WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - JACK VINEY

[Grimseyisgod 378]

ok so maybe i overstated categoric. But Melbourne will not use pick 3 or 4 for him

[King Kunta 97]

And one rated him at 3, but neither were Melbourne football club recruiters so that offers no insight into whether we will take him at 3 or not.

[Daz's Dee's 113]

Personally, if we have to pick up Viney for a 1st round draft pick say pick 4 ish.. its not worth getting him at all.

I think he has potential to be a superstar but there are so many players that are just like him, especially because

this years draft is superdraft and i think that there could be 3 or 4 "vineys" and maybe even better than him.

For a second round pick it would be unbelievable to get Viney and 2 other picks at 3 and 4

So you think he is a potential "superstar" but not worthy of pick 3 or 4?? I'm happy with a potential superstar on our list it's been few and far between! I'd also like to add when he was being heavily pursued by AFC he chose the MFC in a show of faith I'd like to see that full filled as he appears to have done everything asked of him and no major injuries to change their mind.

[Hannibal 5,814]

I don't know why some flogs get concerned by where 'some' recruiters rate a player.

Fyfe was pick 20, but where would you have him now ? Beams was pick 29, but where would you have him now ? Hannebery was in the 30's, but where would you have him now ? Redden was in the 30's, but where would you have him now ? Shuey was 19, but where would you have him now ?

Yet dickwads argue over whether Viney is 6-10, or 5-15; and if he falls outside our range whether we'll say bye ? You're delusional. Viney will be at Melbourne next year no matter what pick we have to take him. And he's worth it. The guy is a leader, he's as manic as Joel Selwood, he hits targets, and despite the views of some fools he's quick. We're lucky he's ours - even if you don't recognise it.

Our first decent F/S since Barassi and supporters are happy to let him go. FM.

[Mad_Melbourne 872]

I don't know why some flogs get concerned by where 'some' recruiters rate a player.

Fyfe was pick 20, but where would you have him now ? Beams was pick 29, but where would you have him now ? Hannebery was in the 30's, but where would you have him now ? Redden was in the 30's, but where would you have him now ? Shuey was 19, but where would you have him now ?

Yet dickwads argue over whether Viney is 6-10, or 5-15; and if he falls outside our range whether we'll say bye ? You're delusional. Viney will be at Melbourne next year no matter what pick we have to take him. And he's worth it. The guy is a leader, he's as manic as Joel Selwood, he hits targets, and despite the views of some fools he's quick. We're lucky he's ours - even if you don't recognise it.

Our first decent F/S since Barassi and supporters are happy to let him go. FM.

I for one am not happy to let him go, but fact of the matter is if we have pick 3 and there are 3 players or more rated better than him we will not take him! He will be a second round pick because gws and GC would be silly to do anything otherwise

[bing181 8,165]

I don't know why some flogs get concerned by where 'some' recruiters rate a player.

Great post BH. Thanks.

[rpfc 27,451]

I don't know why some flogs get concerned by where 'some' recruiters rate a player.

Fyfe was pick 20, but where would you have him now ? Beams was pick 29, but where would you have him now ? Hannebery was in the 30's, but where would you have him now ? Redden was in the 30's, but where would you have him now ? Shuey was 19, but where would you have him now ?

Yet dickwads argue over whether Viney is 6-10, or 5-15; and if he falls outside our range whether we'll say bye ? You're delusional. Viney will be at Melbourne next year no matter what pick we have to take him. And he's worth it. The guy is a leader, he's as manic as Joel Selwood, he hits targets, and despite the views of some fools he's quick. We're lucky he's ours - even if you don't recognise it.

Our first decent F/S since Barassi and supporters are happy to let him go. FM.

I love this post, BH.

But let's not forget you were on the other side of this issue only a few months ago...

I understand where people are coming from, but you don't eff around with talents like Viney.

It will be a pleasure to watch this kid in a MFC jumper.

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,078]

ok so maybe i overstated categoric. But Melbourne will not use pick 3 or 4 for him

I know this is an incorrect statement and Ive heard this from people who know. Melbourne will not walk away from Viney and he is as good as ours. We are bluffing with the suggestion we wont use pick 3 for him if need be. We will because unlike all the other players in the draft he is already emotionally invested in the club and because unlike many he is a manchild and ready to play. More disposals than Moloney at Casey, etc.

