2, assuming gws use 1 for whitfield.

[BIG JIM 508]

So in this scenario, what us to stop gc bidding for viney?Doubt gc would take grundy with 2, assuming gws use 1 for whitfield.

Will be sending one ricky bobby very cheap i think.

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,078]

Not sure we are interesting in Martin - apparently has shades of Morton. Looks great among kids.

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,078]

What Ive heard we are interested in Toumpas and not string beans. Even if that stringbean is called the human highlight and draws the ball like a young Goodes.

Edited August 28, 2012 by Norm Smith's Curse

[DEELIRIOUS 156]

I would much rather that pick 3 going to Toumpas, 4 going to Hogan (we can work on his set shots over 2013)/be used on another midfielder, 12 being used to nab another midfielder/be used in a trade/be used to grab a skilful half backman, and use the 2nd rounder on Viney as has been mentioned

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

I would much rather that pick 3 going to Toumpas, 4 going to Hogan (we can work on his set shots over 2013)/be used on another midfielder, 12 being used to nab another midfielder/be used in a trade/be used to grab a skilful half backman, and use the 2nd rounder on Viney as has been mentioned

I'm all for that. What ever gets Hogan I am happy with.

[furious d 447]

I've got one for you, provide some Evidence that Viney is in the top 5 best in this Draft, "Clown" you sound very much like another postor who uses similar writing styles & putdowns to try to imply an inner strength & a valid argument.

And only 19 posts too.

Who's bidding are you doing?

You are a [censored] end of the highest order.

I'm guessing you're accusing him of being me, after accusing me of being a Viney.

Mods can you please assure this FOOL that I have NO aliases.

You have been shown time and time again that your claims that no one rates Viney top 5 are a nonsense but you play the man not the ball in reply, the classic tactic of a man with a weak argument. [censored]

[Hannibal 5,814]

You are a [censored] end of the highest order.

I'm guessing you're accusing him of being me, after accusing me of being a Viney.

Mods can you please assure this FOOL that I have NO aliases.

You have been shown time and time again that your claims that no one rates Viney top 5 are a nonsense but you play the man not the ball in reply, the classic tactic of a man with a weak argument. [censored]

And I thought he meant me ...

[King Kunta 97]

I've got one for you, provide some Evidence that Viney is in the top 5 best in this Draft, "Clown" you sound very much like another postor who uses similar writing styles & putdowns to try to imply an inner strength & a valid argument.

And only 19 posts too.

Who's bidding are you doing?

Get a life if you think that by having eight thousand posts somehow your opinion is more valid than mine.

Have a look at this guys mock draft, obviously watches a lot more under age football than you do

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/knightmares-2012-mock-draft.956129/

Has him rated only behind Daniher, O'meara and Whitfield, of which we can only take one, basically saying he is the second best available selection.

Jog on you loser

[rpfc 27,451]

Jack viney will come to the dees in the 2nd rnd because we will take martin with pick 3. This is something i was told at the game Saturday watch this space. GC will not bid in the mini draft 2012.

So in this scenario, what us to stop gc bidding for viney?Doubt gc would take grundy with 2, assuming gws use 1 for whitfield.

Will be sending one ricky bobby very cheap i think.

If those intentions of ours are true, this is a very possible scenario.

Edited August 29, 2012 by rpfc

[olisik 4,060]

Jack viney will come to the dees in the 2nd rnd because we will take martin with pick 3.

This is something i was told at the game Saturday watch this space.

GC will not bid in the mini draft 2012.

3. Martin

4. Toumpas

13.Stringer

24.Viney

We need a 1 KPP of our top 4. If Stringer is unlikely to slip to 13 then we should take Hogan instead of Martin.

Is the minidraft done after the normal draft? If so it could be something like

Option 1

3. Toumpas

4. MD 1 (Martin)

13. Stringer

26. Viney

If Stringer dosn't last

Option 2

3. Toumpas

4. MD1 (Hogan)

13. Kennedy/Garlett/Vlastuin

26. Viney

Edited August 29, 2012 by olisik

[rjay 23,907]

Interesting that Mathew Haynes has dropped right back in the mock draft to the 50's, looked like he would be a top 10 the year before. Tall & very quick. Wouldn't mind him as a late pick.

[rpfc 27,451]

We need a 1 KPP of our top 4. If Stringer is unlikely to slip to 13 then we should take Hogan instead of Martin.

Is the minidraft done after the normal draft? If so it could be something like

Option 1

3. Toumpas

4. MD 1 (Martin)

13. Stringer

26. Viney

If Stringer dosn't last

Option 2

3. Toumpas

4. MD1 (Hogan)

13. Kennedy/Garlett/Vlastuin

26. Viney

MD before ND.

[dazzledavey36 48,742]

What Ive heard we are interested in Toumpas and not string beans. Even if that stringbean is called the human highlight and draws the ball like a young Goodes.

i also heard we rate toumpas very highly also. even oliver wines who is built like a brickshitouse and ready to go straight away would be a good get. watching adelaide outmuscle us on the weekend shows wy we need bigger bodies.

[olisik 4,060]

MD before ND.

there goes that theory

[dee-luded 2,958]

Ah, the orchestra has started playing the company tune.

All finding pitch together in harmony.

Sing along now.

[dee-luded 2,958]

I'm really concerned with taking a 17Yr old skinny kid from across the country.

I'd much prefer the powerfully built kid Who has shown to like to play aggressively.

If it means we take Viney with Rnd 2, I'm all for it. (Pick 3, or 4 for Hogan)...

[furious d 447]

Ah, the orchestra has started playing the company tune.

All finding pitch together in harmony.

Sing along now.

Most apt username ever.

[ChaserJ 3,964]

From the Casey local paper:

Lovett was unsure of the make-up of the Scorpions' line-up. But he did confirm highly rated youngster Jack Viney will return after serving a one-week suspension.

"The finals exposure will give him some experience for next year."

[Pennant St Dee 11,257]

I don't care how good some of you think Martin looks, massive risks with him and I am not talking Jack Darling type risks. If we a really going for MD take Hogan don't take Martin and I believe Neeld will go the same option.

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,078]

I dont think we will take any risks this time around. We have to have learnt from our mistakes and perhaps bad luck,