Scully, Trengrove, Butcher, Ball

[DeeM 42]

I have found out today that, we are getting Scully and Trengrove 1+2, Melbourne think that Butcher will slide to 11 and the contract is nearly completed in regards to Ball.

[powser85 0]

how would u have found that out?

[Arem 0]

Change your username.

Scully and Trengrove have been locked in at 1 and 2 for weeks now, Butcher is going to Sydney or Port Adelaide, and Ball has no choice really... retire or play for Melbourne... I think he'll chose the latter. :D

[Deestroy All 14,262]

I hope Scully, Trengove Butcher Ball doesn't become a regular sentence.

[two sheds jackson 3]

I don't expect you to name your source, but can you at least provide some details about why Melbourne expect Butcher to slide to 11, and how we managed to convince Ball that we'd be a good option, just to show you're serious? I'd love to believe you obviously, but it's hard to take you seriously when all you've said is "this is definitely going to happen", without elaborating. You've got to give us something.

[deeflog 679]

more information if you have it M4B, or is there no more info?

[DeeM 42]

i knew this would come. a close friend of mine is on the Melbounrne list and he told me today.

I didnt ask details but melbourne thinks Butcher will slide, and Ball has many options.

[Hannabal 4]

i knew this would come. a close friend of mine is on the Melbounrne list and he told me today.

I didnt ask details but melbourne thinks Butcher will slide, and Ball has many options.

Firstly, I don't believe that a listed player would have access to that information, as BP doesn't even tell his own MFC scouts who he's going to take, and secondly, you said that a "contract was close for Ball" and now you say "he has many options", which is contradictory to the first statement - although true.

[DeeM 42]

Firstly, I don't believe that a listed player would have access to that information, as BP doesn't even tell his own MFC scouts who he's going to take, and secondly, you said that a "contract was close for Ball" and now you say "he has many options", which is contradictory to the first statement - although true.

Well Ball does have many options but im saying that we are very close to signing him.

And i didnt think listed players would know much about the draft, but when i asked him if there was any news that is what he said....you be the judge

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

I hope Scully, Trengove Butcher Ball doesn't become a regular sentence.

Some of your sharpest there DA.

[Hannabal 4]

Well Ball does have many options but im saying that we are very close to signing him.

And i didnt think listed players would know much about the draft, but when i asked him if there was any news that is what he said....you be the judge

Cale Morton said recently on MFC.com (I think) that the players keep a close eye on what is going on in the draft. I believe that the player you talked to is simply speculating and mentioning the two prominent names that the whole footy community is discussing. And yes, it has also been discussed that Butcher may slide.

Thanks for sharing your conversation, but I don't believe that it sheds any new light.

[jabberwocky 2,301]

Well Ball does have many options but im saying that we are very close to signing him.

And i didnt think listed players would know much about the draft, but when i asked him if there was any news that is what he said....you be the judge

Being pedantic....how can you sign him? I can understand the organising of details of a contract. I don't understand how you could sign someone without drafting them first

[Redleg 37,763]

Being pedantic....how can you sign him? I can understand the organising of details of a contract. I don't understand how you could sign someone without drafting them first

In this case you can. He agrees to go into PSD and we have first pick and we agree to pick him.

We can even advise the AFL of this and he can get permission to train with us before the PSD.

Edited October 17, 2009 by Redleg

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Being pedantic....how can you sign him? I can understand the organising of details of a contract. I don't understand how you could sign someone without drafting them first

probably just means he is close to fleshing out the deal we are proposing and, once he's happy with it, nominating in the PSD

please be true

[Arem 0]

and Ball has many options.

re-sign with St Kilda - no, retire - no, enter the ND and risk ending up anywhere in the country - no, this leaves one option and the only realistic option. I claim no insider information but am 99% certain he will be in the red and blue next year.

[Guest Rojik of the Arctic]

I have found out today that, we are getting Scully and Trengrove 1+2, Melbourne think that Butcher will slide to 11 and the contract is nearly completed in regards to Ball.

Sort of interesting but pretty vague and not really anything to get too excited about. Scully and Trengove look like a lock anyway, Butcher sliding is a "maybe" at best and out of our control and the Ball bit just sounds like we are at least having our offer listened to - which while nice - isn't anything concrete.

[thebigdemon 0]

I have found out today that, we are getting Scully and Trengrove 1+2, Melbourne think that Butcher will slide to 11 and the contract is nearly completed in regards to Ball.

Dont be suprised if Melbourne take Griffiths over Butcher with pick 11. I think the top two look pretty set but Griffiths looks like he has a lot of up side and can kick the ball a mile. If Port dont take Griffiths at 8 or 9 im sure Melbourne will pounce.

[Viney Vidi Vici 110]

except Griffiths is injury prone... might throw them off. don't know how bad though.

[Deeman 1,403]

My mother always told me not to count my Balls before they hatched and I've always considered that to be sage advice.

I won't believe the Luke Ball story until I see him in red and blue. I think ATM he would still be even money about Ball remaining a Saint.

[Supermercado 2,617]

It's bizarre how many people think we'd pick Ball if he told us he didn't want to play for us.

[H_T 2,941]

I hope Scully, Trengove Butcher Ball doesn't become a regular sentence.

Haha.

It's all hearsay, I don't believe there is anything new here.

Edited October 17, 2009 by High Tower

[Jack7 463]

Butch won't slide to 11,he has far too much upside-great lead,pack mark,huge tank.His kicking will improve at AFL level,if he does nothing but kick all preseason,he'll improve out of sight,he's extremely good at every other part of his game.

He'll never kick like Fev or Lloyd but Rewoldt has struggled for years and improved greatly this year.Look at Richo,struggled his whole career and has still kicked 800+ goals.

Just a shame we won't draft him.I expect him to go 5-8.

[thebigdemon 0]

except Griffiths is injury prone... might throw them off. don't know how bad though.

Yeah I heard that too. But if he does a couple of full pre seasons he could be something special. Great physique. Big tall and strong. We'll have to wait and see I guess. I think Port might be keen at 8 or 9. Not many talls in this draft by the sounds of it.

[Guest hangon007]

Yeah I heard that too. But if he does a couple of full pre seasons he could be something special. Great physique. Big tall and strong. We'll have to wait and see I guess. I think Port might be keen at 8 or 9. Not many talls in this draft by the sounds of it.

Think they are into young Jordan Gysberts aswell ... However, heard from a reliable source Port complained about how the Eastern Rangers kids lacked preparation for their interviews.

[Redleg 37,763]

Think they are into young Jordan Gysberts aswell ... However, heard from a reliable source Port complained about how the Eastern Rangers kids lacked preparation for their interviews.

You wouldn't hold that against them.