We WILL use pick 3 to for VIney if forced and this is the one thing I can certain of. The basis of your statement is pick predictions (which would only be relevant if players careers were always ultimately dictated by pick placement which is flawed) and off-the-cuff statements from a few at the club that you have misread.

That being said using pick 3, we may not have to.

We CANT (how many times can it be said) use the Scully priority picks on a father/son. So no pick 4 possible. Its pick 3 or second round.

Any very ambigious statement about what MFC intend to do with picks in relation to Viney cannot be taken as catagorical primarily because there is bluff involved because we WANT him to slip through to second round. Hence the reason we did not even include his performance or stats on our website in relation to Casey.

Edited August 27, 2012 by Norm Smith's Curse

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,078]

I don't know why some flogs get concerned by where 'some' recruiters rate a player.

Fyfe was pick 20, but where would you have him now ? Beams was pick 29, but where would you have him now ? Hannebery was in the 30's, but where would you have him now ? Redden was in the 30's, but where would you have him now ? Shuey was 19, but where would you have him now ?

Yet dickwads argue over whether Viney is 6-10, or 5-15; and if he falls outside our range whether we'll say bye ? You're delusional. Viney will be at Melbourne next year no matter what pick we have to take him. And he's worth it. The guy is a leader, he's as manic as Joel Selwood, he hits targets, and despite the views of some fools he's quick. We're lucky he's ours - even if you don't recognise it.

Our first decent F/S since Barassi and supporters are happy to let him go. FM.

Thank god some people know what they are talking about! Phew!

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,078]

Personally, if we have to pick up Viney for a 1st round draft pick say pick 4 ish.. its not worth getting him at all.

I think he has potential to be a superstar but there are so many players that are just like him, especially because

this years draft is superdraft and i think that there could be 3 or 4 "vineys" and maybe even better than him.

For a second round pick it would be unbelievable to get Viney and 2 other picks at 3 and 4

That entire post is mind blowingly wrong... Name another player in the draft who is currently exceeding AFL players for disposals in the VFL?

We cant use pick 4 because its Scully compo and cant be used on father son

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

I don't know why some flogs get concerned by where 'some' recruiters rate a player.

Fyfe was pick 20, but where would you have him now ? Beams was pick 29, but where would you have him now ? Hannebery was in the 30's, but where would you have him now ? Redden was in the 30's, but where would you have him now ? Shuey was 19, but where would you have him now ?

Yet dickwads argue over whether Viney is 6-10, or 5-15; and if he falls outside our range whether we'll say bye ? You're delusional. Viney will be at Melbourne next year no matter what pick we have to take him. And he's worth it. The guy is a leader, he's as manic as Joel Selwood, he hits targets, and despite the views of some fools he's quick. We're lucky he's ours - even if you don't recognise it.

Our first decent F/S since Barassi and supporters are happy to let him go. FM.

Post of the year!

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,078]

I completely disagree. I am not sure if you have watched the TAC cup or not but Nathan Hvorat as an example shows more class than Viney and is very similar in the way they play just way more polished.

Viney is NOT in the top 5 players in this draft

Cale Morton looked great at similar levels.

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

Just get Viney. I don't give a stuff where just get him. Christ he is already playing well at VFL unlike bloody Cook. If he were to be at another club next year it would be damn hard for me to respect this club anymore.

Edited August 27, 2012 by cowboy_from_hell

[rjay 23,905]

Melbourne WILL NOT pick up Viney with pick 4.

It has been categorically said

We will pick him up with pick 3 I believe.

[Philthy 284]

FFS! How many other kids in this years draft (that twits on this forum rate higher than Viney) have been smashing it in the VFL??He is getting more possessions than Moloney (last years b&f) yet people are happy to let him go?

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

FFS! How many other kids in this years draft (that twits on this forum rate higher than Viney) have been smashing it in the VFL??He is getting more possessions than Moloney (last years b&f) yet people are happy to let him go?

How nice would it have been to see Cook,Bennell and Morton play VFL before the draft? You are exactly right the kid is playing well in the VFL so just bloody get him.

