Brendan Fevola

[Akum 2,660]

effectively McLean + Henderson for Fev + 27 - good work!

You mean for Fev + 11 + 27

[titan_uranus 22,979]

You mean for Fev + 11 + 27

Yes, but Carlton gets 12 from Brisbane. I think old55 was saying that effectively 11 and 12 are very similar, so you can ignore those, and you're left with Fev + 27 for Henderson + McLean.

[Disco Demons 92]

poor daniel rich and simon black...no options up forward at all...

i think i said it in an earlier post...but who's going to play on brown, bradshaw and fev...???

voss has won a brownlow...and three premierships...coached a side to the finals...now he's added a coleman medalist to his playing list...he's been extremely active in trade week...what can't voss do?

Voss now has potential to become one of the greatest captain coaches of all time now...

[Armitage Shanks 0]

Carlton have been royally pantsed in this trade....

Traded a 70+ a year goalkicker in his prime for an unproven 19 year old and pick 12.

I don't really care but i am just glad he didn't get to Collingwood.

Carlton cannot and will not make finals next year.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Voss now has potential to become one of the greatest captain coaches of all time now...

Hyperbole and only 3 to 4 premierships short of Barassi, Smith and Matthews

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Carlton cannot and will not make finals next year.

So we can take that as a given. Thanks

[Keyser Söze 0]

Carlton have been royally pantsed in this trade....

Traded a 70+ a year goalkicker in his prime for an unproven 19 year old and pick 12.

I don't really care but i am just glad he didn't get to Collingwood.

Carlton cannot and will not make finals next year.

???????

Carlton are big winners - they get a good young CHF who has been forced to play CHB for most of his short career AND a 1st round pick for a Basket Case they could not offload to any other team.

This deal is far far better than Bradshaw & Rischitelli

I just wonder how much of his salary the blues have had to pay to get this deal done...

Edited October 9, 2009 by Keyser Söze

[Armitage Shanks 0]

Well when that said pick 12 and Lachie "Never heard of him" Henderson kick 70+ between them next year i will agree with you.

[Keyser Söze 0]

Well when that said pick 12 and Lachie "Never heard of him" Henderson kick 70+ between them next year i will agree with you.

just because you're ignorant of Henderson doesn't mean he's not good.

And he has a lot more years in him to come than Fevola

Remains to be seen how Fev performs in an attack where he is not the sole main focus... will he become the same old petulant brat when others are kicking goals but he can't get a touch?

Don't take 70 goals as a given. This could just as easily implode.

[Guest The Old Xaverian]

Carlton got bent over bigtime.

[Armitage Shanks 0]

Carlton got bent over bigtime.

Agreed.

[Keyser Söze 0]

Carlton got bent over bigtime.

Carton should've been happy to get bent over bigtime to rid themselves of the Fev

Considering alternative possible endings to trade week for them, I'd say this is one of the best they could've hoped for

[H_T 2,941]

Carlton got bent over bigtime.

Pies going to trade Davis? Or what?

[beelzebub 22,671]

I wonder what odds I can get for Lions in the 8 or top 4 for that matter

Edited October 9, 2009 by belzebub59

[Dr Jekyl & Mr Hyde 0]

Carlton are going to on trade Pick #12 for Andrejs Everitt from the Western Bulldogs.

[rpfc 27,664]

Pies going to trade Davis? Or what?

Don't engage.

Just look blankly, and sidle on by.

[H_T 2,941]

Carlton are going to on trade Pick #12 for Andrejs Everitt from the Western Bulldogs.

Bulldogs will think it's Christmas.

[Jaded No More 59,569]

This is potentially a very very good deal for Carlton, depending on what they get with pick 12 and how both kids develop.

Voss clearly has both eyes on the premiership!

[Dr Jekyl & Mr Hyde 0]

I don't see how people can think Carlton have been bent over?

Fact: Carlton have traded off a problem child who was holding their side back (believe or or not) for a first round selection (Pick #12), and KPP Pick #8 from the 2007 Draft.

Fact: After his antics at the Brownlow, Carlton were prepared to delist Fevola.

Fact: Lachlan Henderson is 19 years old and was touted as Browns replacement at Brisbane - he is exactly the type of player Carlton would have been hoping to draft this year.

Fact: Carlton only have to pay $200k of Fevs Salary this season.

Fact: Carlton are now back in the first round again to either on trade that pick or utilize it in November.

Edited October 9, 2009 by Dr Jekyl & Mr Hyde

[Keyser Söze 0]

I don't see how people can think Carlton have been bent over?

Fact: Carlton have traded off a problem child who was holding their side back (believe or or not) for a first round selection (Pick #12), and KPP Pick #8 from the 2007 Draft.

Fact: After his antics at the Brownlow, Carlton were prepared to delist Fevola.

Fact: Lachlan Henderson is 19 years old and was touted as Browns replacement at Brisbane - he is exactly the type of player Carlton would have been hoping to draft this year.

Fact: Carlton only have to pay $200k of Fevs Salary this season.

Fact: Carlton are now back in the first round again to either on trade that pick or utilize it in November.

I 100% agree.

[Dr Jekyl & Mr Hyde 0]

Sorry guys I got it wrong.

Carlton threw Pick #27 into the trade with the Lions to ensure that they pay 0% of Fevolas Salary.

Another tick for them.

They now have $1.4 Million to move in the cap and attract other players.

[Keyser Söze 0]

Sorry guys I got it wrong.

Carlton threw Pick #27 into the trade with the Lions to ensure that they pay 0% of Fevolas Salary.

Another tick for them.

They now have $1.4 Million to move in the cap and attract other players.

0% ????????

WOW. Carlton are the big winners in trade week if they have pulled that off

[DemonDave 1,078]

Fact: Carlton only have to pay $200k of Fevs Salary this season.

You were personally involved in the contract negotiations? How could you possibly know this as fact??

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Well when that said pick 12 and Lachie "Never heard of him" Henderson kick 70+ between them next year i will agree with you.

And when Fev could have stayed and punched the lights out of every other senior player at Carlton and still kick his 70+ goals, Carlton would have been cherry ripe indeed.

Carlton got bent over bigtime.

They already were bent over with Fev.

They have come out of a bad dysfunctional situation reasonably well.

I don't see how people can think Carlton have been bent over?

Fact: Carlton have traded off a problem child who was holding their side back (believe or or not) for a first round selection (Pick #12), and KPP Pick #8 from the 2007 Draft.

Fact: After his antics at the Brownlow, Carlton were prepared to delist Fevola.

Fact: Lachlan Henderson is 19 years old and was touted as Browns replacement at Brisbane - he is exactly the type of player Carlton would have been hoping to draft this year.

Fact: Carlton only have to pay $200k of Fevs Salary this season.

Fact: Carlton are now back in the first round again to either on trade that pick or utilize it in November.

Absolutely

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Carlton threw Pick #27 into the trade with the Lions to ensure that they pay 0% of Fevolas Salary.

Another tick for them.

They now have $1.4 Million to move in the cap and attract other players.

If that is so, then that is a very good outcome indeed.