[Demon16 69]

i really don't think most people want to let him go, they just don't want to have to pay what he is worth. no other team has ever had to pay evens for a father/son, so it feels like we are getting shafted, in reality we're not.

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

i really don't think most people want to let him go, they just don't want to have to pay what he is worth. no other team has ever had to pay evens for a father/son, so it feels like we are getting shafted, in reality we're not.

Picking up a gun inside mid who is playing against experienced AFL players as a teenager is not getting shafted in my eyes. I don't care if we have to use a high pick on him. I will not feel shafted at all if viney is read out at pick 3. At least for once we can say in years to come we got a high pick right for once.

[Goodvibes 3,596]

I love the fact that our club is putting on a bit of a show, trying to create the illusion that we won't follow through on our promise to draft Jack and from what I've seen the only people who are starting to lose their nerve are MFC supporters. We will take him but we're going to bluff all the way to nomination day and hope that the recruiting departments of GWS and Gold Coast scare as easily as your average Demonland poster. If they do, we grab him in the second round and we have what will be viewed as a bonus early first rounder. If they hold their nerve and nominate him, we'll be spewing that we've missed out on another early selection but then we'll call his name and move on and be rapt that Jack Viney is at our club.

[Axis of Bob 10,218]

I love the fact that our club is putting on a bit of a show, trying to create the illusion that we won't follow through on our promise to draft Jack and from what I've seen the only people who are starting to lose their nerve are MFC supporters. We will take him but we're going to bluff all the way to nomination day and hope that the recruiting departments of GWS and Gold Coast scare as easily as your average Demonland poster. If they do, we grab him in the second round and we have what will be viewed as a bonus early first rounder. If they hold their nerve and nominate him, we'll be spewing that we've missed out on another early selection but then we'll call his name and move on and be rapt that Jack Viney is at our club.

Further to that, I think a large part of the show is to make it easier for us to do a deal with GWS/GC. Not so much for those clubs, but to make it look less like draft tampering to the AFL.

For example, it's easier for those clubs to pass on Viney under the false claim that they didn't want to risk it, and then do a deal with the MFC involving pick 3. If we came out and said that Viney is as good as ours with pick 3 then it would look pretty dodgy when GWS/GC passed on him and then did a deal with us.

[Goodvibes 3,596]

For example, it's easier for those clubs to pass on Viney under the false claim that they didn't want to risk it, and then do a deal with the MFC involving pick 3. If we came out and said that Viney is as good as ours with pick 3 then it would look pretty dodgy when GWS/GC passed on him and then did a deal with us.

If that's true Bob, we're putting way more thought into this than any zone, forward press or centre clearance tactic I've seen implemented on the field this year. Hope you're right but I get the feeling it's not that complicated.

[skills32 229]

Why are you guys repeating yourselves?

[s-t-i-n-g-a 439]

Why are you guys repeating yourselves?

[dee-luded 2,958]

Watched him in the national champs, and although effective at that level he won't have anywhere the AFL career of viney. He's a tiny bloke even in comparison to Viney and certainly doesn't have the stocky build of Jack. Plus Viney will bring along intangibles that many don't possess.

Although he may not be top 5 in terms of his skills set, his work ethic and hunger for the contest will spread through the playing group like wildfire which makes him deserving of a number 4 pick

OH, OK... So it is official then... We are going to trade our {Pick 3} to GWS now they are confirmed with the 1st pick...

So tell me, when is the club going to come onto these boards to do the "Sell" to the supporters to accept this deal.

You sound like your on the 'Inside'.

Personally, I think Grundy could be everything that Hogan can be to a forwardline.

So maybe we would be better off taking A Quickish Mid & Grundy with our first 2 picks,,,, use our Mid 1st Rnd for another quickish Mid, & if JV isn't there, use our 2nd Pick for another quality kid.

Then fight like Hell to bring Jack Back.

[dee-luded 2,958]

Provide some evidence you clown

I'm more than happy to be proven wrong, but even if he has said it I'm sure we can take it with a grain of salt due to the circumstances and would not be revealing of his true sentiments

I've got one for you, provide some Evidence that Viney is in the top 5 best in this Draft, "Clown" you sound very much like another postor who uses similar writing styles & putdowns to try to imply an inner strength & a valid argument.

And only 19 posts too.

Who's bidding are you doing?